Large Normal 232—Sibyl's Elegy [GAME OVER]

[Anastasia]

Finally i voted 2 scums (t3 and bloodhail), and i told you the whole first day we should elim kitty.
Im not so bad.

you are the best!

[Nero Cain]

enchant was pretty obvious scum. I was rather worried early game b/c I thought there was a good chance they could be flipped.

[The Bulge]

Mod PT ::

[Andresvmb]

enchant was pretty obvious scum. I was rather worried early game b/c I thought there was a good chance they could be flipped.

You were obvious Scum and we didn’t flip you.

[bloodhail]

enchant was pretty obvious scum. I was rather worried early game b/c I thought there was a good chance they could be flipped.

was fairly stunned at the reads on him, my goal in the later days was to be a big loud distraction so people wouldn't look in his direction

[samantha97]

enchant was bussing t3 and kitty, and t3 was bussing enchant, + gunsmith clear on nero after a flipped traitor...

mafia played well plus the way events shook out we were mechanically screwed on top of it

[Nero Cain]

I have no redactions.

[Andresvmb]

enchant was bussing t3 and kitty, and t3 was bussing enchant, + gunsmith clear on nero after a flipped traitor...

mafia played well plus the way events shook out we were mechanically screwed on top of it

You are defending terrible play to make yourself feel better. If we lose to KittyTacky towards the end there fine. We executed Vasex over bloodhail who was screaming Scum, for no good reason at all. And we also ran through two counter wagons of Town. The mechanical solve was just bad luck, but I am still shocked at how bad we played here.

[DrippingGoofball]

Thank you Bulger, and good game scum team!

[Dunnstral]

I have no redactions.

[bloodhail]

actually the d1 was kind of a disaster lmao everyone was getting run up, t3's first vote was on his teammate for absolutely no good reason, i just went with the flow and tried to recover afterwards

[Andresvmb]

Scum Team played well not to execute the Traitors, but beyond that the Town did the job for them. I just... I don’t know I need to stop getting so emotionally invested.

[Nero Cain]

3's first vote was on his teammate for absolutely no good reason

distancing

[The Bulge]

Neighbourhood ::

[Andresvmb]

actually the d1 was kind of a disaster lmao everyone was getting run up, t3's first vote was on his teammate for absolutely no good reason, i just went with the flow and tried to recover afterwards

I highlighted that the game was on a good course towards the beginning. But D3 onwards was a demonstration on how to completely shit the bed from a winning position.

[bloodhail]

I have about 4 scumreads

who

(T3, Nero Cain, Rathe, deep-city-lights)

Deep-city-lights weakest of the bunch

You scumread DCL after 3 RVS posts?
VOTE: Etine

VOTE: deep-city-lights

Explajn?

T3 also blatantly chainsaw defended my slot lmao

thank god the game was a massive spamfest so no one actually reread

[Kerset]

So this setup had
Miller with no corresponding town cop
Only one TI - half Gunsmith, who had two false innos and one false guilty.
Neighborhood with only scum in it - almost bastard mechanic

Idk who thought that town may win this.

[Andresvmb]

Neighborhood with only scum in it - almost bastard mechanic

This has been used multiple times in different games. It’s definitely not bastard.

[Kerset]

and this is large where vig is not insta confirmed bc of SK possibility

[bloodhail]

actually the d1 was kind of a disaster lmao everyone was getting run up, t3's first vote was on his teammate for absolutely no good reason, i just went with the flow and tried to recover afterwards

I highlighted that the game was on a good course towards the beginning. But D3 onwards was a demonstration on how to completely shit the bed from a winning position.

ye mass claim was completely unnecessary and antitown, maybe we kill rathe anyway that night but he guaranteed his death 100% with no second report for not much gain

[Nero Cain]

I mean a 3 shot vig could theoretically wreck the scum team. It's like a super aggressive cop that shoots b4 it gets a result.

[Andresvmb]

I don’t know there are games were I really feel the mechanics screwed us. I really don’t see that here. We need to be more self-critical. We incorrectly cleared Enchant and that started becoming transparent as the game progressed and we did nothing about it. KittyTacky was Scum and Vasex’s head was probably exploding pushing for that slot as Scum which we also incorrectly cleared. And it’s funny because it was literally a PR Claim I’ve seen Scum make. And the rest just played Scummy I mean we at different times named all of them as Scum.

What did we do instead? We blew through consecutive Town players we really shouldn’t have and we kept listening to Scum for I don’t know what reason.

[Anastasia]

pretty sure we lost this on day play alone :3

[The Bulge]

So this setup had
Miller with no corresponding town cop
Only one TI - half Gunsmith, who had two false innos and one false guilty.
Neighborhood with only scum in it - almost bastard mechanic

Idk who thought that town may win this.

Town also had up to 4 night kills and 2 protectives + bulletproof. The traitors could also have been nightkilled by either side.
Simple Fruit Vendor is a town investigative. Babysitter and Jailkeeper both have quasi-investigative potential.
Plus the Universal Backup.
The miller messes with the Mafia Cop.
There is nothing bastard about having 2 traitors. There is nothing bastard about putting 2 players of any alignment together in a neighbourhood. There is nothing that states that multiple traitors should be aware of each others identities. Which, mind you, is another innate advantage for the town—not only was the scumteam disjointed due to the traitor, but doubly so due to the traitors' own dilemma.
The setup is balanced.

[Nero Cain]

most ppl were town reading me early on. I know you'll disagree but I really feel like the only reason you really really thought I was scum b/c I was fake pushing on you.