saying that his play there is "scum piggybacking off a player's read" is a narrative in which he's scum, but not anIn post 1421, nomnomnom wrote:I'm not in his mind so I can't say for sure but the fact that he has voted there after quoting a jjh post makes me think that scum!him could just be piggybacking off a player's read, and as I said, Cyrus is that kind of player who will attract votes entirely on play and posting style so it's an easy vote to make. Certainly easier than voting jjh here I'd say.
Do you think he's town?
If you do, you have a version of your game that has jjh/moon/nk all as town, so I would be curious as to where you think the scum would be in a world where that is the case
pedit: I've thought numerous times that it could simply be that moon is exhibiting some classic town read shift but what makes me unsure is his insistence on avoiding the question altogether. In my mind if he's town he would have no trouble telling me something he told norwee? Instead he went on a tirade about how unfun I am to play against when I was simply asking questions, so basically the question in my mind really is "would town!moon be this annoyed by me right about now?"
explanation
for why
he chose to do that instead of voting his counterwagon. jjh is almost assuredly town, i think, and i'm leaning towards moon and NK both being town. scum is primarily in you right now i think, but in general i get the feeling that scum just aren't doing much in this gamestate.
But instead of trying to convince you I'll ask you this: in a world where all 4 of NK/Moon/JJH/Me are town, where is the scum?
