Mini Normal 2216 | Screaming | Post-game!

[Seanzie]

I have no idea why the text on my most recent post showed up so small. I am asking ssbm_Kyouko "Do you think Boxxy will flip mafia or town?".

[ssbm_Kyouko]

I have no idea why the text on my most recent post showed up so small. I am asking ssbm_Kyouko "Do you think Boxxy will flip mafia or town?".

Town

Spoiler:

I think it's something to do with spoiler tags because when I tried to quote 499 for my response, my response was formatted like your question was.

[Seanzie]

I have no idea why the text on my most recent post showed up so small. I am asking ssbm_Kyouko "Do you think Boxxy will flip mafia or town?".

Town

Spoiler:

I think it's something to do with spoiler tags because when I tried to quote 499 for my response, my response was formatted like your question was.

I think we are at the verge of hammering Boxxy. If you have anything to say in their defense, can you share?

[MaxTheFox]

Possibly unpopular opinion. Cyrus is town. Read only the first few pages though, still reading.

[humaneatingmonkey]

Interesting interesting

[humaneatingmonkey]

Good night guys

[ssbm_Kyouko]

I have no idea why the text on my most recent post showed up so small. I am asking ssbm_Kyouko "Do you think Boxxy will flip mafia or town?".

Town

Spoiler:

I think it's something to do with spoiler tags because when I tried to quote 499 for my response, my response was formatted like your question was.

I think we are at the verge of hammering Boxxy. If you have anything to say in their defense, can you share?

We are not at the verge of hammering boxxy as they have claimed PR

[humaneatingmonkey]

how do you see that playing out, bdsm?

[Dwlee99]

If that's real that sounds like a good role so
UNVOTE:
at least for now but probably for longer.

[Dwlee99]

you think someone would do that? go in a mafia game and lie?

this is unthinkable

I'm reading this as soon as I wake up and it's so funny in this mental state

[MaxTheFox]

Let's not vote PR claims day 1.

[MaxTheFox]

The risk is too big.

[Dwlee99]

Max do you have more thoughtsTM? Have you caught up?

[nomnomnom]

Are we really doing this?
People just instantly unvoting because someone claims PR like that and they just buy it?

[Salsabil Faria]

UNVOTE: boxxy

It's not about buying or not buying, fmpov it will be a good play if we don't eliminate pr, especially on Day in 1. If he is truly a TPR than he should be the nk tomorrow. But if he will alive on Day 2, then he will have some explanations to do.

[nomnomnom]

Roaming Detective is one of these roles that sounds good on paper but is an extremely weak role.
And now that it is claimed you can be sure it will be 100% a useless role, so scum can easily claim that role and wifom the hell out of town, so I don't buy it.

[nomnomnom]

I've been burnt enough by scums claiming PR on day 1 after a successful push to think that the line of "let's not lynch a claimed PR day 1 guys" is a bad one.
I don't buy the claim and it's the kind of role you can claim and then use to WIFOM all game as scum.

[Salsabil Faria]

Btw, I'm busy rn, will post in details later. But

cyrus62

still doesn’t reply my question on 221 (while being on the phone and replying others but keeps ignoring me) which is very scummy. I still think

Seanzie

and him aren’t TvT, interaction between them seems genuine, not performative.

VOTE: cyrus62

[nomnomnom]

Let's suppose boxxy really is a town roaming det. Now the scums know that there is a roaming det. If that is the case, town!boxxy at most only gets one guilty, and that's the best case scenario.
I have absolutely no problem lynching this claim on day 1 with this in mind, because it's way more likely that boxxy claimed this role as scum with the intent of going full WIFOM on town by claiming non-guilties all game long, and that info says absolutely no info on the scumteam as well.

[Salsabil Faria]

I've been burnt enough by scums claiming PR on day 1 after a successful push to think that the line of "let's not lynch a claimed PR day 1 guys" is a bad one.
I don't buy the claim and it's the kind of role you can claim and then use to WIFOM all game as scum.

I know and also have experience about that... My point is there are 3 scums and we have time to hunt the other two. If we leave the pr claim today, he definitely have to show us the night result in Day 2 if he will still alive with claiming pr.

[Salsabil Faria]

Let's suppose boxxy really is a town roaming det. Now the scums know that there is a roaming det. If that is the case, town!boxxy at most only gets one guilty, and that's the best case scenario.
I have absolutely no problem lynching this claim on day 1 with this in mind, because it's way more likely that boxxy claimed this role as scum with the intent of going full WIFOM on town by claiming non-guilties all game long, and that info says absolutely no info on the scumteam as well.

We can eliminate him on Day 2 if that happens. I mainly want to what scum do with the claim.

[Salsabil Faria]

Let's suppose boxxy really is a town roaming det. Now the scums know that there is a roaming det. If that is the case, town!boxxy at most only gets one guilty, and that's the best case scenario.
I have absolutely no problem lynching this claim on day 1 with this in mind, because it's way more likely that boxxy claimed this role as scum with the intent of going full WIFOM on town by claiming non-guilties all game long, and that info says absolutely no info on the scumteam as well.

We can eliminate him on Day 2 if that happens. I mainly want to what scum do with the claim.

want to see*

[nomnomnom]

If we leave the pr claim today, he definitely have to show us the night result in Day 2 if he will still alive with claiming pr.

And as I said this result will be completely useless unless
1) He really is town
2) He somehow managed to invest the player making the nightkill
3) the moment he announces he visited a member of the scumteam with a fake guilty that player is free to perform nightkills without ever being found guilty
This is the perfect kind of role for scum to claim because you can spend all your game faking garbage results and WIFOMing about scums not NKing you because of these parameters.
I don't buy the claim and boxxy is still scummy as fuck.
pedit: detective doesn't clear anyone, why would scums actually perform a nightkill there? Tell me

[MaxTheFox]

Max do you have more thoughtsTM? Have you caught up?

I was AFK for a while. But basically I skimmed the thread. Early Cyrus vs nomnomnom is TvT I think.

Maybe because I wasn't interacting with the thread early it's hard for me to form opinions.

[MaxTheFox]

The risk is too big.

Maybe because in my first game someone hinted at PR and town hung them and was on the verge of losing all game.