Dogs vs Cats Mafia Spectator/Dead thread

[Thestatusquo]

being readable is bad, actually.

[Jingle]

being readable is bad, actually.

^

Saying someone is obvious as town is inherently saying they have a shitty scum game.

[Nero Cain]

<---has most obvious meta, still gets scum read

[Isis]

I always make myself as readable as possible as town and as unreadable as possible as scum.

[Thestatusquo]

I dont think that works out favorably for your scum game.

[Firebringer]

Nor ur town game

[Isis]

I dont think that works out favorably for your scum game.

It does not, but tanking a town game you are currently playing so that you can win a scumgame in the future breaks mafia rule 9, the way I've always interpreted it.

[Jingle]

It does not, but tanking a town game you are currently playing so that you can win a scumgame in the future breaks mafia rule 9, the way I've always interpreted it.

I agree. You should argue that you're completely readable and obvious town as both alignments. The trick is to get people to think there's a stark difference between your games when there really isn't. I have not yet figured out how to do the second half, so if anyone knows how, I'd like to know.

[Thestatusquo]

I dont think that works out favorably for your scum game.

It does not, but tanking a town game you are currently playing so that you can win a scumgame in the future breaks mafia rule 9, the way I've always interpreted it.

It's tricky because being super readable when town but not Scum kind of breaks that rule in the other direction.

I think there's a ton of players on the site these days who only care about being town read as town and basically cannibalize their whole scum game to accomplish that.

[Chara]

i have no idea how one would strike that balance. i guess the ideal is a player who you know has a good scumgame but you're pretty is town

this

game. and in this scenario that's good play regardless of what that player's alignment is.

[Chara]

*pretty sure is town.

[Isis]

I dont think that works out favorably for your scum game.

It does not, but tanking a town game you are currently playing so that you can win a scumgame in the future breaks mafia rule 9, the way I've always interpreted it.

It's tricky because being super readable when town but not Scum kind of breaks that rule in the other direction.

I think there's a ton of players on the site these days who only care about being town read as town and basically cannibalize their whole scum game to accomplish that.

You shouldnt think about sets of games when you play, just play the current game to win.

I think there is a trend of people playing to the concept of getting townread as town is a subgoal that should always be doable and then they roll scum and don't care about getting townread in the same way and it's kind of a apathetic fractional trust tell yeah.

[Isis]

I always care more about getting townread as scum because I think it matters more for wincon.

[Chara]

i care about getting townread as both alignments, as town it's so i don't become a miselim/forced to claim as a PR. but i know i go about it differently.

[Thestatusquo]

Everyone welcome pooky, StD and Shiro.

[Farkran]

Lol cats and dogs fight each other

Also pooky was obvcat HI POOKY

[Thestatusquo]

Spoiler: remaining scum number spoilers

Cats are all gone now. 1 Dog and 2 Rats remain.

[MURDERCAT]

Hey friends

[Dwlee99]

Welcome to the show

[Thestatusquo]

If town elims correctly today they still have a shot despite 4 miselims.

[Chara]

hello Pooky!

i think it's a rat win.

[Thestatusquo]

I'm enjoying watching town try to parse the NK data because honestly its just pure happenstance that it hasn't been 3 kills most nights.

[MURDERCAT]

Yeah that was definitely confusing

[Isis]

I really dislike this type of game. I think I wouldn't join another like this even if shea was modding unless MURDERCAT convinced me again

[Thestatusquo]

When you say this type of game what do you mean out of curiosity.