Newbie 2064 - (GG)

[Zyla]

Nice! It's always cool when you meet good people through forums

gg all. I guess I'm kind of bad at reading people.

See, you say this, but you targeted Scum n1! If HEM had targeted anyone else, that would've made for a really easy case against them, so gg on that one!

[Noraa]

Noraa, your PT is beautiful, I'm enjoying reading it
(idk why stream of consciousness is so fun to read)

Honestly, I was mostly surprised that Unwnd seemed so defeated when we were close to winning, I was pretty sure that Unwnd was town until that point, due to the fact that my predecessor jailed that slot, so if it weren't for that I probably wouldn't have realized Unwnd was scum

haha thank you

[Noraa]

OMG CABD EDITED MY POST IN MY PT
YET ANOTHER CRIME
WHERE IS THE GREEN PENGUIN I CALL UNFAIRRRR

[catboi]

gg all. I guess I'm kind of bad at reading people.

Everyone is, but you get a little better with experience. Don't sweat being wrong when you're new. I hope I didn't put you off with my questioning, I only wanted to get you to think critically about thelogic behind your scumread of me - I think your impulse for suspecting me was entirely understandable but you didn't really seem to have considered worlds where I was town, and that type of thinking can lead to tunneling.


It was unfortunate the game had to deal with so many replacements, I was hoping to give the game some life and then half the players subbed out after me. >_> Big thanks to Super, Zyla, and Noraa for picking up the slack and closing this game out!

I was reasonably confident HEM was teamed with orctin but didn't want to force myself to fight him after I replaced in because that read was going to be a pain inthe butt to sell people on compared to orctin. There were a lot of posts that I thought made them an extremely obvious team, but at the same time I was telling people not to go crazy with pre-flip associatives - that's normally the right idea, and I want to encourage new players to think more in terms of looking for people who are individually scummy rather than trying to find the exact team during the day. Still, I immediately regretted not fleshing out my suspicion and leaving behind a clear legacy before the day ended as things looked murky for a bit on day 3. That's a lesson for me, I suppose.

I hope the high number of replacements didn't turn off the people who played in this game! I did enjoy all the newbies I had a chance to read, and I hope you'll stick around. I swear most games aren't this bad in terms of replacements. In particular, I thought James and navigatorv were great and showed an impressive level of effort for newer players. I hope navigator is doing all right and that they come back when their schedule clears up.

[Noraa]

I just want to say that I feel absolutely betrayed that Johnnyfarrar died before I got here.
HMPH
*kik*
And also you Jacko HMPH you better haz a good reason!!!!!!!!!!!!
*pout*

[unwnd]

I for one was holding out hope that unwnd could pull it off when Super decided the argument was so utterly convincing that hammering herself was the only path forward to break the 2-2 tie.

It wasn't the game for tryhard scum unwnd

GG

[NinjaStore]

gg all. I guess I'm kind of bad at reading people.

Everyone is, but you get a little better with experience. Don't sweat being wrong when you're new. I hope I didn't put you off with my questioning, I only wanted to get you to think critically about thelogic behind your scumread of me - I think your impulse for suspecting me was entirely understandable but you didn't really seem to have considered worlds where I was town, and that type of thinking can lead to tunneling.

I was criticized in a previous game offsite for changing my reads instead of just picking one and sticking to it. In this game, I had a tough time following everything all at once so I just focused on a few specific details that stood out when I was reading through the thread, and hoped I was finding stuff others were overlooking.

[Noraa]

OMG THAT NEW NEWBIE GAME
SEs: Me, Bulge, Catboi, Ita
BOMBBBBBBBBBBB

[JamesTheNames]

James no offence but why are you townreading the scummiestcplayer of the day and voting me lmao?

I just wanted to double check your reaction to it.

[humaneatingmonkey]

Sorry I had to replace out. Need to focus for an entire week.

Noraa, do we know each other? You mentioned you always scumread me

[JacksonVirgo]

Nice

[JamesTheNames]

Nice

Thank you for playing while you did.

[JacksonVirgo]

Nice

Thank you for playing while you did.

No problem, I had to replace out to focus on personal things.

[Noraa]

Sorry I had to replace out. Need to focus for an entire week.

Noraa, do we know each other? You mentioned you always scumread me

I've certainly seen you around. Whether or not I've played with you on this account idk.

[Noraa]

Nice

Thank you for playing while you did.

No problem, I had to replace out to focus on personal things.

<33333 fiiine
OK WHERE IS MON NOW
how dare he be night killed!
unacceptable.

[Micc]

thanks all for the game and to cabd for moderating.

Sorry for replacing out. Every once in a while I forget that I don't like playing mafia and decide to try it again. Fascinating game to study and I love teaching it to the extent I'm able, but man I hate playing.

[Noraa]

Omg your reads are so good. I'm a big fan >.<

[Noraa]

you remind me of clidd!!!!

[navigatorv]

Hey all, sorry for replacing out, the constant subouts just made things too hard to follow lmao hope everyone had fun, thanks for hosting Cabd! ^^

[catboi]

Hey all, sorry for replacing out, the constant subouts just made things too hard to follow lmao hope everyone had fun, thanks for hosting Cabd! ^^

Sorry you had such a difficult experience for your first game, I do hope you give things another try, I swear most games aren't this bad in terms of replacements. I was really impressed with your play, especially for someone totally new to forum mafia and had been looking forward to working with you.

[navigatorv]

Oh yeah, once life's a little less hectic for me I'll give it another go. I appreciate what you said and hope we can play properly someday ^^

[PenguinPower]