In post 1677, boxxy wrote:@Almost50 what of this case do you disagree with?In post 1663, humaneatingmonkey wrote:@boxxyIn post 1658, boxxy wrote:@monkey can you explain calmly and early why you had me essentially locked scum day1 and day 2
A. bad progression
A1. focusing on anti-town elims instead of scumreads (even though you make a fuss about "noise on scumhunting")
A2. calling me scum and pushing for my elimination for garbage posting and then giving me a townlean for more garbage posts
A3. recanting that you thought i was scum and were actually pushing for my elimination
A4. calling Seanzie dishonest (shading) and then voting nomnomnom for anti-town scumhunting methods
A5. voting nomnomnom for anti-town scumhunting methods (as she pushes for cyrus), instead of cyrus (who nomnomnom pushes) who you actually scumread
B. bad reaction to pressure
B1. dismisses my push by painting me as stupid
B2. claims an investigative role that vaguely gives any clearance to slots
B3. unable to explain what a detective is
B4. TMIs that I'm town in the statement "your trash play cost us the game"
B5. goes straight to AtE and basically gives up trying to solve the game
B6. dismisses my posts as "filler"
C. roleclaim
C1. still alive in N1
C2. checked Seanzie, his townread, but not nomnomnom or HEM or anyone else who he still suspected
D. mechanical
D1. flip will confirm Salsabil
D2. eliminate wifom
D3. gives a lot of associative reads
The reason why I slowed down today and I want to get an in-depth read of every slot is that there's a very good chance that you're still scum here and I want to have the freedom to eliminate you Day 4. But that means I have to nail scum today. I'm treating this day as MELO. I think I have 33% if not 66% chance of doing that with {Max The Fox, Almost50, and Bambi Jay}.
OUCH! A call for me to effort while watching a soccer game isn't cool, bro.
OK, let me see..
A. I didn't see any bad progression from you. I even agreed with your reads, and especially the one on HEM at the time. Since I ended up thinking the solve was cyrus/HEM/nom I wouldn't have seen your vote on Nom or your push on HEM as "alarming" AT ALL.
B. I didn't see "bad reaction to pressure" either. As I was TRing you already, and I was SRing your push targets I naturally thought you were doing some good work and agreed to your views and arguments in general. I pribably would have behaved the same if I was in your shoes.
ASLO (B) The claim came out naturally and felt genuine to me, and -as I said- I thought (and still do) Scum could not have faked that Role (and especially the Modifier). I don't even understand HEM's B2 because it is what it is. The Setup Designers decided to use that role, so what else could you have done?
Note: I also can see HEM's PoV now that I see he's likely Town. I mean, it was a wrong PoV but easily coming from a player who knows his own alignment and expected something that doesn't actually concur with this setup. Like, I've once been eliminated as a Simple FV by a Complex FV who thought the two could not have been included in the same setup, so he faked a guilty on me (actually faked having received Fruit from me) and Scum made the best of it to eliminate me on that day and eliminate him the next. Town players are usually stupid and tunneled (myself included)
C. Roleclaim: I disagree with the first part (still alive) because I can see Scum trying to eliminate someone they thought was more dangerous if they expected you to check the one that didn't do the kill. (In fact, it would probably have been my plan to keep you alive until you've cleared the scum that isn't doing the kills)
The second part I do agree with and have voiced that out at the time. I thought the check on Seanzie was a bad choice and I said I would have checked Nom myself.
D. Mechanically speaking; HEN's argument here make sense, but I'd say it was immature/preemptive (Listen.. English isn't my 1st language and I am preoccupied so.. what I mean is it "came too early". I would have felt better about it if it came after you have produced 2-3 results, because one result could have still hit the scum that didn't kill on N1 anywa so one result means shit)