Dogs vs Cats Mafia Spectator/Dead thread

[SirCakez]

A town win after five straight mislims would be disgusting, definitely

[SirCakez]

Especially in a game where literally 1/3 of the players were scum...

[Thestatusquo]

If town had elimmed BHL yesterday they would have still had a shot.

They technically still do have a shot if they elim BHL or raya today and then scum cross kill.

that would leave us with raya/BHL, S_S, flow trap tomorrow with the chance to elim the last rat to win.

[Nero Cain]

A town win after five straight mislims would be disgusting, definitely

that's just the way MB goes. I'd also argue that the players that were eliminated didn't play super great though Titus was mostly bad luck. And sometimes town just needs to die so things can get solved. Like I certainly get your point that we had like 1 correct lynch and the majority of scum were nked and therefore we don't deserve this but I think if Flow and SS do figure this out then town does and if they don't then scum was just better today.

Also, it might be partly my fault b/c I died n1 and wasn't there to shoot a buncha the scum.

[Isis]

Stop using that word dude

[SirCakez]

Titus was just terrible luck from a tricky setup
I don't think many towns would have done differently there
We also had the really bad luck with dog miller getting hit by cop (although Andante should have claimed that..)

[Dwlee99]

I'm just sad that it seems like dogs will lose without ever being eliminated

Firedog was right, I was too townie

[Dwlee99]

Is this a record for time between day start and first post?

[SirCakez]

Probably not i think I've seen 12+ hours before

[Firebringer]

Hey cakez welcome to the party

[SirCakez]

Hi FB

[xofelf]

S_S, *No* that is the wrong conclusion, don't you fucking dare.

[Thestatusquo]

This game is like the poster child for "don't try to outguess the mod."

[Thestatusquo]

I thought there were many different ways today could open, one of the two remaining town players saying a hard counterclaim of the town PR from the elim the day before was town was not on that list.

[Thestatusquo]

I think its very unlikely the town miselims here today though without something wild happening with flow trap getting counter claimed. But elim on flea is just as bad for town anyway.

[Nero Cain]

I don't really blame SS for thinking there's only an alien faction left since there was an alien cop. Like yes, red herrings have been a thing in setups but I think Occams might say that there's an alien faction. I also think it's not a bad thought process to think both dogs and cats are dead since thinking that 1 faction is larger than the other faction is prob never going to be anyone's first thought. Also in "true" multiball, the factions are meant to be the same size.

[Dwlee99]

Dogs would need some compensation for double dog cop: miller is not enough all dogs flipped vanilla

[SirCakez]

I don't really blame SS for thinking there's only an alien faction left since there was an alien cop. Like yes, red herrings have been a thing in setups but I think Occams might say that there's an alien faction. I also think it's not a bad thought process to think both dogs and cats are dead since thinking that 1 faction is larger than the other faction is prob never going to be anyone's first thought. Also in "true" multiball, the factions are meant to be the same size.

This and the evidence from the NKs is really weird
If I were still alive I wouldn't expect this whole third faction either

[Isis]

I just want to be friends with cakez

[SirCakez]

We are friends

[Isis]

Has any one ever smiled right after they had a sadcry and cried again

[Jingle]

Also in "true" multiball, the factions are meant to be the same size.

Eh. Factions are meant to be balanced, not necessarily the same size. Asymmetrical multiball is honestly more appealing to me and there are multiple opens that utilize this style of balancing them by giving them different sets of powers. (The various Jungle setups, for example.)

With that being said, I think confusion as to the makeup of the scumteams here is entirely reasonable.

[Thestatusquo]

Yeah I said earlier that I really wish I had just gone with something else instead of aliens for the red herring cop. Like I said, I thought I was giving a clue to maybe third team but I think it actually just ended up confusing people too much for what I wanted it to do.

[SirCakez]

The problem with Aliens is that it implied the limited kills of the Alien faction from like Great Idea

Some other flavor might have been better

[Thestatusquo]

Yeah it was meant to be a red herring but not so much of one that it derailed the whole game