In post 726, MathBlade wrote:Yes. That’s the world I am in yes. If you look at the game linked Yellowstone DGB did the exact same thing with AGamblingPig.
If you look at the second link, with DGB and Muffin DGB said they investigated Muffin and then muffin coasted to end game.
That’s always been my point and I think DGB is a liar. Nom’s is implausible and so is DGB if we take T3 at face value and I think we should.
I just read some of the scumthread in that game cause the game is long, the discussion summarized in
In post 66, DrippingGoofball wrote:We could also do this:
I roleblock AGP
JV claims 1 shot vig on whoever we NK and claims the scumkill didn't go through
I claim to have RB'd AGP
We sacrifice AGP
We are conftown until end game.
(AGP is other scum member here) So I can agree with the idea that DGB has plotted something involving a mass scum roleclaim. I still think both scum are unlikely, but I can see where you are coming from. But, if you really want to flip both of them, doesn't it make more sense to flip DGB first? If you believe they are both scum, then the power role seems more likely to be DGB. nomnomnom has the earlier 'hammer me' posts, and the post positioning gives DGB a better position. The main reason I personally suspect DGB more is the late claim and scummier vibe. Furthermore, nomnomnom's claim of friendly neighbor means that every day we wait, we can become much more certain of his true alignment. I am kind of down to annihilate DGB today. Killing a friendly neighbor claim as soon as we hear it just seems nonsensical. Why am I the only one who thinks this?
Well, if the wagon goes that way, I'll jump on. But I think that scumhunting outside of the pair is still fine since waiting a day gives us much better odds for flipping either of them.
Most recently, I'm getting big pings from Almost50. "Let's all claim now since half of us have already claimed our roles? And let's start with the people who we already know are power roles?
754" That's a incredibly scummy idea. It's like "town has already messed up a little, so let's go all the way". Especially with the amount of doubt I have on some of the roles that have been claimed. Also, looking at Almost50's iso, he's been on both the MURDERCAT and Flea wagon. He was the push behind MURDERCAT, and he was pretty absurdly confident in a nonsense probability argument. (probability is not the most rigorous subfield of mathematics). He doesn't have that many posts, but every post he does have is somewhat scummy.
Other people on both wagons:
Titus (didn't actually vote for MC, but thought she did in
218). I think their ISO is fairly clean, though.
Toogeloo (I'm feeling town on them for now)
nomnomnom (very scummy but again waiting to annihilate them is the best move)
T3 (his votes are really scummy, E-1 for flea and fake hammer for MURDERCAT. Text is convincing, though)
I think that's all of them. Besides this the only major negative feeling I had was on Galron, but reading his ISO didn't feel that bad for some reason. So I think the best wagon is here
VOTE: Almost50
