Newbie 2071: The Sandwich Debate - End!

[fferyllt]

Vote Count 1-4

The filling of this "bread and meat" combination is from some medieval recipes. The filling consists of roast pork loin, mushrooms, onions, eggs and mild white cheese.

GrandpaMo

(2): HockeyFan, Rocky14

HockeyFan

(2): cowsloveSushirolls, JamesTheNames

JamesTheNames

(1): GrandpaMo

VFP

(1): The Bulge

Not Voting

(3): T3, Beesechurger, VFP

With 9 alive, it takes 5 to eliminate.

Deadline: July 14, Midnight US Eastern Time.

Countdown: (expired on 2021-07-13 21:00:00)

Mod Notes:

Beesechurger has (expired on 2021-07-05 13:20:00) in which to post before I must seek a replacement.
-

[Beesechurger]

https://cuberule.com/

Therefore, that bagel thing is a sandwich

Now don't kick me mods

[The Bulge]

that rule is the worst stance on sandwiches i have ever seen, bar none. wow.

[The Bulge]

let us know when you've read the game, i wont be seen talking any sort of food with you

[cowsloveSushirolls]

hi, back from sleep. i responded to some posts here, but clipped some parts where i didn't respond

Specifically why I think cows is town is because his thought is too complex for a fresh newb straight from mafia.gg.

I disagree but eh its fine, at least this time the TR is justified from u so maybe you are actually town this game

two surprises here
1) hockey doesn't think i'm particularly town
2) t3 thinks i'm particularly town
wouldn't this make me leaning towards mafia's side if your image of me is a forum newbie straight from mafia.gg?
surely i'm being coached by a partner of questionable alignment to say these kind of things

could you clarify what "the TR is justified from u" means, @hockey?

can't be talking about james's alignment too soon, we might find something wacky

What does this even mean

grandpa asked to stop discussion when talking about james and his claim while campaigning for just discussion, it's a coincidence but he knows that more attention is gonna be put on james here, so i said that lol

my 2 cents on james (sorry grandpa), i was getting somewhat awkward/forced vibes from his early posting before the claim. my initial reaction to 40 was that i can see scum motivation behind it, specifically the "if I redact it later[...] feel free to hammer me" bit, but aside from it just being a particularly distracting shitpost, i cant find a reason for town to post this seriously. with 104 tho i'm thinking it could be townfuckery that's drawing my suspicion. i stand by the forced feel i was getting early on, but call him a light scumlean for me for now.

I really like this from Bulge, now idk if hes town just yet, but I do like this

yea i liked it too
i'll probably add that this post

I'm a very townie person, it just takes multiple day phases until people normally realise it.

and 'if i redact it later[...] feel free to hammer me" from the post earlier seem to contradict each other in terms of attitude so one of those posts have to be forced

[JamesTheNames]

I'm sure you'd agree not every post has the same level of seriousness, right cowsloveSushirolls?

[cowsloveSushirolls]

I'm sure you'd agree not every post has the same level of seriousness, right cowsloveSushirolls?

no comment

[HockeyFan]

hi, back from sleep. i responded to some posts here, but clipped some parts where i didn't respond

Specifically why I think cows is town is because his thought is too complex for a fresh newb straight from mafia.gg.

I disagree but eh its fine, at least this time the TR is justified from u so maybe you are actually town this game

could you clarify what "the TR is justified from u" means, @hockey?

Ok so pretty much I can reword it a bit. Basically the reasoning for his TR on u is smth I liked

[The Bulge]

Hockeyfan can you explain why you thought James' 40 was so nai you seemingly accused grandpa of faking a read on it?

[GrandpaMo]

Hey @Grandpa, u said in 79 "also i wanna create early discussion and move from the flavor scum fluff talk". Well u've had about 10 posts and none of them done what you wanted to do. Sure u had a mini read on James about him "tstbs" but like what else....? You even shut down the discussion from that post so what are you attempting to do?

Weren't you still discussing? Cows even implied and explicitly said they were talking about the claim etc. It's ironic becuase THAT caused the discussion in the first place.

After I said a read, which was the first geninue read of the game with a line of reasoning, you decided to respond to it and that sparked discussion.

I did shut it down due to it later being NAI and maybe sparking some anti-town behavior which results in outting a PR by accident etc.

[GrandpaMo]

my 2 cents on james (sorry grandpa), i was getting somewhat awkward/forced vibes from his early posting before the claim. my initial reaction to 40 was that i can see scum motivation behind it, specifically the "if I redact it later[...] feel free to hammer me" bit, but aside from it just being a particularly distracting shitpost, i cant find a reason for town to post this seriously. with 104 tho i'm thinking it could be townfuckery that's drawing my suspicion. i stand by the forced feel i was getting early on, but call him a light scumlean for me for now.

Lol, I love how Hockey pointed out my read (same exact reasoning too!) and said it was weird for me to say it. But once Bulge, you, said it all of a sudden "I liked it"

What's the difference between me and bulge's post that made you like theirs instead of mine?

[GrandpaMo]

Hockeyfan can you explain why you thought James' 40 was so nai you seemingly accused grandpa of faking a read on it?

Are we thinking the same thing here?

[Rocky14]

this is actually weird post. -townpoints.

tstbs imo

you'''re'r'e reaction testing already?

Weird vibes from this post by cowsloveSushirolls. Isn't the point to hunt?

James, Hockeyfan, Grandpa, and admittedly CLSR actively generating useful conversation points.

VFP and T3 have managed to be about while saying little.

[Rocky14]

Unvote: GrandpaMo

[Rocky14]

I don't think James' "claim" is really problematic.

[JamesTheNames]

my 2 cents on james (sorry grandpa), i was getting somewhat awkward/forced vibes from his early posting before the claim. my initial reaction to 40 was that i can see scum motivation behind it, specifically the "if I redact it later[...] feel free to hammer me" bit, but aside from it just being a particularly distracting shitpost, i cant find a reason for town to post this seriously. with 104 tho i'm thinking it could be townfuckery that's drawing my suspicion. i stand by the forced feel i was getting early on, but call him a light scumlean for me for now.

Lol, I love how Hockey pointed out my read (same exact reasoning too!) and said it was weird for me to say it. But once Bulge, you, said it all of a sudden "I liked it"

What's the difference between me and bulge's post that made you like theirs instead of mine?

I want to add something to what Mo added here.

in my homesite claiming VT early comes from town many times more than scum so i'll townbin you and call it a day

Why do you have an issue with GrandpaMo, when cowlovesSushirolls did worse? According to Mo what I did puts me between Null and Town for him. Null is an option bare in mind. For cowlovesSushirolls they town binned me.
So how come cowlovesSushirolls didn't get something along the lines of :

There is literally 0 chance that's the read u got out of James post 40 if you are town. How are u even getting a read on that post

In fact instead of pressuring cowlovesSushirolls in a similar way to GrandpaMo, you give, basically the complete opposite as a response:

eh I think its mostly NAI, i think ppl who say they're VT appear as they're town to not get sussed later

My vote is staying on Hockey Fan.

[cowsloveSushirolls]

Weird vibes from this post by cowsloveSushirolls. Isn't the point to hunt?

poking at grandpamo because the two things they said felt contradictory. they are hunting in a way that i'm fine with, but it just read out like a reaction test, so i gave them a reaction
"they lose townpoints from this, but the post is too scummy to be scum"

[GrandpaMo]

Weird vibes from this post by cowsloveSushirolls. Isn't the point to hunt?

poking at grandpamo because the two things they said felt contradictory. they are hunting in a way that i'm fine with, but it just read out like a reaction test, so i gave them a reaction
"they lose townpoints from this, but the post is too scummy to be scum"

that isnt what i was tryna imply lol

i was just trying to think in my head that hey if they were town -- how would in a world they would say this (

i dont want to say the answer to this

) already did dammit below.

and then if they were scum -- there would be the reason to confuse town or just add fluff shit post.

and im more inclined to believe either or -- hence why i said in the later post that this should looked at eod and not be really focused on, for all we could know james could be softing pr. this is why i want to avoid the discussion for now.

usually in conversations like these its best to relapse judgment in a later case. you can find james scummy for other reasons or in my case, you can find james towny.

[GrandpaMo]

In fact instead of pressuring cowlovesSushirolls in a similar way to GrandpaMo, you give, basically the complete opposite as a response:

they do this with the bulge as well.


they liked bulge's response to ur comment about post 40, even implying they were sheeping by saying "sorry grandpa" which i thought was funny

[GrandpaMo]

I don't think James' "claim" is really problematic.

it's not. lol

and whoever is trying to make it a problem, is probably scum.


also -- hockey's claim of my thing saying it didn't create discussion -- i still disagree as we are discussing it rn

[JamesTheNames]

In fact instead of pressuring cowlovesSushirolls in a similar way to GrandpaMo, you give, basically the complete opposite as a response:

they do this with the bulge as well.


they liked bulge's response to ur comment about post 40, even implying they were sheeping by saying "sorry grandpa" which i thought was funny

I am aware, I wanted to point out cowlovesSushirolls as they town binned it, you Null/town lean it, and The Bulge scum leans it. Yet the 2 extremes got positive comments but the moderate read got pressured.

[GrandpaMo]

In fact instead of pressuring cowlovesSushirolls in a similar way to GrandpaMo, you give, basically the complete opposite as a response:

they do this with the bulge as well.


they liked bulge's response to ur comment about post 40, even implying they were sheeping by saying "sorry grandpa" which i thought was funny

I am aware, I wanted to point out cowlovesSushirolls as they town binned it, you Null/town lean it, and The Bulge scum leans it. Yet the 2 extremes got positive comments but the moderate read got pressured.

eh i kinda disagree it -- i felt as tho me and bulge has the exact reasoning lol

we both were weary of the claim and was thinking of it in town and scum world but i think bulge was heavily leaning more scum.

i believe their spot on u is like null - scum lean

[GrandpaMo]

In fact instead of pressuring cowlovesSushirolls in a similar way to GrandpaMo, you give, basically the complete opposite as a response:

they do this with the bulge as well.


they liked bulge's response to ur comment about post 40, even implying they were sheeping by saying "sorry grandpa" which i thought was funny

I am aware, I wanted to point out cowlovesSushirolls as they town binned it, you Null/town lean it, and The Bulge scum leans it. Yet the 2 extremes got positive comments but the moderate read got pressured.

i just reread what u said -- i understand now.

[HockeyFan]

Hockeyfan can you explain why you thought James' 40 was so nai you seemingly accused grandpa of faking a read on it?

Its NAI cuz I dont think scum posts smth like that early into the game. Likewise, theres no reason for any VT to claim their role d1 so its not something town

should

do, so imo its NAI

Hey @Grandpa, u said in 79 "also i wanna create early discussion and move from the flavor scum fluff talk". Well u've had about 10 posts and none of them done what you wanted to do. Sure u had a mini read on James about him "tstbs" but like what else....? You even shut down the discussion from that post so what are you attempting to do?

Weren't you still discussing? Cows even implied and explicitly said they were talking about the claim etc. It's ironic becuase THAT caused the discussion in the first place.

After I said a read, which was the first geninue read of the game with a line of reasoning, you decided to respond to it and that sparked discussion.

I did shut it down due to it later being NAI and maybe sparking some anti-town behavior which results in outting a PR by accident etc.

I was discussing it but u came along with 140 and decided to minimize the discussion and your reasoning in what u just said is super ??. Since when does figuring out James motive for claiming VT/also his aligment result in anti-town behavior?

my 2 cents on james (sorry grandpa), i was getting somewhat awkward/forced vibes from his early posting before the claim. my initial reaction to 40 was that i can see scum motivation behind it, specifically the "if I redact it later[...] feel free to hammer me" bit, but aside from it just being a particularly distracting shitpost, i cant find a reason for town to post this seriously. with 104 tho i'm thinking it could be townfuckery that's drawing my suspicion. i stand by the forced feel i was getting early on, but call him a light scumlean for me for now.

Lol, I love how Hockey pointed out my read (same exact reasoning too!) and said it was weird for me to say it. But once Bulge, you, said it all of a sudden "I liked it"

What's the difference between me and bulge's post that made you like theirs instead of mine?

Bulge didnt say tstbs, and explained their thought process behind it instead of just flat out saying "oh James is tstbs"

[HockeyFan]

my 2 cents on james (sorry grandpa), i was getting somewhat awkward/forced vibes from his early posting before the claim. my initial reaction to 40 was that i can see scum motivation behind it, specifically the "if I redact it later[...] feel free to hammer me" bit, but aside from it just being a particularly distracting shitpost, i cant find a reason for town to post this seriously. with 104 tho i'm thinking it could be townfuckery that's drawing my suspicion. i stand by the forced feel i was getting early on, but call him a light scumlean for me for now.

Lol, I love how Hockey pointed out my read (same exact reasoning too!) and said it was weird for me to say it. But once Bulge, you, said it all of a sudden "I liked it"

What's the difference between me and bulge's post that made you like theirs instead of mine?

I want to add something to what Mo added here.

in my homesite claiming VT early comes from town many times more than scum so i'll townbin you and call it a day

Why do you have an issue with GrandpaMo, when cowlovesSushirolls did worse? According to Mo what I did puts me between Null and Town for him. Null is an option bare in mind. For cowlovesSushirolls they town binned me.
So how come cowlovesSushirolls didn't get something along the lines of :

Alright, sure I may have softballed cows there and I dont like it, looking back. But still, town binning someone is less scum leaning then having them has null to town because that way, you keep your options open which is why i pressured Grandpa more.

There is literally 0 chance that's the read u got out of James post 40 if you are town. How are u even getting a read on that post

In fact instead of pressuring cowlovesSushirolls in a similar way to GrandpaMo, you give, basically the complete opposite as a response:

Wow what a surprise, I interact different with my SRs then I do with my TR's, crazy right?

eh I think its mostly NAI, i think ppl who say they're VT appear as they're town to not get sussed later

My vote is staying on Hockey Fan.