Silent Star 4: Yin and Yang

[Flea The Magician]

Yin

- Are there any truly criminal between
Amy Dunne, Ydrasse and Ircher?

No there are not.

yin

, is there a criminal between Tanner, Ydrasse, and Ircher?

Yes there is.

[Tanner]

i'm aware of that, my question in 1768 wasn't random. i don't get why you're calling it "burning myself" though.

[NorwegianboyEE]

Tanner should already know if Yin is being real or bullshitting here. Assuming criminal means an anti-town role. As Yin is directly saying Datisi is a ‘criminal’

Do you have anything to share about what you think it could mean Datisi?

[Amy Dunne]

Amy: what made you more confident i'm town?

I keep having visions of Pooky laughing at me in a scum PT somewhere, and Infinity is there too. The whole gang! All laughing and pointing at me.

to be honest i am coming around to the town Pooky world, and it does have something to do with his post where he was like "yes i would never want to deal with that" when Amy was talking about how he wouldn't do what he did this game as scum.

yes i know. me too.

(and it also has to do with the post on me like i said earlier.)

do you scumread him or is this a paranoia read?

This.

[Amy Dunne]

Also, you were hardpushing for Nakata lim, then changed your mind to Ircher. That kind of re-evaluating pings townie to me.

[Tanner]

@norwee - my role is not anti-town, so it's either:

(1) being a criminal doesn't have anything to do with a person's alignment and there's another hidden metric to see if someone is a criminal or not.
(2) inspired by pooky - the "criminals" are actually the town, this game is 4 town vs 9 scum, ??? hectic game ??? (i don't think this is likely but it's a thought)
(3) the answers yin gives us are bullshit.

i thought about trying to get yin to contradict himself somewhere to see if it's (3), but since it's obviously too close to end of day, that's gonna have to wait. my personal guess is that it's (1), since i doubt hectic would introduce this whole mechanic for it to just do literally nothing?

[Flea The Magician]

VOTE: Tanner

Quickest and probably best way to find out at this point.

[Flea The Magician]

I was hoping you'd give me reason to refute it.

[Amy Dunne]

Amy if you vote Nakata we can put them to E1 right now.

Can you tell me why there better than Ircher? I keep going back and forth on it. I think Nakata is scummier but if Ircher flips scum, then we have proof Yin is lying to us but I could do either.

Hectic said we have plurality lim, so does that even matter?

[Ydrasse]

a classic silent star game would be its actually 3 and we’re using it as a way to hunt and do things and then like two days later we lim people but then actually they’re now stumps who draft a new team that we have to play with and also like there’s a vengekill idk

[Ydrasse]

VOTE: Tanner

Quickest and probably best way to find out at this point.

this is the least productive thing you could be doing

[clidd]

I think it's a mix of 1 and 3.

2 doesn't seem likely to me.

[Ydrasse]

like we have three wagons and deadlines almost here no ones voting tanner lmfao

[Ydrasse]

if infinity doesn’t go thru i’ll switch to nakata ig

[Amy Dunne]

@norwee - my role is not anti-town, so it's either:

(1) being a criminal doesn't have anything to do with a person's alignment and there's another hidden metric to see if someone is a criminal or not.
(2) inspired by pooky - the "criminals" are actually the town, this game is 4 town vs 9 scum, ??? hectic game ??? (i don't think this is likely but it's a thought)
(3) the answers yin gives us are bullshit.

i thought about trying to get yin to contradict himself somewhere to see if it's (3), but since it's obviously too close to end of day, that's gonna have to wait. my personal guess is that it's (1), since i doubt hectic would introduce this whole mechanic for it to just do literally nothing?

Unless things change on D2, my role pm says this is bs.

#2, I mean. #3 is probably right though.

[Tanner]

VOTE: Tanner

Quickest and probably best way to find out at this point.

this is a joke, right?

[Amy Dunne]

VOTE: Tanner

Quickest and probably best way to find out at this point.

this is the least productive thing you could be doing

like we have three wagons and deadlines almost here no ones voting tanner lmfao

Flea can join Nakata in the pointless votes club.

[Ydrasse]

like at this point i literally think that we’re not playing against the normal type of goons because what are the votes of half these people

[Amy Dunne]

if infinity doesn’t go thru i’ll switch to nakata ig

Why Infinity > Nakata/Ircher?

I think they both look worse?

[Ydrasse]

if infinity doesn’t go thru i’ll switch to nakata ig

Why Infinity > Nakata/Ircher?

I think they both look worse?

norwee saying she sounds like an alien uncomfortable in human skin is the best analysis anyone could give of her play and in what world is town!infinity that out of place in a game like this esp if theres something fucky going on

[Tanner]

flea: i understand that this is a fucky game where we cannot blindly trust information given to us by npc's
flea: tanner is solid town
also flea: *votes tanner based on information given to us by npc's*

[Ydrasse]

ircher > i think has some reflections of towny mindset
nakata > i couldn’t immediately recall everything in my case on him; however this doesn’t mean he’s town either which is why nakata over ircher

[Ydrasse]

...do people have reads on flea?

[Amy Dunne]

Infinity's just generally been lower energy for a while now :/

I hope she feels better soon!

This post makes me unsure.

[Tanner]

...do people have reads on flea?

it just dropped a decent amount.

also i feel like i should be drawing a conclusion from the fact that literally all three of the viable wagons seem to be lurking the heck out of this game at this hour, but i genuinely have no idea anymore.