Newbie 2071: The Sandwich Debate - End!

[The Bulge]

now i am!

[JamesTheNames]

He's scum.

[JamesTheNames]

UNVOTE: cowsloveSushirolls
VOTE: The Bulge

[cowsloveSushirolls]

VFP's playstyle makes absolutely no sense from a mafia perspective, so i might pass on that one too

I disagree. it might not be a Good way of playing scum, but we can't discount theories in the realm of, for example, what if vfp hates playing scum, has realized people in the newbie queue are unlikely to actually pile on against inactivity/noncontribution, and so decides to go with the easier playstyle for peace of mind? I'm talking out of my ass a little here, I only have 1 game with vfp, but my point is that in general, those kinds of possibilities and other irl factors should never be

completely

written off.

i was thinking less of the active lurking and more of the awkward, almost opportunistic attacks and vague cases (no offense)

[GrandpaMo]

UNVOTE: cowsloveSushirolls
VOTE: The Bulge

is this a serious vote?

[GrandpaMo]

UNVOTE: cowsloveSushirolls
VOTE: The Bulge

is this a serious vote?

[T3]

UNVOTE: cowsloveSushirolls
VOTE: The Bulge

is this a serious vote?

[T3]

UNVOTE: cowsloveSushirolls
VOTE: The Bulge

is this a serious vote?

[GrandpaMo]

hm. so its more like this.

I am thinking about this pool:

[VFP, rockey, StrangeMatter]

or the other subgroup of

[Hockey, Cows, Bulge]

I feel like those 3 of hockey, cows, bulge there is one PR, one scum, and one VT.

And the other scum lies within the first group.

I won't explain why those groups are combined just yet.

Excuse me, but did you mean [VPF, StrangeMatter]? Rockey isn't in this game anymore.

Okay, I wasn't going to say something but this bothered me.

Strangematter finally comes into the game and responds to me mistankly having the wrong name.

Then disappears.

It was so out of place and just felt unnatural. I thought strangematter would eventually respond to my points or even to other things just like hockey would have, but they never did, they just made that complaint and left the thread once again.

Oh I will, but I've been busy for most of the day, so I can't really respond. Speaking of which, I looked through your ISO and noted you town read people who have similar thought processes or sheep. Can you explain this thought process behind that?

Also, you seem to put Beezle as one of the people on the list, can you please explain where you put would put them as a read?

Why not have them as a read?

[T3]

I can't say why bc of ongoing games but I

think

Bulge is almost certainly town.

[fferyllt]

Mention of ongoing games is strictly not allowed. Sitewide rule is here

[JamesTheNames]

UNVOTE: The Bulge
VOTE: T3
Beese Churger has had more helpful input on the game than T3.

[HockeyFan]

@cows, why do u SR bulge, i actually think they're quite town

the people i listed above the condemn pool are people i'd actually defend if people came rallying against them
i don't feel the same about bulge yet, but they are null
i don't have dirt on bulge (i can talk about how their reads are different from my awesome towny POV reads lol) but i can't pick out things that are super town either

are you able to towncase them?

Sure! My TR on Bulge is mainly because of their tone, i think their tone is mainly town. Posts such as 141,301,484 are town. Furthermore, thier whole interaction of the "tsbts" thing wasnt scummy at all, and a slight TL based on that. They have progressed their reads as the game went on(althought they havent made a full reads list yet, their reads are pretty clear rn). So basically thats why I think they're town

VFP's playstyle makes absolutely no sense from a mafia perspective, so i might pass on that one too

I disagree. it might not be a Good way of playing scum, but we can't discount theories in the realm of, for example, what if vfp hates playing scum, has realized people in the newbie queue are unlikely to actually pile on against inactivity/noncontribution, and so decides to go with the easier playstyle for peace of mind? I'm talking out of my ass a little here, I only have 1 game with vfp, but my point is that in general, those kinds of possibilities and other irl factors should never be

completely

written off.

i was thinking less of the active lurking and more of the awkward, almost opportunistic attacks and vague cases (no offense)

Why do u think scum cant pull this off

[cowsloveSushirolls]

Why do u think scum cant pull this off

i'm sure they can, but i guess it's the same reason i attribute anti-town actions to town: scum has no incentive to do them if there's way more effective ways of carrying out something
if you have access to daychat with an entire partner, i don't think you go and attack people in such a way that's uncoordinated

[HockeyFan]

i'm sure they can, but i guess it's the same reason i attribute anti-town actions to town: scum has no incentive to do them if there's way more effective ways of carrying out something

Scum do infact have an incentive to be "anti-town" so ppl can just go them calling "omg they're tstbs"(which is basically what you're doing rn)

[cowsloveSushirolls]

i'm sure they can, but i guess it's the same reason i attribute anti-town actions to town: scum has no incentive to do them if there's way more effective ways of carrying out something

Scum do infact have an incentive to be "anti-town" so ppl can just go them calling "omg they're tstbs"(which is basically what you're doing rn)

is VFP a powerwolf, hockey?

[HockeyFan]

i'm sure they can, but i guess it's the same reason i attribute anti-town actions to town: scum has no incentive to do them if there's way more effective ways of carrying out something

Scum do infact have an incentive to be "anti-town" so ppl can just go them calling "omg they're tstbs"(which is basically what you're doing rn)

is VFP a powerwolf, hockey?

havent seen their scum games, so idk, but if you'e talking about this game, yes probably they are(I really hope im not misinterpreting what powerwolf means kek)

[cowsloveSushirolls]

the question is open to everyone
tell me how scum!VFP plays

[cowsloveSushirolls]

might even say they're not the vote today if you guys keep this up

[GrandpaMo]

@hockey do u think cows could be paired with vfp lol

[GrandpaMo]

ik crazy read... but i just wanna see if we are thinking the same thing

[T3]

the question is open to everyone
tell me how scum!VFP plays

Almost every single one of VFP's games has been with me.
I still have no idea.

[StrangeMatter]

Why not have them as a read?

.
Not exactly the response I expected to get.

[fferyllt]

et

[fferyllt]

allez