In post 547, Green Cap Boys wrote:I feel obligated to remind you that youIn post 471, T3 wrote:I don't know. I could see scum looking at the rules or whatever and realizing 'wtf I don't have a nightkill better townslip 'In post 51, ta vera wrote:the obvious question here is: is this a real townslip?In post 8, NorwegianboyEE wrote:Do mafia have a nightkill or do they just toss poison at people.playedin the previous MBOS where several townies townslipped about the lack of a nightkill.
The potion distributions are randomly generated. There's no intentional design in any role. Bingle's claim is likely true regardless of alignment. I don't know why he'd get an ingredient with no potion but I also don't see why he'd bother to come up with that lie - it opens him up to a potential counter claim if he's scum and there's a potionless townie.In post 541, NorwegianboyEE wrote:I still don’t think it’s utterly damning, and i liked his posts from that point onwards and i agree with T3’s point of: "Bingle should be better at mechanics as scum to know better than to claim something that looks utterly scummy." Therefore i can only assume he did so because it is real, and Schadd felt like adding an miller type role that looks scummy by default but is town.
I don't think there isanyclaim scum could conceivably make here that would be cause for pumping the brakes (I certainly can't think of one that'd make me stop), but Bingle is also aware that as a semi-nightless setup, losing a scum member, even a functionally powerless one, is a fairly significant blow and he'd have tried harder to avoid the yeet. Although you could argue that his posting was him trying to avoid the yeet. But meh. I think the analysis from him is fine and there are people I suspect more.
-R
Usually when someone says someone else is mech scum it's best not to make them elaborate.In post 531, The Limit Does Not Exist wrote:mastina still hasn't explained why bingle scumclaimed even after multiple people have asked so that's what I'm assuming it is, and it's a bullshit reason.
Oh, that makes sense. Thinking about it, they also did it in a weird attention grabbing way.In post 534, NorwegianboyEE wrote:This is also an really easy way to fake town as an hydra though.
"Hey Flea, if you say you scumread Norwee while i townread them it will look town, because Townie dissonance is townie. Datisi was doing it with Retti so we need to copy!!"
And that is just why you're on the glare list, not the yeet list. I'm used to you being quite confident in your opening reads, and you fail to have quite same force that I have come to expect here.In post 496, mastina wrote:Flea I <3 you but you're probably just scum here especially since of all the players in the game you're the most qualified for knowing that this is my towngame since you've seen me recently in my games more than anyone else and you not being able to see that I'm town here is one of the reasons why you're probably scum. </3In post 365, Fairy Circle wrote:Mastina and Norwee on my *glare* list for now.
Amusingly most of the posts containing reads at that point for Momcindas, I believe I had only aired two people I intend to keep a rather close, unfaltering gaze on.In post 511, T3 wrote:As of page 14 I've disagreed with all of Fairy's reads. .-.
This is absolutely awful and I pray Momcinda resolves her tech issues soon so that we may take a united stance upon this.In post 534, NorwegianboyEE wrote:This is also an really easy way to fake town as an hydra though.
"Hey Flea, if you say you scumread Norwee while i townread them it will look town, because Townie dissonance is townie. Datisi was doing it with Retti so we need to copy!!"
How is it awful? It’s an genuine strategy i’ve even done myself with Gamma in a scum hydra.In post 555, Fairy Circle wrote:This is absolutely awful and I pray Momcinda resolves her tech issues soon so that we may take a united stance upon this.
In post 520, T3 wrote:I finished my catchup and shall declare a townbloc: T3, Norwee, Emp, GCB
could you elaborate on why you find my slot town? you only seemed to substantially mention it in 483 and 493, and those posts feel a bit... contradictory?In post 553, T3 wrote:Emp, Norwee, GCB are town.
Norwee's meta case was very compelling.In post 557, Green Cap Boys wrote:In post 520, T3 wrote:I finished my catchup and shall declare a townbloc: T3, Norwee, Emp, GCBcould you elaborate on why you find my slot town? you only seemed to substantially mention it in 483 and 493, and those posts feel a bit... contradictory?In post 553, T3 wrote:Emp, Norwee, GCB are town.
-D
The hydra dissonance felt like it was done in a way to draw attention to it.In post 555, Fairy Circle wrote:And that is just why you're on the glare list, not the yeet list. I'm used to you being quite confident in your opening reads, and you fail to have quite same force that I have come to expect here.In post 496, mastina wrote:Flea I <3 you but you're probably just scum here especially since of all the players in the game you're the most qualified for knowing that this is my towngame since you've seen me recently in my games more than anyone else and you not being able to see that I'm town here is one of the reasons why you're probably scum. </3In post 365, Fairy Circle wrote:Mastina and Norwee on my *glare* list for now.
Given your recent play, I still hold my suspicions, but I know you will become clear to me in time.
Also, yis, is ana amazing film
Amusingly most of the posts containing reads at that point for Momcindas, I believe I had only aired two people I intend to keep a rather close, unfaltering gaze on.In post 511, T3 wrote:As of page 14 I've disagreed with all of Fairy's reads. .-.
This is absolutely awful and I pray Momcinda resolves her tech issues soon so that we may take a united stance upon this.In post 534, NorwegianboyEE wrote:This is also an really easy way to fake town as an hydra though.
"Hey Flea, if you say you scumread Norwee while i townread them it will look town, because Townie dissonance is townie. Datisi was doing it with Retti so we need to copy!!"
T3 would you care to elaborate more upon your read on us?
-Malefleacent
And that therefore proves the rule? False dissonance to generate townreads upon us? As opposed to "Well yes there is a disagreement on reads, but we will resolve this between us and act accordingly"In post 556, NorwegianboyEE wrote:How is it awful? It’s an genuine strategy i’ve even done myself with Gamma in a scum hydra.In post 555, Fairy Circle wrote:This is absolutely awful and I pray Momcinda resolves her tech issues soon so that we may take a united stance upon this.
Are you claiming this is an impossible thing for scum!you to do?
Ah. UNVOTE:In post 562, Fairy Circle wrote:And that therefore proves the rule? False dissonance to generate townreads upon us? As opposed to "Well yes there is a disagreement on reads, but we will resolve this between us and act accordingly"In post 556, NorwegianboyEE wrote:How is it awful? It’s an genuine strategy i’ve even done myself with Gamma in a scum hydra.In post 555, Fairy Circle wrote:This is absolutely awful and I pray Momcinda resolves her tech issues soon so that we may take a united stance upon this.
Are you claiming this is an impossible thing for scum!you to do?
Given that Momcinda has ongoing technical issues which had lead to a struggle in us being even able to communicate effectively with each other, there will be dissonance for a short while, and I am proverbially leading the charge here. Momcinda's reads are all in the thread, she has discussed none with me as yet.
-Malefleacent.
Would also seem I misread a post of faes where I believed there was a Norwee read.In post 324, Fairy Circle wrote:In any case, phone issues has me unable to post until late at night buuttttt
That should be rectified soon!
Im also always V/LA on the weekends.
And its monday night. Anyway, someone tell me what i missed
You know i’m not actually trying to super push you as scum based on this point alone. I’m just saying i do not think your hydra dissonance is townie because it could be faked.In post 562, Fairy Circle wrote:And that therefore proves the rule? False dissonance to generate townreads upon us? As opposed to "Well yes there is a disagreement on reads, but we will resolve this between us and act accordingly"
Maybe, but that post was being secretive wrt mechanics, not reads...In post 478, T3 wrote:Secretiveness with reads is almost always towny.
