Open 823 - To Tell The Truth | Game Over

[ArcAngel9]

no? If we get Player X and Player Y. and Player x's role is innocent, and they get a true result, they will be annouced as town. However, lets say we roll a 6 on the 1VX(number of mafia), Players Y's role will be announced as town even if they are mafia so we do we really have confirms? I could just be stupid

Wont X elimination confirms that Y result was untrue.

Elimination does reveal their rule faction isn't it?

If X gets eliminated, it confirms that X's result was true, it does *not* confirm that Y's result was false.
Since "X is innocent" is true, that means that "X is innocent or ..." is true regardless of what comes after the or

My only question is what happens if both results are false

We are complicating it. It is simple

D1 reveals the identity of two players - One of it is True and the other is false. Eliminate one and the other gets confirmed.

N_M is town

Too soon to say!

T3 is scum

Way too soon to speculate!

T3 is scum

I was going to say this but he has to roll town in at least one game right? :^). or idk he could be scum for voting N_M the locktowned

The possibility of a rolling town is more than rolling scum.

my rat died the other week.

What? Is there context to this?

maybe shouldn't spam submit, no wonder it was lagging

Okay.

VOTE: goals

We got a cow for this, no need of a goat.

[cyrus62]

before yall start pushing me im not that active this time cause im also moding.

[cyrus62]

so i think arc and t3 are scum together.

[HockeyFan]

no? If we get Player X and Player Y. and Player x's role is innocent, and they get a true result, they will be annouced as town. However, lets say we roll a 6 on the 1VX(number of mafia), Players Y's role will be announced as town even if they are mafia so we do we really have confirms? I could just be stupid

Wont X elimination confirms that Y result was untrue.

Elimination does reveal their rule faction isn't it?

If X gets eliminated, it confirms that X's result was true, it does *not* confirm that Y's result was false.
Since "X is innocent" is true, that means that "X is innocent or ..." is true regardless of what comes after the or

My only question is what happens if both results are false

We are complicating it. It is simple

D1 reveals the identity of two players - One of it is True and the other is false. Eliminate one and the other gets confirmed.

N_M is town

Too soon to say!

T3 is scum

Way too soon to speculate!

T3 is scum

I was going to say this but he has to roll town in at least one game right? :^). or idk he could be scum for voting N_M the locktowned

The possibility of a rolling town is more than rolling scum.

my rat died the other week.

What? Is there context to this?

maybe shouldn't spam submit, no wonder it was lagging

Okay.

VOTE: goals

We got a cow for this, no need of a goat.

This whole post is ew imo. Its a bunch of discrediting of reads because "iTs tOO eArLy"

[cyrus62]

VOTE: arcangel

[Zyla]

D1 reveals the identity of two players - One of it is True and the other is false. Eliminate one and the other gets confirmed.

Nono, one is true, the other is

possibly

false
Specifically, the one we get tomorrow will have a 3/8 chance of rolling guilty, regardless of whether or not they are
(I'm assuming we can't do a no-lim because that would break this setup in a couple of nights)

[T3]

VOTE: goates

[Marashu]

Official Vote Count 1.02

Elimination

With 9 alive, 5 votes are required for elimination.

goats

(2): ArcAngel9, T3

Not_Mafia

(1): Not_Mafia

Zyla

(1): MegAzumarill

cyrus62

(1): Zyla

ArcAngel9

(1): cyrus62

Not Voting

(3): goats, imaginality, HockeyFan

Deadline:

(expired on 2021-08-18 08:49:51).

Mod notes:

[HockeyFan]

VOTE: arcangel

Wait wtf cyrus might be town?

VOTE: goates

T3 what are you doing and why are you like this. I dont understand the pattern of your votes

[Zyla]

VOTE: arcangel

Wait wtf cyrus might be town?

What about this vote makes him towny?

[HockeyFan]

VOTE: arcangel

Wait wtf cyrus might be town?

What about this vote makes him towny?

It was more of the idea in my head that "hey, cyrus also sees angel's latest post as scummy"(same thought process as me), he might be town!. Ofc its too early to lock him in as hard town but i think he can be a good TL to start off with

[imaginality]

D1 reveals the identity of two players - One of it is True and the other is false. Eliminate one and the other gets confirmed.

Nono, one is true, the other is

possibly

false
Specifically, the one we get tomorrow will have a 3/8 chance of rolling guilty, regardless of whether or not they are
(I'm assuming we can't do a no-lim because that would break this setup in a couple of nights)

2/8 if we elim scum.

[Zyla]

Oh yeah. I don't think I've ever actually managed to hit scum first time so I forgot it was possible xD

[cyrus62]

VOTE: arcangel

Wait wtf cyrus might be town?

What about this vote makes him towny?

It was more of the idea in my head that "hey, cyrus also sees angel's latest post as scummy"(same thought process as me), he might be town!. Ofc its too early to lock him in as hard town but i think he can be a good TL to start off with

I think that's called a mind meld.do you also feel t3 is bad?

[HockeyFan]

VOTE: arcangel

Wait wtf cyrus might be town?

What about this vote makes him towny?

It was more of the idea in my head that "hey, cyrus also sees angel's latest post as scummy"(same thought process as me), he might be town!. Ofc its too early to lock him in as hard town but i think he can be a good TL to start off with

I think that's called a mind meld.do you also feel t3 is bad?

T3 is doing ....... t3 things so everything hes doing is NAI as of now. I still dont understand the vote swapping, but again its t3 and no one ever understands him

[cyrus62]

Truth is when scum hunting I try to look for who isn't helping advanced the game and is just posting to post. Or is trying to seem townier then every one else.

[T3]

VOTE: arcangel

Wait wtf cyrus might be town?

VOTE: goates

T3 what are you doing and why are you like this. I dont understand the pattern of your votes

tbh i just want to sppedlim someone so we can get to the mech stuf.

[T3]

VOTE: arcangel

Wait wtf cyrus might be town?

VOTE: goates

T3 what are you doing and why are you like this. I dont understand the pattern of your votes

I know exactly what alignment cyrus is but we don't want to do anything with him yet.

[ArcAngel9]

so i think arc and t3 are scum together.

I have a better theory. I think you and hockey are scum together!

VOTE: arcangel

Wait wtf cyrus might be town?

What about this vote makes him towny?

It was more of the idea in my head that "hey, cyrus also sees angel's latest post as scummy"(same thought process as me), he might be town!. Ofc its too early to lock him in as hard town but i think he can be a good TL to start off with

So what part of what i said was scummy?

Oh yeah. I don't think I've ever actually managed to hit scum first time so I forgot it was possible xD

Happens but rarely!

VOTE: arcangel

Wait wtf cyrus might be town?

What about this vote makes him towny?

It was more of the idea in my head that "hey, cyrus also sees angel's latest post as scummy"(same thought process as me), he might be town!. Ofc its too early to lock him in as hard town but i think he can be a good TL to start off with

I think that's called a mind meld.do you also feel t3 is bad?

Having mid meld together!! More reasons to believe that i might be right about both of your scum partnership!

Truth is when scum hunting I try to look for who isn't helping advanced the game and is just posting to post. Or is trying to seem townier then every one else.

This is a wrong tell.. there are plenty of town players who just lurk and play lousy. And i have seen more competent active players who outplay town players.

[HockeyFan]

VOTE: arcangel

Wait wtf cyrus might be town?

VOTE: goates

T3 what are you doing and why are you like this. I dont understand the pattern of your votes

I know exactly what alignment cyrus is but we don't want to do anything with him yet.

Mate what, you 2 scum partners?

so i think arc and t3 are scum together.

I have a better theory. I think you and hockey are scum together!

VOTE: arcangel

Wait wtf cyrus might be town?

What about this vote makes him towny?

It was more of the idea in my head that "hey, cyrus also sees angel's latest post as scummy"(same thought process as me), he might be town!. Ofc its too early to lock him in as hard town but i think he can be a good TL to start off with

So what part of what i said was scummy?.

I said earlier that post was mainly trying to discredit's peoples early reads(such as T3 scum, N_M town e.tc)

[T3]

VOTE: arcangel

Wait wtf cyrus might be town?

VOTE: goates

T3 what are you doing and why are you like this. I dont understand the pattern of your votes

I know exactly what alignment cyrus is but we don't want to do anything with him yet.

Mate what, you 2 scum partners?

so i think arc and t3 are scum together.

I have a better theory. I think you and hockey are scum together!

VOTE: arcangel

Wait wtf cyrus might be town?

What about this vote makes him towny?

It was more of the idea in my head that "hey, cyrus also sees angel's latest post as scummy"(same thought process as me), he might be town!. Ofc its too early to lock him in as hard town but i think he can be a good TL to start off with

So what part of what i said was scummy?.

I said earlier that post was mainly trying to discredit's peoples early reads(such as T3 scum, N_M town e.tc)

I can read cyrus very well.

[imaginality]

VOTE: arcangel

Wait wtf cyrus might be town?

VOTE: goates

T3 what are you doing and why are you like this. I dont understand the pattern of your votes

I know exactly what alignment cyrus is but we don't want to do anything with him yet

.

This last sentence makes me think T3 scum cyrus town.
T3, can you explain what you meant by that sentence?

P-edit: so do you think cyrus is town? Or scum?

So what part of what i said was scummy?.

I said earlier that post was mainly trying to discredit's peoples early reads(such as T3 scum, N_M town e.tc)

I agree with this, at best it seemed like a big post to say essentially nothing (except for the idea that eliminating one investigation target confirms the other, which definitely isn't true in most cases).

[T3]

Won't say.

[imaginality]

so i think arc and t3 are scum together.

I have a better theory. I think you and hockey are scum together!

This seems omgussy?

Having mid meld together!! More reasons to believe that i might be right about both of your scum partnership!

I don't think a scum pairing would openly say they're mind melding? Seems more like something they wouldn't want to comment on.

Truth is when scum hunting I try to look for who isn't helping advanced the game and is just posting to post. Or is trying to seem townier then every one else.

This is a wrong tell.. there are plenty of town players who just lurk and play lousy. And i have seen more competent active players who outplay town players.

'not advancing the game' isn't the same as lurking (the latter is a subset of the former). Posts like your "it's too early!" #53 don't exactly advance the game either.

I think Cyrus's approach is a useful one especially early game.

[imaginality]

Won't say.

VOTE: T3

This 'I have a read but I won't tell you it yet' seems anti-town. Seems like keeping it unspoken means you can wait to see whether others lean cyrus:town or cyrus:scum so you can then say that's what your read was too.