Newbie 2075: Icecream Cake (Game Over)

[Quiet Owl]

Are we going to eliminate T3 without looking at anyone else then? This seems unwise.

[T3]

hnnnnhgggggkkkhhhhhjWheme is town.

[T3]

*moans*

[WhemeStar]

Are we going to eliminate T3 without looking at anyone else then? This seems unwise.

Who said anything like that

[Kerset]

Are we going to eliminate T3 without looking at anyone else then? This seems unwise.

unwise? well he claimed VT. he either lives as scum or as VT, who never dies at night (which increase the odds of PR death)

[Psyche]

Are we going to eliminate T3 without looking at anyone else then? This seems unwise.

idk about you but ive been looking at everyone all game so far

[Kerset]

quiet if you want second thoughts then why have you not given opinion on cook? I stated his wagon already

[Kerset]

Are we going to eliminate T3 without looking at anyone else then? This seems unwise.

idk about you but ive been looking at everyone all game so far

Do i look cute? :3

[Psyche]

I think I want to VOTE: Quiet Owl.

It seems like just the sort of content-free virtue signaling I'd expect from Mafia near a mislim tbh.

[Psyche]

Oh, QO was on the T3 wagon. That changes my calculations a bit. UNVOTE:

[Psyche]

guess i'll pretend we have enough to justify a thread re-read

[Kerset]

sooo you dont want t3 anymore?

[Psyche]

will have to see

[GuyInFreezer]

VC 1.04

T3 (3):

Quiet Owl, Cook, Sea monkey

Sea monkey (2):

Whemestar, T3

Cook (2):

Kerset, MegAzumarill

Not voting:

navigatorv, Psyche

With

9

alive,

5

votes to eliminate

Deadline:

(expired on 2021-08-16 11:51:42)

[T3]

@mod cook has 2 votes not 1

[WhemeStar]

Oh did sea monkey replace ben

[WhemeStar]

UNVOTE:

[Quiet Owl]

quiet if you want second thoughts then why have you not given opinion on cook? I stated his wagon already

I did, a while back. I highly doubt that mafia would devise and post an entire theory for winning the game as town. Too much work for not enough gain, and asking for roleclaims is always going to attract suspicion.

[Quiet Owl]

Are we going to eliminate T3 without looking at anyone else then? This seems unwise.

Who said anything like that

No-one said, but by my count there were four people voting for him when I posted that.

[Psyche]

quiet if you want second thoughts then why have you not given opinion on cook? I stated his wagon already

I did, a while back. I highly doubt that mafia would devise and post an entire theory for winning the game as town. Too much work for not enough gain, and asking for roleclaims is always going to attract suspicion.

but cook even said she was planning even

before

signing up to post the theory
very little besides her ego would prevent her from doing it even with a mafia role pm, especially with people like you around willing to give towncred for it

[Quiet Owl]

I'm aware of that, and that this is a genuine attempt to test her theory. But you think she'd deliberately sabotage the mafia?

[Psyche]

don't the mafia already know which setup we have?

[Sea monkey]

which setup do we have?

[Psyche]

ughh

[Quiet Owl]

don't the mafia already know which setup we have?

Mafia know whether the setup is A, B or C, but not the specific setup.

The way I see it, there are three possible options.
1) Cook is town, and her posting of the theory is a genuine attempt to aid the town. I think this is most likely.
2) Cook is scum, and her posting of the theory is a genuine attempt to aid the town. Betraying your team is a dirtbag move and not something I'd expect from Cook.
3) Cook is scum, and her posting of the theory is an attempt to gain towncred and discover power roles. This is ridiculous, because the theory was tracker specific before the game started, before mafia!Cook knew that she was mafia or whether or not there was a possible tracker in the game. It's possible, but improbable.