mini theme 2229: MBOS 13 schweppes' pulpy potions daya 5

[Green Cap Boys]

VOTE: T3

I feel that Fairy is getting run up solely for defending me and I don't like it.

That doesn't feel true at all? T3 gave a list of reasons in 1109 that don't mention that, RCE says he didn't like the dumbtell in 1145, mastina is because they're scumreading her (842), norwee is just saying they're not townie (1001), dwlee is just PoE, it seems? (1024)

This seems like a defense that is totally divorced from reality, which is scummy, at least in my opinion.

-R

[Green Cap Boys]

My brain has been barely able to get into the game the past few days but reading the available case on Fairy Circle doesn't fill me with confidence, Flea had struck me as gut-towny very earlier in the game. Had actually read faer scumgame to fake-meta them in our earlier game even though I was scum, fae felt more actively involved here and faer opinions on things struck me as believable.

-R

[Green Cap Boys]

Screw trying to be organized and logical, current feelings are that I'd bet on at least 2 scum in here:

RCEnigma
mastina
Titus
TLDNE

Think some of the people there are getting far too much leeway simply for having strong opinions rather than actually being towny.

-R

[T3]

Man where’s Emperor at.

VOTE: T3

I feel that Fairy is getting run up solely for defending me and I don't like it.

That's... not true.

[T3]

Accidentally quoted 1141.

[Dwlee99]

It doesn't assume either of those things, but it is much more likely for town to be potionless than mafia and his slip about the potions is very unlikely if he was in a PT where he could see his mafia buddies' potions.

[Dwlee99]

^ @RC if that wasn't clear

[Green Cap Boys]

VOTE: Titus

[Green Cap Boys]

Weighing the appetite for this, we have a little less than a day to deadline and I feel decidedly meh about the current wagons

-R

[NorwegianboyEE]

I love that Emperor guy and if they ever die i am going to feel very sad.

[T3]

I explicitly stated Fairy/Titus isn't s/s.

[The Limit Does Not Exist]

Screw trying to be organized and logical, current feelings are that I'd bet on at least 2 scum in here:

RCEnigma
mastina
Titus
TLDNE

Think some of the people there are getting far too much leeway simply for having strong opinions rather than actually being towny.

-R

can you be more specific about who in this group is "getting far too much leeway for having strong opinions"?

- lilith

[T3]

VOTE: titus
Titus just lies when defending Fairy?
'I'm voting Fairy because Fairy defended Titus.'
I stated that I wasn't doing that.

[T3]

Screw trying to be organized and logical, current feelings are that I'd bet on at least 2 scum in here:

RCEnigma
mastina
Titus
TLDNE

Think some of the people there are getting far too much leeway simply for having strong opinions rather than actually being towny.

-R

can you be more specific about who in this group is "getting far too much leeway for having strong opinions"?

- lilith

Probably mastina.

[T3]

In this case mastina having strong opinions is a strong meta towntell.

[NorwegianboyEE]

Mastina IS town though.

[Green Cap Boys]

Screw trying to be organized and logical, current feelings are that I'd bet on at least 2 scum in here:

RCEnigma
mastina
Titus
TLDNE

Think some of the people there are getting far too much leeway simply for having strong opinions rather than actually being towny.

-R

can you be more specific about who in this group is "getting far too much leeway for having strong opinions"?

- lilith

mastina/Titus, mainly. I'm not actually sure why anyone's giving your slot a pass.

-R

[T3]

Fairy and Titus have both done weird "LOOK AT ME IM DEFENDING" defenses but never actually attempted to stop each other's wagons. [not s/s]

[Dwlee99]

VOTE: Titus

It's happening??

[NorwegianboyEE]

I'm not terribly eager to vote Titus again. I already explained why i think they are more likely town here.

[Dwlee99]

VOTE: Fairy ??

Cold feet be damned?

[T3]

pain
is Titus scum? mnehhhh probably not
is Fairy scum? like yeah maybeeee but math says they are

[Green Cap Boys]

I'm not terribly eager to vote Titus again. I already explained why i think they are more likely town here.

That is what I am getting at when I'm saying she's getting too much of a pass for having strong opinions, the actual reasoning behind it doesn't feel like a believable town thought process at all.

-R

[Dwlee99]

VOTE: Titus
Green cap LOCKTOWN

[T3]

I'm not terribly eager to vote Titus again. I already explained why i think they are more likely town here.

That is what I am getting at when I'm saying she's getting too much of a pass for having strong opinions, the actual reasoning behind it doesn't feel like a believable town thought process at all.

-R

Yeah. People seem to be townreading her for bad meta reasons.