3d20 – The Great Board Game War [GAME OVER]

[Marashu]

I agree that rolled town roles shouldn't out (at least, not yet.) Saying you rolled a town role is fine, but I'd rather if scum didn't know what we have. Exception: If you rolled town and a miller-like modifier, I think we should out those(alignment and mod) but not the PR.

[Marashu]

I won't disclose my second role, but, I rolled a 6, ____, 7. So I'm useless on odd nights.

Did you get your own role/roll?

[JamesTheNames]

I won't disclose my second role, but, I rolled a 6, ____, 7. So I'm useless on odd nights.

Did you get your own role/roll?

I did my roll*.
Also do you mean my original role?

[cyrus62]

I won't disclose my second role, but, I rolled a 6, ____, 7. So I'm useless on odd nights.

ok i can do this thanks BTW . 7 ,___ ,1

[JamesTheNames]

Wow my typing is terrible, I did mean my roll*.

[cyrus62]

I agree that rolled town roles shouldn't out (at least, not yet.) Saying you rolled a town role is fine, but I'd rather if scum didn't know what we have. Exception: If you rolled town and a miller-like modifier, I think we should out those(alignment and mod) but not the PR.

thank you glade some one agrees . i think this comes from a pro team BTW.

[JamesTheNames]

I think both are fine actually, this mode makes it really easy to lie about your role and rolls. Both can be used in different ways to bluff. Giving either, from my eyes, is Green.

[MegAzumarill]

Hello my fellow townies.
I rolled cult bus driver (2 modfiers). [19,17,20] And I'm upset for obvious reasons
I'm pretty sure that's one of the 5 fudged rolls because it seems super strong.
Let's get this show on the road.

VOTE: redtea

[ssbm_Kyouko]

The reason we need full rolls is for cases like James' roll. Functionally we cant tell the difference between James roll and Marashu's roll because 1 number from 5 rolls has been changed. By him claiming a blank middle number, we wont be able to tell if a flipped role matches his original roll or if it matches Marashu's roll with the 2nd die modified.

I wouldn't be surprised if James or someone on James' team advised him to claim in this way to muddy the waters

VOTE: JamesTheNames

[ssbm_Kyouko]

I agree that rolled town roles shouldn't out (at least, not yet.) Saying you rolled a town role is fine, but I'd rather if scum didn't know what we have. Exception: If you rolled town and a miller-like modifier, I think we should out those(alignment and mod) but not the PR.

I went back and checked, I dont think there is any way for anti-town to play around knowing what roles went to town. There's also no guarantee the roles went to town or that the roles/modifiers were the same due to the 5 fudged rolls

[JamesTheNames]

The reason we need full rolls is for cases like James' roll. Functionally we cant tell the difference between James roll and Marashu's roll because 1 number from 5 rolls has been changed. By him claiming a blank middle number, we wont be able to tell if a flipped role matches his original roll or if it matches Marashu's roll with the 2nd die modified.

I wouldn't be surprised if James or someone on James' team advised him to claim in this way to muddy the waters

VOTE: JamesTheNames

I can confirm I didn't start or end up as a parity cop.

[ssbm_Kyouko]

Cyrus what was your 2nd dice?

[JamesTheNames]

I'm just going to ask this to double check that I understand this fully, I'm pretty sure I do.
Let's say I rolled a 1,1,1 this means just a bog standard vanilla town.
That role is then added to a pool of 13 total roles, and those new roles are given out randomly.
Is my understanding of this correct? I just need it double checked.

[ssbm_Kyouko]

I'm just going to ask this to double check that I understand this fully, I'm pretty sure I do.
Let's say I rolled a 1,1,1 this means just a bog standard vanilla town.
That role is then added to a pool of 13 total roles, and those new roles are given out randomly.
Is my understanding of this correct? I just need it double checked.

Yes, and there is a possibility that one of those three 1s was changed by the mod to make the setup balanced. The mod changed 1 die each on 5 different rolls before reshuffling the resultant roles to the players

[JamesTheNames]

I'm just going to ask this to double check that I understand this fully, I'm pretty sure I do.
Let's say I rolled a 1,1,1 this means just a bog standard vanilla town.
That role is then added to a pool of 13 total roles, and those new roles are given out randomly.
Is my understanding of this correct? I just need it double checked.

Yes, and there is a possibility that one of those three 1s was changed by the mod to make the setup balanced. The mod changed 1 die each on 5 different rolls before reshuffling the resultant roles to the players

Okay good, I was contemplating revealing the 2nd roll I got and ended up overthinking and getting mixed up.
I figured because original role wouldn't be very strong I may aswell just reveal it.
6, 10, 7.

[ssbm_Kyouko]

So if Town Even-Night [Role] flips, we dont know if it was your or Marashu's roll. If you tell us you rolled a 3 - JOAT, then if we see a Town Even-Night JOAT flip, it's reasonable to assume it was your roll and not Marashu's that had the Parity Cop fudged into a JOAT

[ssbm_Kyouko]

VOTE: Cyrus

[JamesTheNames]

I think Cyrus has made his role easy to speculate. 45 and 47. I reckon he rolled an 18-20. That's just my speculation, he can verify if wants to but he doesn't have to. If he isn't going to tell us there's no point hovering focus on him when it could be used better elsewhere.

[JamesTheNames]

Actually I'm actually pretty sure its a 7. I'm pretty sure he rolled a Town PGO with no modifications. 7, 7, 1. Ignore my 67.
I find it strange if it is the case that he wouldn't out the role existing if he were town.
UNVOTE: Robert M Hunter
VOTE: Cyrus62

[Dwlee99]

Stay the course on mega

[cyrus62]

Cyrus what was your 2nd dice?

wont say its just better that way. trip wires only work if no one knows.

[cyrus62]

Actually I'm actually pretty sure its a 7. I'm pretty sure he rolled a Town PGO with no modifications. 7, 7, 1. Ignore my 67.
I find it strange if it is the case that he wouldn't out the role existing if he were town.
UNVOTE: Robert M Hunter
VOTE: Cyrus62

this makes me think you got my roll.

[cyrus62]

yes 7,7,1 but now scum know thanks alot now the trick wont work gee.

[cyrus62]

VOTE: everyone who postedfor role fishing . gee you guys going give the baddies the advantage.

[JamesTheNames]

yes 7,7,1 but now scum know thanks alot now the trick wont work gee.

PGO is basically a town sided Jester. Their job is to get targetted during the Night, similar to a Jester being hammered during the day. Knowing it exists allows more room for town to play and importantly bluff. Let's say we had a really strong town role, if they convinced non-town players that they were the PGO, all of a sudden they're immune to Night Kills (theoretically). If non-town didn't know of the PGO's existence, that strong town role would just be Night Killed.