Open 825 - PYP X/Y: HoS_S [game over!]

[House]

Pesky CSF, you're just too town to be town.

Guess you gotta die.

[Cat Scratch Fever]

@Auro Oh, I was talking about the VC Penguin quoted in 2398.

[Auro]

Yeah but that's what I'm going off of, right? The reason you weren't present there is that you had voted Enchant and then immediately shifted to Titus.

[Cat Scratch Fever]

I'm not comparing playstyles, just that that bus play stood out to me, I figure you're pretty capable of townposting as scum though

I'm very flattered :3 But at the risk of making my scumgame painfully obvious in the future, I would say my WIM levels are nowhere the same and I kind of just lurk as scum.

[Auro]

Eh

VOTE: MM

[Cat Scratch Fever]

Yeah but that's what I'm going off of, right? The reason you weren't present there is that you had voted Enchant and then immediately shifted to Titus.

No, the quoted VC in 2398 was way before that, before your fakehammer on Gamma.

[Auro]

Ah, right. My bad.

[House]

When Titus had claimed, you backed off

Little nitpick, but i unvoted

before

she claimed.

UNVOTE:

Long day at work, today.

I'll be back later.

I'll try to check in tonight but it's date night. I may not be back and active before deadline. For that reason, I will claim. I'm the universal backup.

[Gamma Emerald]

MM + 1 of {Auro/ManateeGal} are all fine lims for today.

My first choice remains MM.

This does not parse in my head. It makes more sense to say that just one of those three are fine?

[Gamma Emerald]

It seems to me like Flea scum only makes sense if Enchant is also scum, I can't really see Flea scum Enchant town. So again, even without any real townread there I guess I just don't really get the wagon.

If MM flips red, Flea is basically IC for this post.

I kinda get it but I also don’t

[House]

It seems to me like Flea scum only makes sense if Enchant is also scum, I can't really see Flea scum Enchant town. So again, even without any real townread there I guess I just don't really get the wagon.

If MM flips red, Flea is basically IC for this post.

I kinda get it but I also don’t

That post reads as trying to set up a mislim following losing a buddy.

Why would scum box themselves into scumreading another buddy when the one that's currently being scumread is in danger of being eliminated?

[House]

MM + 1 of {Auro/ManateeGal} are all fine lims for today.

My first choice remains MM.

This does not parse in my head. It makes more sense to say that just one of those three are fine?

I was saying (at that time) that i believed the scum team to be either:

MM + MG, or
MM + Auro

Current theory, however, is:

MM + Thor, or
MM + Auro (trying to rock the boat when town was beginning to find each other was Not A Good Look, plus I'm willing to work with Penguin on his suspicions there as well)

[House]

That feels kinda flimsy
Why do you think Flea wouldn’t bus? How does your read on me factor into that?

Doesn't really make sense. A random last minute vote on Enchant there would give basically no town credit and would probably actually be more suspicious than it would give town credit. There's especially no reason to do it when we literally had tied competing wagons.

It has basically nothing to do with my read on you?

She's already casing faer in preparation for toDay.

[Gamma Emerald]

MM + 1 of {Auro/ManateeGal} are all fine lims for today.

My first choice remains MM.

This does not parse in my head. It makes more sense to say that just one of those three are fine?

I was saying (at that time) that i believed the scum team to be either:

MM + MG, or
MM + Auro

Current theory, however, is:

MM + Thor, or
MM + Auro (trying to rock the boat when town was beginning to find each other was Not A Good Look, plus I'm willing to work with Penguin on his suspicions there as well)

But regardless of team potential there is no reason one person being a good elim precludes another person from also being one

[Gamma Emerald]

It seems to me like Flea scum only makes sense if Enchant is also scum, I can't really see Flea scum Enchant town. So again, even without any real townread there I guess I just don't really get the wagon.

If MM flips red, Flea is basically IC for this post.

I kinda get it but I also don’t

That post reads as trying to set up a mislim following losing a buddy.

Why would scum box themselves into scumreading another buddy when the one that's currently being scumread is in danger of being eliminated?

This also feels backwards
MM only said Flea had to be scum with Enchant, not the other way around

[House]

But regardless of team potential there is no reason one person being a good elim precludes another person from also being one

Level of suspicion, however, is.

Obviously, I wasn't married to that theory, considering I've already amended it.

[Gamma Emerald]

My main issue there is with the “one of” bit

[House]

It seems to me like Flea scum only makes sense if Enchant is also scum, I can't really see Flea scum Enchant town. So again, even without any real townread there I guess I just don't really get the wagon.

If MM flips red, Flea is basically IC for this post.

I kinda get it but I also don’t

That post reads as trying to set up a mislim following losing a buddy.

Why would scum box themselves into scumreading another buddy when the one that's currently being scumread is in danger of being eliminated?

This also feels backwards
MM only said Flea had to be scum with Enchant, not the other way around

Assume for a moment that MM is scum.

She knows that Enchant is scum.

Her team is in danger of losing a member.

Now, reread my post.

[House]

My main issue there is with the “one of” bit

I dunno why.

MM is my primary suspect. The 3rd member, I'm less sure on.

It obviously can't be both of them, as there are only 3 scum. So, it's "one of".

[Gamma Emerald]

But they’re both suspects, therefore they’re both good lims, there is no “one of” in that sort of statement

[Auro]

UNVOTE:
Don't wanna place her at E-2 yet.

[House]

But they’re both suspects, therefore they’re both good lims, there is no “one of” in that sort of statement

Clumsily worded, perhaps, but i was stating the possible scum teams, of which MM was the common denominator.

[Gamma Emerald]

It seems to me like Flea scum only makes sense if Enchant is also scum, I can't really see Flea scum Enchant town. So again, even without any real townread there I guess I just don't really get the wagon.

If MM flips red, Flea is basically IC for this post.

I kinda get it but I also don’t

That post reads as trying to set up a mislim following losing a buddy.

Why would scum box themselves into scumreading another buddy when the one that's currently being scumread is in danger of being eliminated?

This also feels backwards
MM only said Flea had to be scum with Enchant, not the other way around

Assume for a moment that MM is scum.

She knows that Enchant is scum.

Her team is in danger of losing a member.

Now, reread my post.

I guess it checks out but it’s a really dumb way of setting Flea up because the connection was set up from the other end to how it would make sense
Basically I’m saying if MM was doing that, she fucked it up

[Gamma Emerald]

But they’re both suspects, therefore they’re both good lims, there is no “one of” in that sort of statement

Clumsily worded, perhaps, but i was stating the possible scum teams, of which MM was the common denominator.

Eh I think I see the missing logical connector there
“MM + one of these two are probably the scum,

thus

the are all good lims”

[House]

UNVOTE:
Don't wanna place her at E-2 yet.

Yeah, if she's town both scum will jump to hammer her!

Not like that would be informative in itself, or anything.