Mini 2228: Isekai uPick - Endgame

[Gamma Emerald]

I HAVE CAUGHT UP

DUNNSTRAL IS MY STRONGEST TOWN READ

VOTE: Kate bishop

Sry ffery

You caught up and those are your only reads?
(probably not actually but this doesn’t sit well with me)

[Gamma Emerald]

Ah yes, I fell for your classic blunder

You got us!

Pack it up boys time to concede

No but seriously, if you're town I don't see a good reason to tank myself onto you when I'm much more convinced of Toog beign scum.

And if you're scum, I don't see a reason to try and kill you, lose my momentum and have people like Cabd decide that you're not dying today.

I'm uninterested in either outcome, since they're both bad for me, and thus, the town.

So I'm denying the gambit. I'm happy to piledrive Toog into the ground and dust him before moving on.

I would stake this entire game on LLD being town
There’s none of the twisted shit I sensed in Wall Street Bets, it’s all pure reads and fury

[ManateeGal]

hi mr emerald

[Lukewarm]

I’d be willing to vote Wheme
He gives off a remarkably similar vibe to that one time we were scum together

What game are you referring to?

A large normal, I think number 217 was it
It was modded by Ircher

I found it. It was 213

https://forum.mafiascum.net/viewtopic.php?f=55&t=76567

What feels the same to you?

I have not done any meta on him before this, but I just skimmed that iso and don't see it.

If anything, it makes me second guess my read on him :/

[Gamma Emerald]

Some of us don’t get their kicks off being nasty. Clearly not a universal belief.

I am here to tell you: someone on this site ABSOLUTELY gets a joyride off of making others suffer needlessly. And the person they are targeting is one of my closest friends on this site, perhaps the closest now that the former holder of that title did the one thing you never do to me, which is to drive the knife in twice. One betrayal of my emotions or standards I can handle, the second is when things go personal. Depending on who the Breaker of Malos is, will determine how much ire I will feel once I have them pinned to the fucking wall.

[Gamma Emerald]

hi mr emerald

full reads list with explanations pls

I’d be willing to vote Wheme
He gives off a remarkably similar vibe to that one time we were scum together

What game are you referring to?

A large normal, I think number 217 was it
It was modded by Ircher

I found it. It was 213

https://forum.mafiascum.net/viewtopic.php?f=55&t=76567

What feels the same to you?

I have not done any meta on him before this, but I just skimmed that iso and don't see it.

If anything, it makes me second guess my read on him :/

He feels like he’s a rag doll floating through the thread

[Lukewarm]

Sure, I guess?

The things that stood out to me this game were the total sheeping, the constant refrain of "I am town, and therefore good town players should magically devine my alignment" and then omgus on town players who didn't.

And those were the things I was looking for when I skimmed that iso. And I didn't see any of those 3.

[Lukewarm]

He seemed to have his own opinions (if anything, giving out too many town reads too easy for my comfort), never called himself townie, and then town read everyone on his wagon

[Gamma Emerald]

Meh
I really feel like I’m onto something, sure the actions themselves differ but that vibe I mentioned feels the same

[Dunnstral]

We have 6 days, we could swing the vote to anyone.

Who do you suggest?

[Lukewarm]

I don't claim to be good at second hand meta.

Ffery, did you look at that game?

[Gamma Emerald]

Vote us then.

Nah, I've got bigger scummier fish to fry. Besides, if you ARE scum with Toog, it's gonna be way harder to kill you today in this town and you know that.

If anything, you saying this is the one thing I expected you to do as scum, because it's better for you here.

But I'm pretty happy to deny your gambit, as one might say.

I HAVE CAUGHT UP

DUNNSTRAL IS MY STRONGEST TOWN READ

VOTE: Kate bishop

Sry ffery

No no no. Not the time. Toog first. I want a full claim from NewspaperBear

AYE AS UR ONE AND ONLY 2 HANDED SWORD I DO AS YOU WISH

VOTE: TOOG

Okay this vibes different tho

[Gamma Emerald]

Like, it reads as an excitable puppy

[Gamma Emerald]

I read the whole game front to back, not just Toog's part in it (he died N2) because I'm a masochist.

How do you EVEN

[Kate Bishop]

Can’t speak for good cop but I did quick skims of every post-hiatus game of his

[Gamma Emerald]

Maybe my attention span/dedication just sucks but I’ve probably never read an already-completed game all the way through if it was 100+ pages

[Kate Bishop]

His being wheme

He only had like two or three scum games lol

[Gamma Emerald]

I still intend to take some time away from this game and hopefully let my temper chill. Seeing all the shit I put up with in that game and managed not to yell, scream and/or replace out really brings home how much less tolerance for slings and arrows I have these days.

Seeya when I'm in a better mood.

This isn't a soft, slings and arrows just reminded me of this and seemed appropriate for the mood

I got my own Bulletproof on my mafia music playlist (link in my sig! Yes it’s a lot of video game music, I’m not the only one who likes to listen to it yaknow)

[DrippingGoofball]

Needlessly categorized reads

Role

LLD
Manatee

Obligatory townread

GIF

Lazy af townread(s)

Cabd

Sheeping my townread(s)

Dunn (Town)
DGB (Leaning Town)

Intentionally not giving reads for various reasons

Kate Bishop

If I townread this now I'm admitting to being too lazy for this game

marcistar

They'll prob sort themselves sooner (& considering just calling it TvT to piss people off for fun)

unwnd
Lukewarm

Leftovers

Kyouko
WhemeStar

First vote of the day

VOTE: Toogeloo

GiF, pls scrape off the mold from these mouldy reads.

[Gamma Emerald]

Do you have any reads yet?

not really yet, do u?

can u restate then? idk maybe im just not understanding/forgetting.
the only thing i can really tell is what ur read on me is

Maybe I'm just looking for a reason to TR marci but I forgot about this quickly on my first read because I got distracted by trying to figure out what Cabd meant by Firebringer in his TRs right after reading it. But I feel like this is town Marci

[Kate Bishop]

I don't claim to be good at second hand meta.

Ffery, did you look at that game?

It was part of the quantitative data about his scum/town posting, but not one I read closely for textual body language stuff.

I'll have a look at it later today.

[Kate Bishop]

I'm:

1: Distraught my tool didn't useful
and
2: Really think we're letting wheme off the hook
but
3: Absolutely don't mind voting there.

When you're around I want pick back up here and continue.

[GuyInFreezer]

GiF, pls scrape off the mold from these mouldy reads.

I dunno I kinda posted a new one yesterday

[Gamma Emerald]

And then can we kill DGB for not wanting to kill this terrible claim

Your claim is waaayyyyyyy worse, why don't I want to kill yoooooooooooouuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuu

Yours is literally the scummiest claim I've seen.

But lot of players have weird, confirmable roles in the game.

=========================

The pagetop game has been really old and tedious and unfunny for years now. It's game and iso pollution.

what
maybe the claim isn’t perfect, I think the concern of it being a cover-up is legit in a way (in my last UPick there was a role that wanted to make the night kill), but by play Rhiannon is a shining beacon of towniness shining upon the thread. And she has a point in how Toog’s vague claim should never have gotten a pass from you, what with your signature.

[Gamma Emerald]

Okay I think I can let Cabd out of the YTYD cage and into my actual TRs