Final Fantasy XIV - A Realm Reborn Mafia (Game Over)

[Romance]

I’m as a subtle as a train wreck regarding my identity.

I’ll consider Cheeky again but I still don’t think my read on them was really personality based.

Have we played on your main?
~C

I don’t think I have with your main, no.

[tictac]

rce feels more connected/less abstracted than what i remember from scum him, but i may be tring time/exp there.
still would not be my first choice.

[RealCheeks]

i don't tr mastina ftr

Why?
~C

[tictac]

(I don’t actually agree with Elsa FYI but that seems a little bit braver than I’d expect from scum)

i was misreading this as u saying u tr elsa for bravery, whinch would have been backwards.

[Romance]

VOTE: SirCakez

Sure.

[tictac]

i don't tr mastina ftr

Why?
~C

the motivation 4 the claim is fucked 4 both align, theres that + effort as far as i can see as far as reasons 4 tr go

[tictac]

VOTE: Momrangal
i guess

[Sakura Hana]

The one thing i remember about mastina, which may be wrong since i havent played mafia in a long time and i havent played with mastina in an even longer time.
But if she's scum she's actually the role she's claiming.

I'm not willing to go down the meta rabbit hole for the time being tho, so i'll just keep it in the back of my head, and mention it in case someone with better memory than me can correct me if im wrong.

[tictac]

But if she's scum she's actually the role she's claiming.

i mean shes basically claiming the powerset that scum are mod confirmed to have

[Qrow and Raven]

I'm out.

But before I go, you have no comment on me literally explaining the strategy to you. Ok.

I don't even get what the strategy accomplishes aside from the mindset of "I don't want to be a scapegoat so I'm going to tap out rather than let that happen", which I think makes little sense with mastina's claim
so you're just being flat-out confusing rn
also re: mastina claim meta the only lies I can remember have either been half-truths or lies as town, so I think Sakura's meta still holds

-Qrow

[Sakura Hana]

But if she's scum she's actually the role she's claiming.

i mean shes basically claiming the powerset that scum are mod confirmed to have

Yes, that's why unless im wrong on her meta, she's town.
And i could very well be wrong, so for now i'll just leave her as a townread.

[Qrow and Raven]

(I don’t actually agree with Elsa FYI but that seems a little bit braver than I’d expect from scum)

i was misreading this as u saying u tr elsa for bravery, whinch would have been backwards.

Um. I'm pretty sure your "misread" was actually what I meant. Why did it feel backwards to you?

Qrow

[tictac]

(I don’t actually agree with Elsa FYI but that seems a little bit braver than I’d expect from scum)

i was misreading this as u saying u tr elsa for bravery, whinch would have been backwards.

Um. I'm pretty sure your "misread" was actually what I meant. Why did it feel backwards to you?

Qrow

scum elsa is very much not timid at all.
if anything i'd expect a lot more of the razzle-dazzle from scum-him
is that not ur exp with him then?

[Qrow and Raven]

Elsa/Titus scum imo.

Interesting.

Elsa, I can speculate on a reason for (but would appreciate clarity), but more relevant to my interests is, why Titus?

- House

was already townreading this slot off of yume's posting but house also looks good for this

Elsa/Titus scum imo.
- C

Elsa is ok today. I agree on Titus though

-R

This is why I'm bad with Hydras. I always set one of them off. Bleh.

Forgive my insolence Cheeky.

feels like you maybe misread, the heads seem to be of mixed opinions on you rn
also can you go into why you mention setting people off here?

To be fair.
I have a feeling that a scum dwlee would have BS'd a reason to townread mastina by now just to get off the spotlight.

P-Edit: Ok thanks.
Although that wasnt what i was doing?

I think a better reason to TR dwlee might be the fact he put the cart before the horse a bit and used mirio's push as evidence that mastina is town
to me it suggests he's got a little bit of natural confbias which I believe is towny
dont't quote me on this in endgame though

-Qrow

[Qrow and Raven]

(I don’t actually agree with Elsa FYI but that seems a little bit braver than I’d expect from scum)

i was misreading this as u saying u tr elsa for bravery, whinch would have been backwards.

Um. I'm pretty sure your "misread" was actually what I meant. Why did it feel backwards to you?

Qrow

scum elsa is very much not timid at all.
if anything i'd expect a lot more of the razzle-dazzle from scum-him
is that not ur exp with him then?

I think elsa is sorta a people pleaser as scum while he does his own thing a bit more as town
though I will say the posting has kinda slid into less towny territory as time has gone on

-Qrow

[Qrow and Raven]

Does anyone other than dwlee find my line of questioning aggressive?

not exactly but I do get why he thinks it was

dwlee uses they/them pronouns

Thank

I am a 400 foot tall purple platypus-bear with pink horns and silver wings.

igeddit

I'm being clammy because if I show my hand too much scum will realize I actually have a day cop ability

Gross, dude. Get a towel.~

-Qrow

[Qrow and Raven]

We are all suffering alts.

this post triggered a not-so-good memory and idk if romance was even in the game that makes this hit like that

-Qrow

[Mystic Bears]

TELL THEM TO TURN OFF CAPS IT'S CASE SENSITIVE.
~C

ROFL!

Something that stuck out to me is how many people glazed over my request altogether. I don't think it was an incorrect thought, and I also realized I misunderstood how it worked once it was clarified in thread. I think it's going to be good information to dig into more at a later time.

I am unimpressed by the votes on me over the request, but understand them. Of the two I think Gamma's was weaker, as it seems fairly surface level.

So what DO you make of the votes on you?

Mastina's town.

why ydrasse alt

... Does Ydrasse have any alts that aren't outed? xD

I did check with the mod, and as a matter of fact: yes. That's in fact how it works! The mod confirmed that me using my 1x guaranteed raid success...will give me another shot at a guaranteed raid success.

The downside to me claiming/confirming this is that now all scum with X-shots know they can get another X-shot but hopefully the town can get more mileage out of the raid. (I claimed without knowing what the raid bonus was, I saw my role earlier, formed a plan for what I'd do on daystart, I was phoneposting when the game started, so didn't know the ramifications until now.)

A townie mindset would save this to stop 3 failed raids in a row or something instead of wasting it early on. But you claimed it when the mod alluded to that type of role day 1 and plan to use it immediately?

I read the raid thing at the beginning and it said only hostile factions can choose to pass or fail the raid if they're in it. So your ability seems more suited to town at first glance. But it said faction(s). So I dunno.

I just don't wanna trust you to claim this role so early. Does the town know when you succeed? Because if we don't know when you use it, then you can just let this raid pass through by just accepting this raid as scum instead. You'd know if your buddies are in the raid anyway.

I like you. The raids are a potential POE tool later on.

Meta is the best scumhunting tool
-T3

Metabad. :3

I'm kind of just waiting for someone to town slip hard or scum slip hard.
I don't really see anything yet. I have pings of town, but then I just go: Nono, what if that's what they want me to think?

There are certain posts that are being uploaded to my brain that I'm trying to make a decision on, such as Qrow's use of past experience to justify that the pace is fine. When, like, okay? Sure? Alright.

This is a town post

Bell posting at all is town bell

If Mastina is scum, by virtue of her roleclaim she has to be on every single raid; and, then, as scum neither she nor any of her scumteam would be allowed to fail a raid without revealing her as fake. I don't think that a scumteam does all of that to ingratiate her to town so she's probably just town. /shrug

Not quite, shes set up to allow any failed raids after this one without incrimination. We're too early for mech talk, the claim is NAI to me from mechanical perspective and mastina is not town by meta even remotely at the moment, as she can powerwolf. For now she's a solid null for me, time will tell.

Let's see if putting things in a readslist helps my thoughts here.

Mirio
Bell
dwlee99

ArcAngel9
Mystic Bears (Noraa + Flea the Magician)
Save The Dragons
Titus
Toogeloo

Head One and Head Two (T3 + ManateeGal)
tictac
Tomorrow Corporation
Whemestar
Mandelbrot (House + Yume)
Sakura Hana
Momrangal
Romance
Elsa Jay

SirCakez
RealCheeks (RCEnigma + CheekyTeeky)

Qrow and Raven (Gamma Emerald + Nancy Drew 39)

Approximately: townread null-positive null-null-to-null-negative scumlean scum.

This lacks something :/ I'm not sure what though

And this is what I was waiting for. Mastina is town until further notice

dafuq just happened?
Reverse OMGUS?
"Youre town!"
"GOOD! you're town too!!"
O.o like yeah I've seen this before but this seems well funny to me, not even AI just funny #fluff

Mirio gets a townread for stealing my thoughts.

Like please tell me this isn't just me? This is comical with how fast it's happening and there's still players who haven't even posted yet xD

#Page10

[Mystic Bears]

-Flea, in case it wasn't obvious

[Romance]

I think Sakura’s town atm. Feels genuine whenever she posts in the weird towny way that just clicks.

[Romance]

I have a few hidden alts actually. ^_~

[Qrow and Raven]

Spoiler:

Go back to your old account and say that to my face. >:(

I thought Bell was like, a Ranmaru alt initially

I mean, i'm bad at alt hunting so i wont bother anyway.

I feel like I've gotten better at alt-hunting by a slight margin but I don't do it unless intrigued by the player/bored, or I feel incensed to do it

So I call out your god and you label me a heretic. Rude.

At least I'm not just letting one player slide through the day.

Also everyone also ignored me earlier but I did also see in the mod post he mentioned hostile Faction(S).

at least one member of the hostile factions are in the raid group, the said member will decide whether the raid succeeds or fail

Did you wanna talk about that or do you wanna tell me Mastina is town?

I kinda took note of this convo as I was skimming on main, I didn't really process the original post tho, this seems pretty benign

Is Sakura Hana fire bringer?

KEKW
I have played with both players in at least one game I can definitely certify their distinctness as human beings

Is Sakura Hana fire bringer?

No, this is my main account.
Fire bringer is a friend of mine tho

I think Firebringer said the exact same thing to me as scum the last game I played with them. Something about protecting other player’s self-esteem.

lol where
and like Sakura has issues with her own self-esteem so I dunno if she'd really have the fortitude to protect others but not herself (though I myself am kinda like that, I may feel like shit sometimes but that doesn't stop me from being the hero when I feel like I need to be, but that's probably because that is handled by a different part of me than the part that processes my own self-esteem)

The Bell Tell.

why'd you bring this up??

-Qrow

[Romance]

I think Mirio had just voted or talked about Bell and the rhyme made me giggle so I posted it.

Also I do think it could still be valid if he fails to keep up with decent content as the game progresses.

[Qrow and Raven]

... Does Ydrasse have any alts that aren't outed? xD

I'm pretty sure ydrasse either wears her identity on her sleeve even when she's on an alt or just reveals it in her sig

-Qrow, who on a tangential note literally dissociated as he was writing this post

[Romance]

I’m not allowed to type properly on Ydrasse for fear of ruining my brand so I have to play on alts and that allows me to unlock more of my brainpower to solve.