In post 1786, Gamma Emerald wrote:I’m kinda ready to turn in for the night but I’ll drop thoughts and we can continue this later probably
LLD’s entrance felt kinda organic in a way that I unfortunately can’t really dive into yet but I expect will make sense when I get to it. The only thing I could say I’m concerned about is her immediate trust that I’m town by how she asserted I was misreading her, but given how Dwlee has interacted with me that’s also entirely understandable. However, Loftwing was weird and while I can kinda see his posting being town it was still not great.
House I think has felt about the same as he did in PYP, and just in general seems to have good intentions. I also think if he’s scum here he doesn’t react the way he did to Pooky’s dumb meta argument. But it’s also D1 and I’m not as assured as I was in PYP that I can read House super-duper easily.
i'd posit that LLD will tell anyone who scumreads her that they're misreading her, regardless of her alignment. "she's good scum" is a bad reason to be scumreading her, and it's not my reason, but i'd ask that you be very careful relying on the immediacy of her suggesting you're lying as a towntell.
don't mind the theory that there's some level of scum in {dwlee, lld} and {lld, megazu} but i don't really see what part of the dwlee/lld interactions actually made you come out seeing lld as town.
could you expand a bit more when you've got time tmo?
re. house, i don't really see it. in pyp i literally used house as a sounding board on d1 as much as i could because i was like, *certain* he was town and didn't want to interact with slots i wasn't certain on (gotta get that sweet n1 kill u know). i kinda like. wouldn't be surprised if this is his towngame, but i don't really see the similarities. he's felt far lower-energy and kind of flat here. it's not about the 'trying to be less assertive on d1' thing either; i dig that. i just haven't found myself picking up anything house is putting down so far.