In post 1573, Almost50 wrote:So there are THREE Bulletproofs in the setup? because BOTH me and zen are 1-shot BP. (that's the part we decided he should leave out when he claimed)In post 1567, Jacket wrote:This is actually close to what I was thinking. Except it makes more sense for cool cookie to be the traitor, since mailman returns a positive to a traffic analyst but a negative to a neighbor finder.In post 1553, Almost50 wrote:T3's role was designed for Scum to identify their Traitor in at least 2 steps, and the Mailman is their "Miller" (gives them a false +ve)
Mini Normal 2242 | Opossum Mafia | Game Over!
Forum rules
- House
-
House Survivor
- House
- Survivor
- Survivor
- Posts: 19605
- Joined: September 5, 2014
- Location: Home of Top Gun
- Almost50
-
Almost50 Monkey Business
- Almost50
- Monkey Business
- Monkey Business
- Posts: 27276
- Joined: November 13, 2015
- Location: Right here.
Well.. I could lowkey see your point, with both BP neighbors designed to be -ve utilities for both sides. Scum get failed NKs and Town gets falls +ve (Via COMPLEX VIG though, NOT the TA/Neighbor Finder)In post 1567, Jacket wrote:
This is actually close to what I was thinking. Except it makes more sense for cool cookie to be the traitor, since mailman returns a positive to a traffic analyst but a negative to a neighbor finder.In post 1553, Almost50 wrote:T3's role was designed for Scum to identify their Traitor in at least 2 steps, and the Mailman is their "Miller" (gives them a false +ve)
Modded 2 Opens & 2 Large Themed games successfully.- House
-
House Survivor
- House
- Survivor
- Survivor
- Posts: 19605
- Joined: September 5, 2014
- Location: Home of Top Gun
You don't see the problem with TWO players claiming identical roles AS TOWN?In post 1576, Almost50 wrote:
Well.. I could lowkey see your point, with both BP neighbors designed to be -ve utilities for both sides. Scum get failed NKs and Town gets falls +ve (Via COMPLEX VIG though, NOT the TA/Neighbor Finder)In post 1567, Jacket wrote:
This is actually close to what I was thinking. Except it makes more sense for cool cookie to be the traitor, since mailman returns a positive to a traffic analyst but a negative to a neighbor finder.In post 1553, Almost50 wrote:T3's role was designed for Scum to identify their Traitor in at least 2 steps, and the Mailman is their "Miller" (gives them a false +ve)
That... completely flies over your head?
No. Just fucking no.
If you were town, you'd be screaming CC at Zen all day long.- T3
-
T3 He/himJack of All Trades
- T3
He/him- Jack of All Trades
- Jack of All Trades
- Posts: 9478
- Joined: February 19, 2021
- Pronoun: He/him
VOTE: houseIn post 1564, House wrote:
Wtf.In post 1553, Almost50 wrote:@STD: Your "I don't want to lim T3" was the final nail. I already started thinking of the situation when House volunteered to be shot instead of you, and again when he asserted redtea should shoot three again. It looked like a blatant attempt to deter the shot off you (and confirmed the team doesn't have a RB), but if you had voted T3 I probably would have thought it was too crazy to be true.
I don't want StD shot because he hasn't claimed, and if redtea says he's going to shoot there it could out even more power.
Where's your head?!
VOTE: A50
scum whiteknightingLarge Normal 241 is currently in play. PM me if you want to spectate or replace in!
https://www.mafiauniverse.com/forums/threads/37202 is in signups.- T3
-
T3 He/himJack of All Trades
- T3
He/him- Jack of All Trades
- Jack of All Trades
- Posts: 9478
- Joined: February 19, 2021
- Pronoun: He/him
VOTE: a50In post 1577, House wrote:
You don't see the problem with TWO players claiming identical roles AS TOWN?In post 1576, Almost50 wrote:
Well.. I could lowkey see your point, with both BP neighbors designed to be -ve utilities for both sides. Scum get failed NKs and Town gets falls +ve (Via COMPLEX VIG though, NOT the TA/Neighbor Finder)In post 1567, Jacket wrote:
This is actually close to what I was thinking. Except it makes more sense for cool cookie to be the traitor, since mailman returns a positive to a traffic analyst but a negative to a neighbor finder.In post 1553, Almost50 wrote:T3's role was designed for Scum to identify their Traitor in at least 2 steps, and the Mailman is their "Miller" (gives them a false +ve)
That... completely flies over your head?
No. Just fucking no.
If you were town, you'd be screaming CC at Zen all day long.
lmaoLarge Normal 241 is currently in play. PM me if you want to spectate or replace in!
https://www.mafiauniverse.com/forums/threads/37202 is in signups.- Almost50
-
Almost50 Monkey Business
- Almost50
- Monkey Business
- Monkey Business
- Posts: 27276
- Joined: November 13, 2015
- Location: Right here.
True that. I misread. You wanted to lim someone else today and shoot T3. Still a weird proposition given T3 is almost confirmed Scum either way.In post 1571, TheZenMan wrote:Wait what? I never said I was okay with a second shot on three, I said the complete opposite.
And I said I was fine with std shot but directly after I wrote I would rather have T3 shot and elim someone else D2.
But let me entertain the idea: Who do you want to lim in T3's stead?
Modded 2 Opens & 2 Large Themed games successfully.-
-
TheZenMan Goon
- Goon
- Goon
- Posts: 110
- Joined: September 17, 2021
Okay, so here is why I suspected A50 was the traitor. Now, first of all I just like to say that I was never VT like I claimed but actually BP VT neighbour. I claimed VT in hopes of drawing a night kill to me. A50 at that point agreed this was a good strat in the PT. But here is the comment he made that made me think he was the traitor:
Notice the breadcrumb he left about he should have claimed BP. That was a very unnecessary sentence to make, and to me seemed like he was signalling his teammates that I was actually a BP.In post 1503, Almost50 wrote:Here's what I suspect is going on: Regardless of cookie's alignment, T3 claims to have checked Dwlee (I assume whoever he responds to first is the target). He sleeps on it and checks Dwlee on N2 and comes back with a GUILTY on D3 (Dwlee can communicate but is not a neighbor). By the time we realize we have been fooled we're already in E-Lo it's GAME OVER with 3 mis-eliminatiosn and 2 Nks (assuming a 9 v 4 distribution). Meamwhile, Redtea is preoccupied and the Scum PRs are safe for the 2 nights it takes them to achieve this.
If this is true, three is more likely truly claiming VANILLA, because if he is a Traitor his death prevents the Scum win on D3 (although they can still achieve it on N3). Whether he's VT or a Goon though is up in the air (but I would slightly lean Goon since he wanted to draw the Vig to himself)
In hindsight I should not have claimed my BP. That would have been risky because of the Complex Vig thing, but it would have been beneficial to draw the NK and take Scum by surprise.
Based on the above, I don't think Scum would ALSO have a RB. We don't have that much strength in our roles as Town collectively. So..
IF T3 IS NOT ELIMINATED TODAY I BEG FOR readtea TO SHOOT HIM TONIGHT
And now coupled with the fact that he outright lied that I said redtea should shoot three again, when I in fact said the complete opposite. There is no way to interpret these actions as anything else but the traitor. Therefore I vote him.
VOTE: Almost50- T3
-
T3 He/himJack of All Trades
- T3
He/him- Jack of All Trades
- Jack of All Trades
- Posts: 9478
- Joined: February 19, 2021
- Pronoun: He/him
Ta/Neighbor Finder works PERFECTLY as a town role in the setup.Large Normal 241 is currently in play. PM me if you want to spectate or replace in!
https://www.mafiauniverse.com/forums/threads/37202 is in signups.- Almost50
-
Almost50 Monkey Business
- Almost50
- Monkey Business
- Monkey Business
- Posts: 27276
- Joined: November 13, 2015
- Location: Right here.
As a designer, I find it absolutely plausible.In post 1577, House wrote:You don't see the problem with TWO players claiming identical roles AS TOWN?
The thing is I only claimed BP (not 1-shot BP), and zen immediately claimed ONE-SHOT in the hood. I thought he wouldn't have if he was Scum, and even if he was the Traitor (hypothetically I was considering it, but in practice I really thought h was Town) I thought keeping him alive and talking to me in the hood was best because he probably can give me some pointers as to who the scums are.
Modded 2 Opens & 2 Large Themed games successfully.- Almost50
-
Almost50 Monkey Business
- Almost50
- Monkey Business
- Monkey Business
- Posts: 27276
- Joined: November 13, 2015
- Location: Right here.
Scum distancingIn post 1578, T3 wrote:
VOTE: houseIn post 1564, House wrote:
Wtf.In post 1553, Almost50 wrote:@STD: Your "I don't want to lim T3" was the final nail. I already started thinking of the situation when House volunteered to be shot instead of you, and again when he asserted redtea should shoot three again. It looked like a blatant attempt to deter the shot off you (and confirmed the team doesn't have a RB), but if you had voted T3 I probably would have thought it was too crazy to be true.
I don't want StD shot because he hasn't claimed, and if redtea says he's going to shoot there it could out even more power.
Where's your head?!
VOTE: A50
scum whiteknighting
Modded 2 Opens & 2 Large Themed games successfully.-
-
TheZenMan Goon
- Goon
- Goon
- Posts: 110
- Joined: September 17, 2021
This is the part that actually made me trust A50 the most in the beginning. He had the same role as me, and disclosed his before I did. That's what made me trust him because I figured we have the exact same role. But I gues BP traitor neighbour would claim to be a BP neighbour. I also found it weird that A50 went straight to claiming BP instead of trying to bait a shot with claiming Vanlilla. Then later he regrets it...In post 1577, House wrote:
You don't see the problem with TWO players claiming identical roles AS TOWN?In post 1576, Almost50 wrote:
Well.. I could lowkey see your point, with both BP neighbors designed to be -ve utilities for both sides. Scum get failed NKs and Town gets falls +ve (Via COMPLEX VIG though, NOT the TA/Neighbor Finder)In post 1567, Jacket wrote:
This is actually close to what I was thinking. Except it makes more sense for cool cookie to be the traitor, since mailman returns a positive to a traffic analyst but a negative to a neighbor finder.In post 1553, Almost50 wrote:T3's role was designed for Scum to identify their Traitor in at least 2 steps, and the Mailman is their "Miller" (gives them a false +ve)
That... completely flies over your head?
No. Just fucking no.
If you were town, you'd be screaming CC at Zen all day long.- House
-
House Survivor
- House
- Survivor
- Survivor
- Posts: 19605
- Joined: September 5, 2014
- Location: Home of Top Gun
Can you link to a (completed) game that has 2 of the same roles where both are town-aligned that gives you that belief?In post 1585, TheZenMan wrote:
This is the part that actually made me trust A50 the most in the beginning. He had the same role as me, and disclosed his before I did. That's what made me trust him because I figured we have the exact same role. But I gues BP traitor neighbour would claim to be a BP neighbour. I also found it weird that A50 went straight to claiming BP instead of trying to bait a shot with claiming Vanlilla. Then later he regrets it...In post 1577, House wrote:
You don't see the problem with TWO players claiming identical roles AS TOWN?In post 1576, Almost50 wrote:
Well.. I could lowkey see your point, with both BP neighbors designed to be -ve utilities for both sides. Scum get failed NKs and Town gets falls +ve (Via COMPLEX VIG though, NOT the TA/Neighbor Finder)In post 1567, Jacket wrote:
This is actually close to what I was thinking. Except it makes more sense for cool cookie to be the traitor, since mailman returns a positive to a traffic analyst but a negative to a neighbor finder.In post 1553, Almost50 wrote:T3's role was designed for Scum to identify their Traitor in at least 2 steps, and the Mailman is their "Miller" (gives them a false +ve)
That... completely flies over your head?
No. Just fucking no.
If you were town, you'd be screaming CC at Zen all day long.
Last I knew, that doesn't happen BECAUSE it leads to town cc'ing town.-
-
TheZenMan Goon
- Goon
- Goon
- Posts: 110
- Joined: September 17, 2021
True, you claimed only BP and then said in the alley that you were also 1-shot BP after I said it first. I can accept you misunderstanding me about T3 shot, but why leave that strange breadcrumb for me actually being BP?In post 1583, Almost50 wrote:
As a designer, I find it absolutely plausible.In post 1577, House wrote:You don't see the problem with TWO players claiming identical roles AS TOWN?
The thing is I only claimed BP (not 1-shot BP), and zen immediately claimed ONE-SHOT in the hood. I thought he wouldn't have if he was Scum, and even if he was the Traitor (hypothetically I was considering it, but in practice I really thought h was Town) I thought keeping him alive and talking to me in the hood was best because he probably can give me some pointers as to who the scums are.-
-
TheZenMan Goon
- Goon
- Goon
- Posts: 110
- Joined: September 17, 2021
I actually thought it was more likely we were both town because we had the same role. Like some strange mind games the designers were playing. I am not that familiar with setups here to know how plausible it was.In post 1586, House wrote:
Can you link to a (completed) game that has 2 of the same roles where both are town-aligned that gives you that belief?In post 1585, TheZenMan wrote:
This is the part that actually made me trust A50 the most in the beginning. He had the same role as me, and disclosed his before I did. That's what made me trust him because I figured we have the exact same role. But I gues BP traitor neighbour would claim to be a BP neighbour. I also found it weird that A50 went straight to claiming BP instead of trying to bait a shot with claiming Vanlilla. Then later he regrets it...In post 1577, House wrote:
You don't see the problem with TWO players claiming identical roles AS TOWN?In post 1576, Almost50 wrote:
Well.. I could lowkey see your point, with both BP neighbors designed to be -ve utilities for both sides. Scum get failed NKs and Town gets falls +ve (Via COMPLEX VIG though, NOT the TA/Neighbor Finder)In post 1567, Jacket wrote:
This is actually close to what I was thinking. Except it makes more sense for cool cookie to be the traitor, since mailman returns a positive to a traffic analyst but a negative to a neighbor finder.In post 1553, Almost50 wrote:T3's role was designed for Scum to identify their Traitor in at least 2 steps, and the Mailman is their "Miller" (gives them a false +ve)
That... completely flies over your head?
No. Just fucking no.
If you were town, you'd be screaming CC at Zen all day long.
Last I knew, that doesn't happen BECAUSE it leads to town cc'ing town.- House
-
House Survivor
- House
- Survivor
- Survivor
- Posts: 19605
- Joined: September 5, 2014
- Location: Home of Top Gun
Counterclaiming is a thing because scum claim roles that town actually has.In post 1588, TheZenMan wrote:
I actually thought it was more likely we were both town because we had the same role. Like some strange mind games the designers were playing. I am not that familiar with setups here to know how plausible it was.In post 1586, House wrote:
Can you link to a (completed) game that has 2 of the same roles where both are town-aligned that gives you that belief?In post 1585, TheZenMan wrote:
This is the part that actually made me trust A50 the most in the beginning. He had the same role as me, and disclosed his before I did. That's what made me trust him because I figured we have the exact same role. But I gues BP traitor neighbour would claim to be a BP neighbour. I also found it weird that A50 went straight to claiming BP instead of trying to bait a shot with claiming Vanlilla. Then later he regrets it...In post 1577, House wrote:
You don't see the problem with TWO players claiming identical roles AS TOWN?In post 1576, Almost50 wrote:
Well.. I could lowkey see your point, with both BP neighbors designed to be -ve utilities for both sides. Scum get failed NKs and Town gets falls +ve (Via COMPLEX VIG though, NOT the TA/Neighbor Finder)In post 1567, Jacket wrote:
This is actually close to what I was thinking. Except it makes more sense for cool cookie to be the traitor, since mailman returns a positive to a traffic analyst but a negative to a neighbor finder.In post 1553, Almost50 wrote:T3's role was designed for Scum to identify their Traitor in at least 2 steps, and the Mailman is their "Miller" (gives them a false +ve)
That... completely flies over your head?
No. Just fucking no.
If you were town, you'd be screaming CC at Zen all day long.
Last I knew, that doesn't happen BECAUSE it leads to town cc'ing town.
If it came from both alignments, there would be zero utility in counterclaiming.- Almost50
-
Almost50 Monkey Business
- Almost50
- Monkey Business
- Monkey Business
- Posts: 27276
- Joined: November 13, 2015
- Location: Right here.
I would urge everybody to calm down and try to think things over from at least 2 different perspectives.
My proposed solve was originally mean to be a PM top the mod (I didn't think it was worth requesting a private personal thread, so was going to "vent it all out" for post-game bragging rights.
Then it hit me my solve -if correct- could actually end the game by tomorrow. We lim one scum today, shoot another by night and lim the third tomorrow. I rethought ot and it seemed plausible, so I decided I should post in the main thread instead.
Modded 2 Opens & 2 Large Themed games successfully.- Jacket
-
Jacket Goon
- Jacket
- Goon
- Goon
- Posts: 527
- Joined: September 16, 2021
https://forum.mafiascum.net/viewtopic.php?f=2&t=87504In post 1586, House wrote:
Can you link to a (completed) game that has 2 of the same roles where both are town-aligned that gives you that belief?In post 1585, TheZenMan wrote:
This is the part that actually made me trust A50 the most in the beginning. He had the same role as me, and disclosed his before I did. That's what made me trust him because I figured we have the exact same role. But I gues BP traitor neighbour would claim to be a BP neighbour. I also found it weird that A50 went straight to claiming BP instead of trying to bait a shot with claiming Vanlilla. Then later he regrets it...In post 1577, House wrote:
You don't see the problem with TWO players claiming identical roles AS TOWN?In post 1576, Almost50 wrote:
Well.. I could lowkey see your point, with both BP neighbors designed to be -ve utilities for both sides. Scum get failed NKs and Town gets falls +ve (Via COMPLEX VIG though, NOT the TA/Neighbor Finder)In post 1567, Jacket wrote:
This is actually close to what I was thinking. Except it makes more sense for cool cookie to be the traitor, since mailman returns a positive to a traffic analyst but a negative to a neighbor finder.In post 1553, Almost50 wrote:T3's role was designed for Scum to identify their Traitor in at least 2 steps, and the Mailman is their "Miller" (gives them a false +ve)
That... completely flies over your head?
No. Just fucking no.
If you were town, you'd be screaming CC at Zen all day long.
Last I knew, that doesn't happen BECAUSE it leads to town cc'ing town.
This game had a 1-shot even night cop and a Night 2 Cop (effectively the same role). I think trying to outguess the mod is bad. (To be clear, I scumread T3 on play. Not just role spec stuff.)-
-
TheZenMan
- Jacket
-
Jacket Goon
- Jacket
- House
-
House Survivor
- House
- Survivor
- Survivor
- Posts: 19605
- Joined: September 5, 2014
- Location: Home of Top Gun
Funny how your "solve" flew out right after I got cold feet on the T3 wagon.In post 1590, Almost50 wrote:I would urge everybody to calm down and try to think things over from at least 2 different perspectives.
My proposed solve was originally mean to be a PM top the mod (I didn't think it was worth requesting a private personal thread, so was going to "vent it all out" for post-game bragging rights.
Then it hit me my solve -if correct- could actually end the game by tomorrow. We lim one scum today, shoot another by night and lim the third tomorrow. I rethought ot and it seemed plausible, so I decided I should post in the main thread instead.
But I think you're "my" traitor?
It is for to laugh.- Jacket
-
Jacket Goon
- Jacket
- Goon
- Goon
- Posts: 527
- Joined: September 16, 2021
- Almost50
-
Almost50 Monkey Business
- Almost50
- Monkey Business
- Monkey Business
- Posts: 27276
- Joined: November 13, 2015
- Location: Right here.
Isn't calling you a Traitor already saying you're BP; given the "info" cookie gave us on D1?In post 1592, TheZenMan wrote:Just wanna say that me voting for A50 is not a reactionary OMGUS to him saying I'm traitor. If not for that breadcrumb about me being BP he left and then outing me I would instead sit here trying to convince A50 he is wrong.
Modded 2 Opens & 2 Large Themed games successfully.- T3
-
T3 He/himJack of All Trades
- T3
He/him- Jack of All Trades
- Jack of All Trades
- Posts: 9478
- Joined: February 19, 2021
- Pronoun: He/him
I recently played a mini normal with 2 cops. But this is different.In post 1586, House wrote:
Can you link to a (completed) game that has 2 of the same roles where both are town-aligned that gives you that belief?In post 1585, TheZenMan wrote:
This is the part that actually made me trust A50 the most in the beginning. He had the same role as me, and disclosed his before I did. That's what made me trust him because I figured we have the exact same role. But I gues BP traitor neighbour would claim to be a BP neighbour. I also found it weird that A50 went straight to claiming BP instead of trying to bait a shot with claiming Vanlilla. Then later he regrets it...In post 1577, House wrote:
You don't see the problem with TWO players claiming identical roles AS TOWN?In post 1576, Almost50 wrote:
Well.. I could lowkey see your point, with both BP neighbors designed to be -ve utilities for both sides. Scum get failed NKs and Town gets falls +ve (Via COMPLEX VIG though, NOT the TA/Neighbor Finder)In post 1567, Jacket wrote:
This is actually close to what I was thinking. Except it makes more sense for cool cookie to be the traitor, since mailman returns a positive to a traffic analyst but a negative to a neighbor finder.In post 1553, Almost50 wrote:T3's role was designed for Scum to identify their Traitor in at least 2 steps, and the Mailman is their "Miller" (gives them a false +ve)
That... completely flies over your head?
No. Just fucking no.
If you were town, you'd be screaming CC at Zen all day long.
Last I knew, that doesn't happen BECAUSE it leads to town cc'ing town.Large Normal 241 is currently in play. PM me if you want to spectate or replace in!
https://www.mafiauniverse.com/forums/threads/37202 is in signups.- House
-
House Survivor
- House
- Survivor
- Survivor
- Posts: 19605
- Joined: September 5, 2014
- Location: Home of Top Gun
How so?In post 1597, T3 wrote:
I recently played a mini normal with 2 cops. But this is different.In post 1586, House wrote:
Can you link to a (completed) game that has 2 of the same roles where both are town-aligned that gives you that belief?In post 1585, TheZenMan wrote:
This is the part that actually made me trust A50 the most in the beginning. He had the same role as me, and disclosed his before I did. That's what made me trust him because I figured we have the exact same role. But I gues BP traitor neighbour would claim to be a BP neighbour. I also found it weird that A50 went straight to claiming BP instead of trying to bait a shot with claiming Vanlilla. Then later he regrets it...In post 1577, House wrote:
You don't see the problem with TWO players claiming identical roles AS TOWN?In post 1576, Almost50 wrote:
Well.. I could lowkey see your point, with both BP neighbors designed to be -ve utilities for both sides. Scum get failed NKs and Town gets falls +ve (Via COMPLEX VIG though, NOT the TA/Neighbor Finder)In post 1567, Jacket wrote:
This is actually close to what I was thinking. Except it makes more sense for cool cookie to be the traitor, since mailman returns a positive to a traffic analyst but a negative to a neighbor finder.In post 1553, Almost50 wrote:T3's role was designed for Scum to identify their Traitor in at least 2 steps, and the Mailman is their "Miller" (gives them a false +ve)
That... completely flies over your head?
No. Just fucking no.
If you were town, you'd be screaming CC at Zen all day long.
Last I knew, that doesn't happen BECAUSE it leads to town cc'ing town.
Link?-
-
TheZenMan Goon
- Goon
- Goon
- Posts: 110
- Joined: September 17, 2021
Ah true, I guess you are guilty of only leaving a breadcrumb for scum to find out I'm actually BP. That is the main reason I think you are a traitor anyway.In post 1596, Almost50 wrote:
Isn't calling you a Traitor already saying you're BP; given the "info" cookie gave us on D1?In post 1592, TheZenMan wrote:Just wanna say that me voting for A50 is not a reactionary OMGUS to him saying I'm traitor. If not for that breadcrumb about me being BP he left and then outing me I would instead sit here trying to convince A50 he is wrong.
Copyright © MafiaScum. All rights reserved.
- House
- T3
- Almost50
- Jacket
- House
- Jacket
- Almost50
- House
- House
- Almost50
- Almost50
- T3
- Almost50
- T3
- T3
- House
- Almost50
- House