Slaughter Hour: Grand Debut | Deliberation Room Blue

[petapan]

it may possibly just be that she's adopted a wildly different playstyle for this account, looking at her other games, and i shouldn't try to read too much into comparisons

[petapan]

i mean, we could probably discuss ulnaya once all reunited right? Having half the game missing isn't really helping, especially when one of those guys is the accused party

i


we have to pick someone now and i'm trying to sort through that

[petapan]

Subject: Slaughter Hour: The Grand Debut! | Event Four

like everyone slightly moving the second duelist while not really making it clear they are is suspicious yeah? and how everyone is ignoring what happened last night from toog unwnd vote on is very very confusing

what is it you want to be acknowledged

toog votes unwnd to e-2 when toog is the most likely other duelist, then unwnd selfvotes to e-1 when toog/unwnd would be the duelists, then gamma moves the second duelist off of toogeloo while asking unwnd who second duelist should be?? which just doesn't make any sense when we are trying to have two mafias in the duel,

like it just doesn't feel like town behaviour from any of them?

Subject: Slaughter Hour: The Grand Debut! | Event Four

well i see what you're saying but i don't think they're all scum doing that. their actions being irrational don't necessarily mean they're scum motivated

nono i agree that it is somewhat unlikely all three are mafia together but two seems possible, and it feels like it should be something that is potentially sortable and it felt like everyone going on with day

Subject: Slaughter Hour: The Grand Debut! | Event Four

like it just doesn't feel like town behaviour from any of them?

i don't really see how this is scummy from toog or unwnd and gamma is close to locktown to me anyway though i do think that behavior was anti-town from him

i didn't realize saber was now the second biggest vote-getter now so sorry

why would a town be rushing a duel that included them? like i could theorize information that mafia could potentially have that would make it make sense? but i can't really think of a town motivation for it,

nvm she's scummy

[petapan]

gypyx do you even have an opinion on who you want to nominate

[Gypyx]

i mean, we could probably discuss ulnaya once all reunited right? Having half the game missing isn't really helping, especially when one of those guys is the accused party

i


we have to pick someone now and i'm trying to sort through that

ya i agree

but like, she's never really been discussed before, so that's a bit problematic

especially since it's probably not gonna be as straight as a simple elimination

pedit : i'm more inclined towards infinity but could do ulnaya / toog with compelling reasons

[petapan]

i'm more inclined towards infinity

why

[SirCakez]

Who is shiki

[SirCakez]

If we want to be the most diplomatic then we put up Toog again
Wild child pick would be Uly

[petapan]

Who is shiki

ulyana

[petapan]

i have zero desire to go back to the well on toog atm

[Gypyx]

i'm more inclined towards infinity

why

- convincing case
- wasn't a big fan of her before reading the case, not really in a SR way but i was fine if she just spontaneously exploded all of a sudden (can't recall why i even put her as a 1.25 in my readslist, like actually lol)
- think the other side will agree with the scumread if they get a say in it, which is also quite important as i think it's likely they do

[petapan]

- convincing case

whose case and why is it convincing

[petapan]

also i don't get why we should have any consideration for what the other side will think about our nomination, just vote who you think is scum!!!!!!!! fuck!!!!!!!!!

[Ydrasse]

gypyx buddy you’re worrying me a little

i’ll revisit ulyana tbh i wrote her off as town from tone + havent reread this game or even really read it with intent until lately so when i’m home or on breaks i’ll do that

[petapan]

i just had an awful thought


we're playing tenet but can't even read the other thread and have to vote on them and not each other



i hate it here now

[SirCakez]

i have zero desire to go back to the well on toog atm

What changed

[petapan]

i have zero desire to go back to the well on toog atm

What changed

i just

hm

it feels lazy? like let's just nominate the lurker troll again

where i think with the flip it's more important to go over people with a more critical eye

[Gypyx]

also i don't get why we should have any consideration for what the other side will think about our nomination, just vote who you think is scum!!!!!!!! fuck!!!!!!!!!

yeah normally i'd say that but like, event 1/2 basically was "fuck you, you vote for who you think is scum but actually give them a town ability"

so i'm expecting the mindgames really, but like if you don't wanna take em' into consideration fine by me

[Gypyx]

gypyx buddy you’re worrying me a little

i'll make it a lot then

(nah in all seriousness kinda sad that my current posting raises eyebrows but i really don't know what else to say so hopefully my inner greenie finally decides to get out of that bucket of red paint)

[petapan]

i think toog voting on dunn day 1 is at least okay


even though as mafia i'd absolutely want a teammate voted into the chair. don't get the sense that was the strategy here

[Gypyx]

- convincing case

whose case and why is it convincing

unwnd, and as for why, it's kinda like, i feel the case puts into words what i'm feeling when reading infinity, not really sure if that's the correct way to word it

[Gamma Emerald]

epic

dunn was scum when he didn’t spin the barrel and started larping as the guy from princess diaries lol

yassss queen love that you saw the Vizzini vibes too

[petapan]

also as far as the nomination goes we don't know if it'll be one or the other or if we have to decide to kill both or what

the second minigame was difficult for town to win if pitted against scum, it would have been extremely hard to manipulate the votes in a way to get 2 scum into the duel but the move was just

vote for who you think was scum and hope it works out

that's all we can do

[Gamma Emerald]

there’s a certain

way she questions things that i think it’s like... she cares about what happens i feel like and not in a scum anxiety way but trying to solve even if the route of questioning can be a bit not helpful at times

yah this makes sense, her questioning does kinda come off as strong Socratic method thinking

i mean, we could probably discuss ulnaya once all reunited right? Having half the game missing isn't really helping, especially when one of those guys is the accused party

yeah this factored into a lot of my choice of who not to execute in the second event, there were several slots that seemed suspicious but I couldn't effectively press my reads while I was the only one able to talk

[Gypyx]

also as far as the nomination goes we don't know if it'll be one or the other or if we have to decide to kill both or what

the second minigame was difficult for town to win if pitted against scum, it would have been extremely hard to manipulate the votes in a way to get 2 scum into the duel but the move was just

vote for who you think was scum and hope it works out

that's all we can do

that's a fair viewpoint alright, i doubt most event will be as random as 3rd one but we can't really tell

i'll probably ship whatever goes on anyways