Slaughter Hour: Grand Debut | Deliberation Room Blue

[petapan]

p sure that's a joke from taly jsyk
also D1 ends at page 70 so that's prolly a solid stopping point

yeah duh its a good joke Taly's avatar is a very large nosed bird and I appreciate it

at page 70 but I'm gonna skip over your thoughts on before choosing an execution for the most part since my opinion on you largely doesn't matter until this part of the event ends
also for some reason I had it in my head that you shot Toog first before the sabotage and not Galron from my skim before replacing in? huh

I still don't feel like I have any particularly strong scum reads - skitter's still my strongest choice but I'm probably biasing myself against her at least a little because I know she's a strong scum player? aside from that my gut says Ydrasse feels a little scummy and I at least wouldn't be surprised if one of Ulyana/Toog were scum? meh

more tomorrowwww

think skitter is probably town but not necessarily off the stuff you've read, she did start going after dunn fairly aggressively on day 2, i dumped quotes in here. could bus, but from what i've seen she tends not to go after partners that aggressively out of nowhere

[petapan]

ulyana's style this game is tough for me to figure out

ultimately i don't think the lack of interaction with regard to dunn is entirely damning, i'e learned from enough observation that there can be no interaction entirely incidentally and it's not like dunn was active

in the end the way she's questioning people feels pointed enough

the one weird thing is her getting demonstrative about unwnd selfvoting on day 2 and wanting to slow things down, which looked good, but then somehow concluding no one in that exchange looked town and i didn't really like that


it's very hard for me to overcome the notion that she tends to be lower activity as scum with what she's done this game

i don't think i want to vote her this phase

[petapan]

i'm like 40 posts into the iso and i want to

VOTE: infinity

i don't know why i ever had a townread on her

[petapan]

aside from the dunn interactions, overall play is just lackluster and it feels like all her votes have been mediocre, doesn't feel like there's a process aimed toward actually figuring anything out

[petapan]

i feel like basically no other vote is acceptable to me

[petapan]

that vote on gypyx from infinity in 2485 is so bad

[Gamma Emerald]

I think I'm willing to fold on skitter before I fold on infinity
I also just said I think the gypyx progression, while weird, doesn't have a straightforward scum agenda you can to it imo

[petapan]

this is lazy skimread stuff but i can try to go into citations tomorrow if necessary

[petapan]

the scum agenda is trying to push someone who is town and misreading my questioning of him as being antagonistic in nature, hoping i'd push him

[petapan]

i sleep now though

[Gamma Emerald]

the scum agenda is trying to push someone who is town and misreading my questioning of

him

as being antagonistic in nature, hoping i'd push

him

I'm assuming the bolded pronouns refer to gypyx

[Gamma Emerald]

...I'm thinking about something

[Gypyx]

kinda a prod dodge hi

just in a "dunno what to say" mood there, and not feeling like acting confident

Gooey going in and actively trying to reingnite the game is a pretty good look in my eyes

really hope we won't stay split like that for much longer, that separation feels so inconvinient

VOTE: Infinity

that's E-1 y'all guys guys guys guys

[Morning Tweet]

"Split Judgement - Team Blue"

Event Rules

---

DECISION 4.5

Team Pink Members:

ulyana, skitter30, Infinity 324, Toogeloo, Dwlee99, Taly

Infinity 324 [3]:

Saber, petapan, Gypyx

ulyana [1]:

SirCakez

Toogeloo [1]:

Gamma Emerald

skitter30 [1]:

Gammagooey

Not Voting [1]:

Ydrasse

With 7 players on the team, it takes 4 votes to decide. If deadline is reached, plurality is in effect.

Link to deadline timer. If the other team makes a decision, the timer is set to 48 hours.

[/mech]

Now playing..

♫

Young the Giant - Cough Syrup

♫
                        

▶ ❚❚ ────────────────────●────────── 3:13 / 4:09

                       

[Gamma Emerald]

VOTE: Ulyana
I still feel like Toog would be the BEST nomination but I’m working with what I’ve got.
I really hope this is just a straight-up gladiator match because if one of my strongest TRs dies to fuckery after you FOOLS voted her into the hot seat, there will be no room to hide. I’m basically just hoping the other side actually has the ability to pick someone sensible, I feel like the ACTUAL consensus here is on Ulyana but somehow Infinity is at N-1.

[Gamma Emerald]

Looking at ISOs I don’t trust the other side to make an acceptable choice on this end, so I’m sticking to my guns. Get off Infinity, NOW. I am invoking Burden of Proficiency on this one. My recent performance has been good enough IMO that I think I’ve earned this.

[Ydrasse]

nope sorry, i read infinity’s iso and wow that is bad.

she consistently had dunn just out of danger; in her poe but always a bit higher than the people that she voted and the only time she caved was when a wagon cropped up.

i’m on mobile so i can’t quote easily but she has an early game solve as like, me/dunn/galron/cephrir, and assuming gooey is townslot (i think so atm) thats... horribly wrong and i don’t think that infinity is usually that far off

the reasons that she townreads dunn enough are weak too, the fact he was an early wagon, accepting one reply from him as fair enough; her scumread extends from pooky’s reasoning and not her own. also means she rated toog + dunn the same on play as scumleans which, uh, hm

[Gamma Emerald]

also means she rated toog + dunn the same on play as scumleans which, uh, hm

where is this

[Ydrasse]

3187

[Ydrasse]

like i kinda hate that bottom tier and then toog and dunn floating juuuuuust above it is hmmm

[Ydrasse]

it makes me feel like because she doesn’t uh, care btwn toog and dunn the dunn sheepvote is to look good

[Ydrasse]

esp if they’re s/s lol

[Ydrasse]

well maybe not especially but like i hope people get it

[Gamma Emerald]

i don’t think that infinity is usually that far off

eh it's old af but I did find a game where she was consistently off the mark
and I think this obsession over "WHO HAS THE WORST INTERACTIONS WITH THE FLIPPED SCUM?" is honestly starting to become a smokescreen for actual scum. I don't think Dunn's entire team was so inept as to tie themselves to their buddy like that (yes this is a self-burn for Panic Room)

[Ydrasse]

.... i mean it’s not tying

and tbh i’m not even looking at their interactions so much as how infinity maneuvered around dunn

i think that wagon was pretty last minute + for a good majority of time dunn was nowhere near being shot down so it’s not like she had time to readjust the way she was treating him