Open 834: Trust Fall - Game Over

[Tammy]

whats everyones read on cookie?
i feel even with those 3 posts fae has* made some of the most ai posts yet

ebwop

cookie's posts felt a bit stilted at parts like the I'm watching you bit and the but how well do you know each other thing. Without more posts to see if that's just their natural tone and writing style though they're just mild pings.

[MafMen]

whats everyones read on cookie?
i feel even with those 3 posts fae have made some of the most ai posts yet

felt like the worst sus was pretty bad so i asked faer about it, besides that nothing why

i have a strong townread and alot of people (unless my brain is remembering shit that didnt happen, which happens more then id like to admit) disagree with my read and so i just wanted to see everyones opinions on faer

i think faer tw sus was a pretty genuine read even if i feel its one thats a little misplaced, what would you say is wrong with it?

[PookyTheMagicalBear]

on a post per towniness level Faer is S-Tier

[PookyTheMagicalBear]

on a towniness per post level Faer is S-Tier

fixed

[Infinity 324]

i don't see what's genuine about it and it just seems wrong, like scum wouldn't try to trick people about the rules they're in the op

could be wrong scum or wrong town

[MafMen]

whats everyones read on cookie?
i feel even with those 3 posts fae has* made some of the most ai posts yet

ebwop

cookie's posts felt a bit stilted at parts like the I'm watching you bit and the but how well do you know each other thing. Without more posts to see if that's just their natural tone and writing style though they're just mild pings.

hmm okay yeah i can see totally see how the tone there can ping somebody

idk if im allowed to make a read like this but judging by faer join date i think it can get passed off as awkward newbie vocabulary

[MafMen]

i don't see what's genuine about it and it just seems wrong, like scum wouldn't try to trick people about the rules they're in the op

could be wrong scum or wrong town

genuine as in they seem to really believe it

while i definitely think fae is thinking about it all wrong the reasons dont seem to be the kind of waffle youd see from scum

[the worst]

i think faer tw sus was a pretty genuine read even if i feel its one thats a little misplaced

hmm interesting. i liked prism's snark at me more than cookies' but i liked cookies' post for another reason.

[MafMen]

on a towniness per post level Faer is S-Tier

fixed

LOL thats one way to look at it yea

[PookyTheMagicalBear]

genuine as in they seem to really believe it

while i definitely think fae is thinking about it all wrong the reasons dont seem to be the kind of waffle youd see from scum

mindmeld here

[PookyTheMagicalBear]

there's no way you're not the person I think you are

but I guess it's not implausible that you've forgotten who you are.

[Tammy]

whats everyones read on cookie?
i feel even with those 3 posts fae has* made some of the most ai posts yet

ebwop

cookie's posts felt a bit stilted at parts like the I'm watching you bit and the but how well do you know each other thing. Without more posts to see if that's just their natural tone and writing style though they're just mild pings.

hmm okay yeah i can see totally see how the tone there can ping somebody

idk if im allowed to make a read like this but judging by faer join date i think it can get passed off as awkward newbie vocabulary

No, I think that's entirely fair. Could be a newbie awkwardness, could just be writing style in general, could be not having much to comment on, but I don't see the towniness off the bat that you guys see.

[Tammy]

I'm getting a total kick out of pooky's alt hunting!

[MafMen]

on the flip side faer activity in previous games is levels above this so idk
still worth townreading i think though

[Tammy]

Also y'all my cat is snoring so loud right now it's so cute.

[the worst]

love kitty snores <3

[Infinity 324]

mafmen keeps pinging me

[the worst]

of the high posters i think mafmen is most likely to be scum
i also always think that about mafmen on d1 lol

[PookyTheMagicalBear]

No, I think that's entirely fair. Could be a newbie awkwardness, could just be writing style in general, could be not having much to comment on, but I don't see the towniness off the bat that you guys see.

I think when people use a reason to townread someone that's so convoluted/weird/notgreat that it's unlikely to be "faked" then it's probably just true.

scum tend to want their reasoning to be like "good"

[MafMen]

there's no way you're not the person I think you are

but I guess it's not implausible that you've forgotten who you are.

true that is a very real possibility

[PookyTheMagicalBear]

wait actually I guess you might not know who I am because I'm not on my main main.

that makes sense.

few people even know what that one is but I guess you would be one of them.

[Tammy]

No, I think that's entirely fair. Could be a newbie awkwardness, could just be writing style in general, could be not having much to comment on, but I don't see the towniness off the bat that you guys see.

I think when people use a reason to townread someone that's so convoluted/weird/notgreat that it's unlikely to be "faked" then it's probably just true.

scum tend to want their reasoning to be like "good"

Which town read did you think fit that bill?

And considering the possibility that cookie is not an alt and is rather new, do you really think that reasoning holds?

(Also, clearly you've never seen me as scum. I've given some stinker reasoning for reads.)

[MafMen]

i dont think bad reasoning = town
its more how much the player seems to believe their read

[PookyTheMagicalBear]

oh i was talking about the scumread on duckie lol

i think it applies even more for scumreads lol

[PookyTheMagicalBear]

I can hear Prism crinkling her nose in disapproval and muttering "trivially easy to fake".