Mini Normal 2246 - Game Over

[Gamma Emerald]

mine

[Wiki]

Just think a bit why the scum Gera need to write this? If he reads the game, he knows what ppl think about the claim and Wiki. If he reads badly, it doesnt mean he is a scum. He confessed he doesnt read much. So either he is suicidal mafia, or he can be anyone. These principles can be townie. Not 100% of course

[Dwlee99]

Wiki  66 posts
Dwlee99  59 posts
Iconeum 51 posts
T3 43 posts
Andresvmb  33 posts
Datisi  32 posts
Gamma 28 posts
Three 22 posts
Selynee  22 posts
Almost50 16 posts
geraintm 2 posts
Dorsey 1 posts
IOnlyAskWhy 0 posts

I will never believe that the whole mafia team is at the bottom of activity list, playing absolutely silently.

Ty for bringing this to my attention Gamma.

Yea this is a bad assumption. Scum play here is complete hit or miss for some people and sometimes scum just lay completely low

[Dwlee99]

I wonder if I'll finally be N1'd

[Gamma Emerald]

Gamma, I need your explanations about your confidence about every of your solid townies.

well in your case it's because you exude all the newbtown energy
I liked how Three was questioning me earlier, but I'm also curious to see his response to pressure
andres I'd expect would be more awkward as scum given his incredible towngame streak
icon and datisi I'm somewhat following the groupthink on

I think that covers all of them, some of these aren't true locks, and that will be the case until I post a full PoE

[Dwlee99]

Not dealing with jail

Wiki

Dwlee99
Iconeum
Datisi
Andresvmb

T3
Selynee (preflips)
Three

Gamma Emerald
Almost50
Dorsey

Salsabil Faria
geraintm

Pedit: there's 4 scum, 6 is a fine pool to be looking in, here's where I'm at though

Quoting for new page
Gamma if you're town do you think bottom 4 wins?

[geraintm]

Just think a bit why the scum Gera need to write this? If he reads the game, he knows what ppl think about the claim and Wiki. If he reads badly, it doesnt mean he is a scum. He confessed he doesnt read much. So either he is suicidal mafia, or he can be anyone. These principles can be townie. Not 100% of course

i barely read the game.
my 2nd post had like...7 pages between it and my first and then my 3rd post had 9 more pages.
as i consider Day 1 useless, and this game i know people will be especially useless Day 1....i aint going to pay too much attention. but if i see someone hard claim something i am just going to accept it.

[Gamma Emerald]

Salsa rolled scum too I think

i also thought her intro was tonally *off*, though at this point i feel like i have way too many scumleans, even for this game

I think I've got a tell for Salsa atp, but it needs time to work properly

[Andresvmb]

See I correctly read you as Scum in a different game because I felt you were wordy. And I do know you get nervous as Scum. My invitation to fight me was to see how willing you were to confront a direct SR of your slot. I just don’t have an answer yet.

i thought it was because i pushed every single possible misyeet... which you only figured out once we killed you, anyway

though thinking back to that game, i recall picking up a few scumreads along the way and willingly getting into fights there (despite being admittedly nervous), so i'm not sure if that's like, a helpful metric for reading my slot.

That was the nail in the coffin. The fact that you kept pushing all of the mis-executions. But I’m talking about how you felt in the early part of the game. I do distinctly recall Scum Reading you then.

[Gamma Emerald]

Not dealing with jail

Wiki

Dwlee99
Iconeum
Datisi
Andresvmb

T3
Selynee (preflips)
Three

Gamma Emerald
Almost50
Dorsey

Salsabil Faria
geraintm

Pedit: there's 4 scum, 6 is a fine pool to be looking in, here's where I'm at though

Quoting for new page
Gamma if you're town do you think bottom 4 wins?

possibly, the only one who's even close to piercing into my townblock rn is A50 and that requires him to actually towntell for me

[Almost50]

I have NO towntells. Only SCUM tells.

[Wiki]

Wiki  66 posts
Dwlee99  59 posts
Iconeum 51 posts
T3 43 posts
Andresvmb  33 posts
Datisi  32 posts
Gamma 28 posts
Three 22 posts
Selynee  22 posts
Almost50 16 posts
geraintm 2 posts
Dorsey 1 posts
IOnlyAskWhy 0 posts

I will never believe that the whole mafia team is at the bottom of activity list, playing absolutely silently.

Ty for bringing this to my attention Gamma.

Yea this is a bad assumption. Scum play here is complete hit or miss for some people and sometimes scum just lay completely low

Bull...
Such a team doesnt exist and has never existed in any games.

[Dwlee99]

Well you're wrong lol

[Gamma Emerald]

I could probably find at least two instances of scum all being less active in recent memory

[Datisi]

I wanted to vote Selynee but I don’t know - I am no longer feeling that vote.

i still find her pretty suspicious (it's just i dislike the wagon on her moreso), care to convince me otherwise?

Selynee was called out on her indecisiveness and as a result, produces a long post about DW to then conclude that… she doesn’t know DW’s alignment? That didn’t strike me as particularly Scummy.

yeah, that's fair. i could be playing devil's advocate here and argue that that's potentially a scummy move because she's kinda being arrogant and doubling down on "i have nothing to read dwlee on either way, why are you giving me shit for being indecisive", but (1) i'm not sure if i believe that, and (2) i think that's a move that is more likely to come from experienced scum, and i don't remember seeing sel around much, which means i'd have to do research. which i currently don't want to do.

also noted on the other game. i think i was in 3 stressful games at the time so i don't remember the early parts very well, so i'm gonna assume you're correct

[Wiki]

Just think a bit why the scum Gera need to write this? If he reads the game, he knows what ppl think about the claim and Wiki. If he reads badly, it doesnt mean he is a scum. He confessed he doesnt read much. So either he is suicidal mafia, or he can be anyone. These principles can be townie. Not 100% of course

i barely read the game.
my 2nd post had like...7 pages between it and my first and then my 3rd post had 9 more pages.
as i consider Day 1 useless, and this game i know people will be especially useless Day 1....i aint going to pay too much attention. but if i see someone hard claim something i am just going to accept it.

Town post. Many scums are voting Gera.
This is not to elim Selynee, if she is a scum. Im not sure about her though.

[geraintm]

If traitor game then Gera > salsa > a50 has a decent chance of winning imo

this post is like....825 times wrong

[Datisi]

Just think a bit why the scum Gera need to write this? If he reads the game, he knows what ppl think about the claim and Wiki. If he reads badly, it doesnt mean he is a scum. He confessed he doesnt read much. So either he is suicidal mafia, or he can be anyone. These principles can be townie. Not 100% of course

geraintm gives me a vibe of scum who saw a town player acting weird/wacky and decided to use it as an excuse for votes. like it's very easy for scum to slip on a "policy yeet people who are fakeclaiming" bullshit. especially with his "meta" of hating day 1 and not caring about providing content and etc.

[Selynee]

Just think a bit why the scum Gera need to write this? If he reads the game, he knows what ppl think about the claim and Wiki. If he reads badly, it doesnt mean he is a scum. He confessed he doesnt read much. So either he is suicidal mafia, or he can be anyone. These principles can be townie. Not 100% of course

as i consider Day 1 useless, and this game i know people will be especially useless Day 1....i aint going to pay too much attention.

Nice vote of confidence.

But have to agree with Wiki here (well, at least conclusion), that's not really enough to scumread them

[Datisi]

If traitor game then Gera > salsa > a50 has a decent chance of winning imo

this post is like....825 times wrong

is this geraintm having... thoughts? on day 1?

[Andresvmb]

I wanted to vote Selynee but I don’t know - I am no longer feeling that vote.

i still find her pretty suspicious (it's just i dislike the wagon on her moreso), care to convince me otherwise?

Selynee was called out on her indecisiveness and as a result, produces a long post about DW to then conclude that… she doesn’t know DW’s alignment? That didn’t strike me as particularly Scummy.

yeah, that's fair. i could be playing devil's advocate here and argue that that's potentially a scummy move because she's kinda being arrogant and doubling down on "i have nothing to read dwlee on either way, why are you giving me shit for being indecisive", but (1) i'm not sure if i believe that, and (2) i think that's a move that is more likely to come from experienced scum, and i don't remember seeing sel around much, which means i'd have to do research. which i currently don't want to do.

also noted on the other game. i think i was in 3 stressful games at the time so i don't remember the early parts very well, so i'm gonna assume you're correct

https://forum.mafiascum.net/viewtopic.p ... #p12608006

That’s the post I was talking about.

[Wiki]

So funny how Dwlee99 is trying to show how he is searching scums the second day in row. Just look at his fake attempts. Check his iso. Today. And remember how he was looking for scums yesterday, telling to everyone, that he has a nice plan for win. Ansolutely useless activity. What he has done already? Nothing useful. This is not a townie.
I will check later who saw us as tvt.
This funny list he made today and repeating it pn new page to show how useful he is, lol.

Dwlee is mafia, and there are maximum 1 mafia in people with 0-1-2 posts in my list. He didnt like my idea, that mafia are among actove players too, though he has no reasons at all to argue with me in that.

[Datisi]

i mean, to me it looks like dwlee is genuinely solving, and

their

posts so far definitely remind me of previous town games i've played with

them

while you are town solely based on vibes and because i am skeptical scum this consistently puts a foot in their mouth

[Wiki]

Not dealing with jail

Wiki

Dwlee99
Iconeum
Datisi
Andresvmb

T3
Selynee (preflips)
Three

Gamma Emerald
Almost50
Dorsey

Salsabil Faria
geraintm

Pedit: there's 4 scum, 6 is a fine pool to be looking in, here's where I'm at though

Quoting for new page
Gamma if you're town do you think bottom 4 wins?

Just look. Is it not funny?

[Datisi]

literally what is the issue with that post