Ok thanks I don't think I'm actually gonna be able to synthesise all this new info immediately it's 8pm so I think I'ma chill for the rest of the evening and approach this tomorrow with a full night of sleep under my belt
In post 403, Deimos27 wrote:@TA, chime in on my argument for limming Kop at some point. The TL;DR was that if you tr me, Norwee, and Noraa it only takes the additional premiss of not!(scum!redtea & scum!NM) to guarantee Kop-scum.
I can't go with not!scum NM. Noraa feels town by her play today but it's hard to trust after the hammer. I have seen those hammers come from town. That's why I am not voting Noraa.
So that leaves me with you and EE as solid town.
Pool of Noraa, redtea, Kop, NM.
That means looking through to see who I can eliminate.
If you're basis of reads is based off of votes, yikes
Dream as if you'll live forever, live as if you'll die today.
Come play Guess that Scummer OR ELSE
In post 414, Deimos27 wrote:In a pool of {redtea, Kop, NM} that's enough to guarantee Kop being scum. In a pool of {Noraa, redtea, Kop, NM) it guarantees at least 1 scum in {Noraa, Kop}
This logic is totally wack
Dream as if you'll live forever, live as if you'll die today.
Come play Guess that Scummer OR ELSE
In post 415, Tamora's Angel wrote:I don't read the game like that unless absolutely forced to or scum are eliminated. With no content from NM it would be hard to eliminate him as partners with anyone.
Ok, I know I'm not in the majority by doing associatives without flips. Did you read the argument for why redtea's voting behaviour does imply they're not with NM though? I feel they should've voted Noraa instead of NM (back when they did so) if they were teammates with NM because they had been shading Noraa so much in the posts prior.
By your logic, red tea is scum with everyone in the game that they haven't voted because they've shaded everyone.
Like the thing is your reads are so messed up. Like your elim pool isn't even an elim pool. You dont have a single good reason to scum read kop whereas I have a good reason to townread them (pending confirmation since theres a replacement who i dont know)
The logic is so fucked up I dont even know where to start picking it apart.
Dream as if you'll live forever, live as if you'll die today.
Come play Guess that Scummer OR ELSE
In post 446, Save The Dragons wrote:don't like "i wouldn't have hammered as scum!" + "i didn't realize i was the hammer!" + "aha i've caught you now, deimos!"
You go find a time I hammered any wagon as scum. I'm quite sure that there are either none or an EXTREMELY small number. I dont do it because I pay so much attention to every little detail as scum that isn't too mech-y
And deimos was scummy af so ..
Dream as if you'll live forever, live as if you'll die today.
Come play Guess that Scummer OR ELSE
In post 446, Save The Dragons wrote:don't like "i wouldn't have hammered as scum!" + "i didn't realize i was the hammer!" + "aha i've caught you now, deimos!"
You go find a time I hammered any wagon as scum. I'm quite sure that there are either none or an EXTREMELY small number. I dont do it because I pay so much attention to every little detail as scum that isn't too mech-y
And deimos was scummy af so ..
see the problem is i believed in mystic bears pretty hard when the bear part told me they wouldn't be doing x or y as scum
I don’t think "i wouldn’t hammer as scum" is nearly of a good as an argument as you seem to think it is.
But i do like your active engaged posting so i’m feeling more like i want a bird or some snappy fruit tea on the menu today.
In post 463, NorwegianboyEE wrote:Though there is also the take that Redtea has so many scumreads on him already that it seems hard to believe he couldn’t be town.
Can I get that applied to me too please
Dream as if you'll live forever, live as if you'll die today.
Come play Guess that Scummer OR ELSE