Mini 2250: Role-A-Pair Mafia (Game Over)

[Pentagon Shape]

Green ISo is lackluster
Blue seems very transparent, which is hard for scum to fake without scumtelling.

Because I've seen tthis come up a few times I'll leave this here.

2) Players will receive a role PM before the game starts informing them only of their alignment, win condition, and whether they are a Modifier or Power. There are six Modifiers (Colors) and seven Powers (Shapes) in the game. Flavor is random and unrelated to role content. They will receive their account names and passwords at this point.

The colors/ shapes that correspond to each ability would be randed after setup generation. So don't pull from the color/ shape any speculation of abilities.

I agree with you, I also like blue.

[Color Blue]

Way too early readlist:


TR: Circle Arrow Yellow Orange Pentagon
TL: Red Triangle
Null: Heart Green
SR: Purple Star Diamond

I want to be wrong on Purple, I think I might be somewhat confbiased against him but most people think he's town so I don't think it will matter much.

I'd actually like pairing with Diamond despite thinking he's suspicious because he sounds like a fun guy and I have a weakness for bad boys.

Why is Triangle a tl for you?

I tend to have a weakness for trolls who don't seem to care about how they are perceived. It leans town for me.

[Color Blue]

Yup, Pntagn, star.

pentagon + star = pentagram.

pntagrm = EVVVVIILLL

nxt.

like this reasoning isnt great or good

but it is funny

and it is reaction testing/doing something

and I like people who do things even if they are doing things for questionable reasons

you can catch scum with bad reasoning just as much as scum with good reasoning

sometimes caught for the wrong reasons does create some interesting reactions.

I like how triangle doesn't seem to really care, he just lets it fly.

[Arrow Shape]

I'm obligated to warn people when they get fanciful in their reasoning.
Also, Hiya.

[Arrow Shape]

Is circle paired yet?

[Heart Shape]

Triangle does care. They broke character to explain the T9 texting. I'm not saying that's scummy, but town reading them for larping is hardly warranted.

[Heart Shape]

Arrow, how do you vibe with Purple's reads list?

[Heart Shape]

The first one, as amended.

[Arrow Shape]

I'll put a table of observations so you can get into my perspective.

Observations
Player	Observation
Color Red	Is a nullread to me. 39 feels like genuine concern. I am unsure if this is coming from Town or if it is coming from Mafia though.
Color Orange	Is a townread for me. Reaction in 23 feels genuine and Town. 135 feels like Town.
Color Yellow	Is highest townread for me. Entrance in 20 feels reasonable. Reaction in 21 feels genuine and Town. 110 feels like Town and almost reminiscient of somebody who I admire.
Color Green	Is a townread for me. Entrance in 9 feels like Town trying to start a conversation. Reaction in 11 to me feels like Town.
Color Blue	Is a townread for me. Reaction in 15 of my entrance feels Town to me.
Arrow Shape	Is a townread for me. Arrow's questioning of me in 95 feels like Town trying to solve the game.
Circle Shape	Is a townread for me. See 12. Reaction to my entrance feels natural. 128 feels like Town who is trying to solve the game.
Diamond Shape	Is currently a null read for me. Is doing things which could come frpm Town but I'm finding it hard to read them. See 42 to get what I mean.
Heart Shape	Is a null read for me. Isn't doing anything Alignment Indicative.
Pentagon Shape	34 and 36 seem like a Town reaction towards my entrance. I find 142 something Town could be concerned about.
Star Shape	Is a townread for me. See 92, 99 and 102 for my reasoning behind townreading him. See 141 as aditional reasoning for why Star is Town to me.
Triangle Shape	Posted nothing so far. I'll keep them as a null read until they start posting.

EBWOP

It feels like they're doing some experimentation. have you tracked how their opinions have evolved since they wrote this? Seeing how they develop their reads should help. But their activity makes it difficult because they have to keep reinventing the wheel if they're scum. They could be motivated scum. But the simpler one is that they're town.

[Arrow Shape]

Oh, you're asking if I agree with their reads list.

Uh, I basically just like the following people for town: Circle, Orange, Blue, Purple, Me.

That's pretty much it so far.

[Color Purple]

Is circle paired yet?

I don't think so.

[Color Purple]

Yup, Pntagn, star.

pentagon + star = pentagram.

pntagrm = EVVVVIILLL

nxt.

Yes, me and star are very clearly Satan worshippers. I find you extremely entertaining. lol

I hope Triangle's joking though. I find their reasoining too idiosyncratic to be taken seriously.

How are you even questioning this? lol

I'm trying to be diplomatic and vocalise my belief that Triangle's just intentionally mucking around when it comes to their reasoning. I do find Triangle's reasoning too unique. It's unusual for symbols to be used as reasoning. Usually reasons are formed by analysis and vibes over symbols.

[Arrow Shape]

Why are you trying to tell everyone the intent of a player that doesn't tell us anything about their alignment?

[Color Purple]

Green ISo is lackluster
Blue seems very transparent, which is hard for scum to fake without scumtelling.

Because I've seen tthis come up a few times I'll leave this here.

2) Players will receive a role PM before the game starts informing them only of their alignment, win condition, and whether they are a Modifier or Power. There are six Modifiers (Colors) and seven Powers (Shapes) in the game. Flavor is random and unrelated to role content. They will receive their account names and passwords at this point.

The colors/ shapes that correspond to each ability would be randed after setup generation. So don't pull from the color/ shape any speculation of abilities.

I kind of agree with the last paragraph for the same reason you had stated. Blue's transparency does help to read her because of what you said. Also, her transparency helps us get into her perspective and we get to understand why she reads certain people as Town or Scum. Green is quite in the background but seems all right to me for now.

[Color Purple]

Why are you trying to tell everyone the intent of a player that doesn't tell us anything about their alignment?

People have different playstyles. I once saw a Town Cop PR hunt as the only PR. That's kind what I'm suggesting about Triangle. They just probably have a strange playstyle like that previously mentioned Town Cop. I can empathise with Triangle because they're probably just never realised how their playstyle can be viewed as.

[Arrow Shape]

I have paranoia on blue. Particularly I can't tell if their spoiler post is them method acting or providing vulnerability. I can't tell if being fanciful is a part of their process or if it's artificial and calculated.

[Heart Shape]

Oh, you're asking if I agree with their reads list.

Uh, I basically just like the following people for town: Circle, Orange, Blue, Purple, Me.

That's pretty much it so far.

No not that. I can't remember exactly what it was but it seemed early on you were sussing Purple a bit, and I wanted to get your thoughts on Purple after that was posted.

[Arrow Shape]

Why are you trying to tell everyone the intent of a player that doesn't tell us anything about their alignment?

People have different playstyles. I once saw a Town Cop PR hunt as the only PR. That's kind what I'm suggesting about Triangle. They just probably have a strange playstyle like that previously mentioned Town Cop. I can empathise with Triangle because they're probably just never realised how their playstyle can be viewed as.

You confuse me with your leaps in logic and assumptions.

[Color Purple]

And how's Yellow? I still townread them but maybe they've been sharing their thoughts with you and it might help reinforce my townread and other's townreads on them.

[Arrow Shape]

I don't think we have a PT yet, or at least I can't find it.

[Arrow Shape]

Oh, you're asking if I agree with their reads list.

Uh, I basically just like the following people for town: Circle, Orange, Blue, Purple, Me.

That's pretty much it so far.

No not that. I can't remember exactly what it was but it seemed early on you were sussing Purple a bit, and I wanted to get your thoughts on Purple after that was posted.

I wrote some words that revealed I was going down a rabbit hole. Their reads post didn't do much for me, circle made me feel slightly better about them and made me think about them in a different way. I sussed them initially for being strange, but their strangeness hasn't really stopped. I'm not hard town reading them, but I am leaning townie there.

[Color Purple]

I don't think we have a PT yet, or at least I can't find it.

Oh. My bad. So Yellow's just fading into the background. I hope that I can find something later to reinforce my townread. I already used their pre-existing posts to justify.

[Color Purple]

Why are you trying to tell everyone the intent of a player that doesn't tell us anything about their alignment?

People have different playstyles. I once saw a Town Cop PR hunt as the only PR. That's kind what I'm suggesting about Triangle. They just probably have a strange playstyle like that previously mentioned Town Cop. I can empathise with Triangle because they're probably just never realised how their playstyle can be viewed as.

You confuse me with your leaps in logic and assumptions.

Oh. Dear. I do often change my mind overnight. I try to keep constitant but my thoughts usually change when I reread posts or read new posts. For example, I had Heart and Red as nulls, but I have since townread both. I also nullread Diamond, but now too townread them. I nullread and still nullread Triangle though, despite empathising with them.

[Color Purple]

I have paranoia on blue. Particularly I can't tell if their spoiler post is them method acting or providing vulnerability. I can't tell if being fanciful is a part of their process or if it's artificial and calculated.

I can't tell either about that post. It could be an attempt at trying to get scum to refocus their attention on her and distract them from focusing on how others view them. If this is artificial, she did do a great job, to be honest.

[Color Red]

And how's Yellow? I still townread them but maybe they've been sharing their thoughts with you and it might help reinforce my townread and other's townreads on them.

I don't think we have a PT yet, or at least I can't find it.