Mini Normal 2253 | Frogs! | Game Over

[Datisi]

what gives you the impression that i would look at past frogs games before outing a read that is based on a tonal ping from a post on page 1?

[Andante]

cause you were bringing up "cause they said they're a newbie" that typically implies you'd at least glance at past games, idk your wording there, I feel like you're scum frogs town

[Datisi]

they said one completed game, that's very much a newbie. i assumed they're not lying about something that is so very easy to check. so no, i did not look at shit. try again.

[frogsfrogs]

What the hell is a big board enthusiast

Board

game

and online

game

enthusiast

[Quiet Owl]

-snipped-

I think I'm voting datisi

Fixed for the sake of posterity, new vote count coming soon.

[bugspray]

what sort of hidden role board games do you have experience with frogfrog?

[Testarossa]

I am indecisive if scumtisi is really that awkward in the beginning or if these are just the glorious attempts of towntisi trying to lead and move the game forward.

It's kind of funny how Datisi and frogs are "townreading" each other but both reads are kind of weird. Although frogs can just be naivety given their newbie status. Kind of disagree with Datisi on frogs, I would only really buy such a tonal read maybe by some of their later posts. It can be a pretty subjective thing though, so I don't necessarily see the tmi that Andante is suggesting here.

[Testarossa]

Actually do you think Datisi's tonal read on frogs is not justified if he would have looked up frogs game? (asking Andante here) Do you think their tone is identical to the scum game they had and thus nai or on what are you basing the conclusion, that Datisi should have reached if they would have looked it up?

[Testarossa]

@kenny, is your vote just random, or do you think they could be scum?

This is actually what I like less from Datisi. What kind of information do you hope to gain from that? I mean kenny's 29 doesn't even leave much room to interpret here unless you are overinterpreting the last bit of his reason. But context looks pretty clear to me here.

Also what do you make now of bugs avoiding your scum accusation?

[Dwlee99]

I think this might be scumtisi but I don't want to fuck up my read rate of finding town!datisi the past bazillion games early and then making him hella paranoid when I buddy up to him the whole game

[kennyk]

i genuinely do like frogsfrogs's tone for town. and considering they said they're a newbie...

@kenny, is your vote just random, or do you think they could be scum?

As I said, I came to the conclusion that frogsfrogs is scum pregame with their name relating to the name of the game and the avatar not matching the name. This is an absolute solid scumread and I am not voting anywhere else.

But now back to serious mode. It was a totally random vote, but the excuse of the name seemed to fit. Do I think frogsfrogs could be scum? Yes, they

could

be. Knowing nothing about the setup I would guess, that the chances of a scum!frogsfrogs are about 1 in 4 (assuming a 2 to 7 ratio between mafia and scum).

On a sidenote: I would call anyone with a join date "October 19, 2021" at least a newbie to this board. So calling frogsfrogs a newbie without checking their games seems kind of logic. I know it is possible, that they had mafia experience elsewhere. I myself fall under this category as well (about a dozen games on greylabyrinth and two on this site with a different account more than 15 years ago).

[bugspray]

it really should be obvious that it wasn't a real vote

[kennyk]

it really should be obvious that it wasn't a real vote

Yeah, it should. But how about your votes? As far as I can see, you voted three times now. Why this rapid vote shifting? Is it some kind of scheme to muddy the water and make vote analysing more difficult in case you flip scum?

[bugspray]

first vote was rvs, second vote was newbtell on nips (saying hi), third vote was adante being anticonstructive and sort of wallowing "oh no its rvs i hate rvs" without actually trying to exit rvs

[Testarossa]

A newbtell on someone that has been around this site since 2018?

[Quiet Owl]

"Now Rise Up And Speak, And Maybe Have A Snack As Well"

by WiresTheRobot

VOTECOUNT

Andante (2): MegAzumarill, bugspray
bugspray (2): Datisi, Testarossa
frogsfrogs (1): kennyk
Dwlee99 (1): frogsfrogs
Datisi (1): Dwlee99

The leading wagon is

bolded

.
With 9 alive, it takes 5 to reach a decision. The deadline is in

(expired on 2021-12-28 17:35:51)

. If a majority is not reached by then, the result will be no elimination.

[Datisi]

@kenny, is your vote just random, or do you think they could be scum?

This is actually what I like less from Datisi. What kind of information do you hope to gain from that? I mean kenny's 29 doesn't even leave much room to interpret here unless you are overinterpreting the last bit of his reason. But context looks pretty clear to me here.

Also what do you make now of bugs avoiding your scum accusation?

i hope to gain information on whether kenny has started sorting people, or if he's just memeing. i can see that his vote was non-serious, but i think it's a nice opportunity to ask him whether he shares my thoughts on frogsfrogs.

it's scummy.

[Datisi]

I think this might be scumtisi but I don't want to fuck up my read rate of finding town!datisi the past bazillion games early and then making him hella paranoid when I buddy up to him the whole game

interesting. what makes you think so this game? especially this early, you started pushing me when i had a grand total of one (1) post.

On a sidenote: I would call anyone with a join date "October 19, 2021" at least a newbie to this board. So calling frogsfrogs a newbie without checking their games seems kind of logic. I know it is possible, that they had mafia experience elsewhere. I myself fall under this category as well (about a dozen games on greylabyrinth and two on this site with a different account more than 15 years ago).

a newbie to this board, sure. but as my read was tonal in nature, that means i have to ask about their experience prior to this board, it doesn't matter that they joined here in october.

[Datisi]

it really should be obvious that it wasn't a real vote

and the reason you're not trying to rip my head off because of that is...?

[Datisi]

testarossa is town.

[MegAzumarill]

testarossa is town.

Perhaps site your sources?

[MegAzumarill]

cite*

[Datisi]

sure: 56, 57, 58.

[Datisi]

actually:

Testarossa (2021). Frogs!.

Mini Normal, 2253

(1), 56-58.

[Dwlee99]

actually:

Testarossa (2021). Frogs!.

Mini Normal, 2253

(1), 56-58.

Nvm I'm funny passing you