In post 1472, innocentvillager wrote: In post 1448, catboi wrote: In post 1441, innocentvillager wrote:id like to hear catboi's opinion on this more than anyone else atm rn because if im wrong i think he'd be the one to best be on the other side and slap me back to reality
I get what you're saying, I'm just not totally convinced the difference makes him scum this game, if that makes sense
okay do u still think he's town though? so u agree now that this isn't actually similar to chromatic ascension?
Not confidently, but not really enough to want to vote him, I'll tell you how I feel when I'm current on the game.
The argument between iv/Datisi on page 60 mostly feels like a headache and reminds me of why I wanted to stop reading this game in the first place. I had IV as town based on overall enthusiasm, case on midwwaybear feels earnest, him turning around and paranoiaing on datisi afte townreading him probably not the play he does as scum, the fixation on the particulars of datisi calling his vote a case is probably towny. I still kind of think datisi is town for his responses but am less sure there
In post 1496, SirCakez wrote:Here I'll sheep IV on this because I do think this is like 99% scum and I'd rather get someone obviously scum out of the game then let them sit around
VOTE: midwaybear
I'm not really picking up on why he is "obviously" scum based on your ISO? You said one post bothered you tonally but I'm not sure how that equates to the level of confidence you have here
In post 1500, Faker wrote: In post 574, catboi wrote:PookyTheMagicalBear wrote:wait do you think scum skitter approaches you this way immediately?
That was the doubt I had but she keeps doing the thing where her reasons for suspecting me keep changing after they become invalid and so I'm tilting my head to the side and going "really"? at the stuff she's saying
Historically, how scum indicative is this behavior? I unfortunately feel like I see it as either alignment, there's the question of "Working backwards" that I consider strongly indicative, but there's vaguely negative feelings and slowly drilling down/reworking it to understand the feeling..
God, I don't know, I don't keep a mental index of it but typically when someone's town and their reasoning is shown to be flawed it gives them some pause, unless they're a severe tunneler
I don't have big thoughts on the read wall in
1501 but I'm not really being whelmed by the scumreads I'm seeing there
1507 pings me
In post 1509, skitter30 wrote: In post 1465, catboi wrote: In post 1450, skitter30 wrote:
This is kinda a gut read, idk. Hard to put into words. But dont super feel like he's town and he isnt really trying to solve anything (ehich can admittedly be nai but makes it hard to townread him too)
Was feeling something with regard to him not being obvious town but I know he's not high effort every game, but...maybe
Sorry, i'm not sure what you're saying here
was saying I think if he continues doing nothing but floating it's scum-indicative
In post 1518, Sleepless Assassin wrote:I'll have a big post to dump tomorrow. If anyone is curious about my reads I'm pretty confident in Innocentvillager and Flow Trap being scum. I have Mare as townier than I'm sure most of you do. Faker/catboi/Midway might contain a scum. Andante probably town. I don't have Datisi as a strong scum read but I am surprised to see him getting votes. Skitter kind of townish. Anyone else is a weaker read than those.
This feel extremely like a mad libs type post, where the names are attached to generic sort of comments without actual reasoning for them, the association of me/faker/midway in a trio is very arbitrary
