Mini 2254 | Subreddit uPick | Fin

[morph the cat]

Vote Count 1-5

mastina

(3): That Idiot Ivan, Suripoko, Shiro

Dwlee99

(2): StrangeMatter, SirCakez

jjh927

(1): The Bombay

StrangeMatter

(1): Dwlee99

The Bombay

(1): Lady Lambdadelta

Rogue

(1): skitter30

skitter30

(1): Rogue

Not Voting

(3): mastina, T3, jjh927

With 13 alive, it takes 7 to eliminate.

Deadline: January 15, Midnight US Eastern Time.

Countdown: (expired on 2022-01-14 21:00:00)

Mod Notes:

-

[The Bombay]

Do you have any other reads jjh927?

[jjh927]

Skitter is town

[The Bombay]

What reasons do you have?

[The Bombay]

Why do you think it's weird that I am happy to defend a stated townread from a push with a role related angle? Is it because you are voting me? Should I be more unwilling to TR you because you voted me? Uncool people are frequently town

I find it weird that you see any player as "well over my day 1 bar for towniness" on page 5.

I also find it weird that that was your response to Lady Lambdadelta's post 117.

It did not engage with the actual reasoning that she gave to call it suspicious. It just called us town, and therefore Lady Lambdadelta's point was wrong.

To again compare your response to Skitter's, Skitter's post showed that she was actually thinking about Lady Lambdadelta's point and thinking about whether we would fake it. Would Marci agree to this? Would Luke try to talk her into it anyways?

[jjh927]

Lld cannot be placed day 1
Mastina will be placed easily at some point in this day

I don't know when I will have reads on other players but for now I can say that it is far too early to be shaking me down for reads

[The Bombay]

for now I can say that it is far too early to be shaking me down for reads

Why are you so against it?

[jjh927]

In day 1, you do not need to do a lot to find town. You should always remember that the vast majority of the game is town and the bar ought to be relatively low.

You are absolutely not going to get me to elaborate on my reads while I am phoneposting at 5am on page 7

[The Bombay]

[jjh927]

If I appear hostile here it is because you have asked me about half a dozen times to do a thing that is absolutely going to disrupt my natural flow for day 1, and the only notable purpose is to facilitate you placing me. I already have you as town. I don't need to watch you placing me to get a better read on you. I'd rather just wait for some more people to pop in than perpetually engage with the repeated "But why"

[Lukewarm]

In day 1, you do not need to do a lot to find town. You should always remember that the vast majority of the game is town and the bar ought to be relatively low.

Might meta jjh on this line later.

-Luke

-----

I might start signing my posts. When we decided to hydra, I thought it would be super obvious who was posting. However, since we both are trying to do the post restriction, I don't know that it is as clear.

151, 153, 156, 158 were all Marci posts.

This one and 154 are from me.

[jjh927]

You are welcome to meta me on it right now

[The Bombay]

So boring but I got what I wanted kind of.

I'm fine with
VOTE: Dwlee99
as well.

Should I sign as well? It's a bit cringey in my opinion.

~Marcistar

[jjh927]

Signing is extremely helpful when you are both posting simultaneously

[Shiro]

Our subreddit choice was r/CatsInBusinessAttire.

Hello fellow cat

[Shiro]

You are a bussienss cat and I am a magic cat so maybe we can start a magic business about catching fish.

[Shiro]

Do you like fish? Cause I reaaaalllly like fish.

[The Bombay]

Let's do it.

I don't think I like it as much as you do unfortunately. You seem like a huge fan, call it intuition.

[Shiro]

How did you know? Are you also a magical cat? I even have a song! Where is my fishy fish fish dish. ^~^

Well a line not a song but still. Nobody will be ready for the ferocious team of US. Well except fisherman, maybe they will be ready since they will have fish. Hm.

[jjh927]

VOTE: Shiro

Clearly the second cat is the scum version of the town one

[Shiro]

VOTE: Shiro

Clearly the second cat is the scum version of the town one

I hiss at you you hear me hiss

[mastina]

except when she's sm

sm?

If you think that someone is a member of the mafia, voting them out is playing to your win condition if you are a member of the town.

There's 3 mafia. I can scumhunt without voting LLD, regardless of my read on her. (Also my proxy vote's not permanent.)

how serious is 20?

Dead serious, albeit accidentally:
I

meant

to include names of players who hadn't posted (which would've lessened seriousness somewhat), but since I forgot...

VOTE: The Bombay
(proxy-LLD, but also, scumread anyway, readslist next post)

[mastina]

Maybe a flavor claim would be in order

Spoiler: These Images' Common Thread

(also a role 'crumb)

T++

:

Rogue > Suripoko > jjh927 > LLD > skitter30

T

:

T3

T?

:

StrangeMatter

N-T:

Dwlee99

N

:

Shiro

N-S:

Ivan

S

:

SirCakez (always) > The Bombay

[jjh927]

What's your line here on Bombay then? Guessing it's different to LLD's

[jjh927]

Also I don't think 3 mafia is confirmed?