Mini Normal 2258 | Bunnies [Postgame]

[Something_Smart]

i read 120 as a shitpost. if your argument here is that 120 (a post where you or so hilariously vote someone after agreeing they're town) is out of your scumrange, that is (1) really sad, and (2) not something i'm buying.

Because you're scum.

Guess I'm scum too then.

[Datisi]

Why would scum need to do reaction tests?

why would scum need to read the game? why would scum have to post content?

[House]

"you don't wanna townread me!!" is basically rvs.

Not in my case.

I was considering voting Noctyrne tbh, but now i just want to vote House.

You have very rigid opinions as to how "a good little townie" is supposed to act...

... whereas I'm more of a "chaotic good" townie & "lawful evil" scum.

This post was made in a town game.

frogs! is proof I wasn't lying about my scum meta. That game was proof I wasn't lying about my town meta.

[VP Baltar]

Scratch that, Datisi was in frogsfrogs, my scumgame that matches the quote.

Got mixed up there.

So the meta you were basing this on was wrong, and you're shifting the goalposts to make it fit? I'm not following why I should buy this is a serious vote.

Nope. The meta of frogs confirms the statement in the quote.

No shifting, whatsoever.

Well, the quote is so vague it is essentially meaningless, thus comparisons to the quote are also meaningless.

Seems post hoc reasoning to me.

[House]

Why would scum need to do reaction tests?

why would scum need to read the game? why would scum have to post content?

Survival.

Nice attempt at deflection, though.

[Datisi]

if you allegedly snowed me in that mini, WHY should i be giving you an easy townread here? wouldn't it be logical that i'd be more wary of you?

[House]

Scratch that, Datisi was in frogsfrogs, my scumgame that matches the quote.

Got mixed up there.

So the meta you were basing this on was wrong, and you're shifting the goalposts to make it fit? I'm not following why I should buy this is a serious vote.

Nope. The meta of frogs confirms the statement in the quote.

No shifting, whatsoever.

Well, the quote is so vague it is essentially meaningless, thus comparisons to the quote are also meaningless.

Seems post hoc reasoning to me.

Then perhaps I've overestimated the abilities of seasoned players. :shrug:

[Something_Smart]

House, you should reveal as IC so we can add "twice" to your sig.

[House]

if you allegedly snowed me in that mini, WHY should i be giving you an easy townread here? wouldn't it be logical that i'd be more wary of you?

Because my town & scum games stand in stark contrast to each other.

I'm easier to read than Creature was back in the day.

[Datisi]

to borrow a great player's words, house's arguments are so bad, it has to be a townie talking out of their own ass.

[House]

House, you should reveal as IC so we can add "twice" to your sig.

Nah.

Hardclaim: Town Jester

[Datisi]

Because my town & scum games stand in stark contrast to each other.

i have one. ONE. game of experience with you. your whole premise of me being scum is that i'm supposed to accept at face value that your scumgame is utter shit and what i saw in that mini is the best you're capable of. i'm not accepting that just based on your own words.

[House]

to borrow a great player's words, house's arguments are so bad, it has to be a townie talking out of their own ass.

Reductio ad absurdum is a common scum tactic.

[Something_Smart]

Man, when I hoped that discussion would pick up in this game, this is

not

what I had in mind.

[House]

Anywho, now that my vote is locked in, I'm heading to work.

See you folks later.

[skitter30]

i think this is a silly argument and probably tvt
if either is scum here i'd say house but i don't particularly think he is

[skitter30]

i think outworlder is prob town, i just want to say

[VP Baltar]

i think outworlder is prob town, i just want to say

Why?

[Laplacian]

Oh dang, this started already and I'm 7 pages behind. Guess it's reading time

[skitter30]

i get nice vibes from 64, 68 and the last line of 100

[Reformed Toxic Player]

even if datisi was modconfirmed mafia to me, i would never vote him out day 1 <3

[Reformed Toxic Player]

that being said i have fuzzy feelings about datisi's alignment rn :3

[House]

i think this is a silly argument and probably tvt
if either is scum here i'd say house but i don't particularly think he is

Copycat.

[skitter30]

ok

[Laplacian]

I've played one game with House so far, and this is exactly how he acted as town in that one, including the fast af claim