In post 2755, Roden wrote:Sorry, was dealing with wedding stuff yesterday, I just finished catching up on the game.
Ircher is caught scum for multiple reasons, I don't believe he's FN and I'm pretty sure he wasn't RB'd. Somebody mentioned earlier that Ircher's reads list looked townie, but also noted that he essentially had written it ahead of time, which leads me to believe it was just fabricated as a last ditch effort to save himself. He also
still
isn't scum hunting, unless you count this:
In post 2587, Ircher wrote:I think Bell scum claimed in the last few pages.
In post 2449, TheWayItEnds wrote:if your action was roleblocked can you use it tonight? for non consec? im assuming not but worth a check
Nope.
This also feels off. The confident conclusiveness of this answer doesn't add up if the claim is real. The reply is instant, and the only way he could know for sure is if he asked the mod ahead of time, but he doesn't mention that. Very much just feels like a "just trust me bro" response.
Also Val needs to die tonight or tomorrow. He tried to instigate an argument but never responded when I brought the receipts. And then today he's like "oh no where's Roden" as if there isn't an unfinished case against him that he's been ignoring.
Consider my vote spiritually on Ircher, I don't want to put him at E-1 in case he hammers himself to cut off discussion and info exchange. I'm fine to do it when we're ready though.
In post 2758, Ircher wrote:In other news, Roden just dropped several percentage points with how he's spinning things here.
Except he’s referring to me who said it first and you didn’t bat an eye
That's not true. I just didn't comment; not everything is worth it at the time. Also, the specifics matter here. You called me out for my initial reaction. Roden is calling me out for providing the standard answer to a question that has a standard answer on this site. That's very different; the former is a good faith engagement even if I disagree. The latter is just incredibly bad faith. You both agree the claim is fake; that's fine, sure; however, the way you reach that conclusion matters, and the way Roden is reaching that conclusion is really iffy compared to yours.
In post 2758, Ircher wrote:In other news, Roden just dropped several percentage points with how he's spinning things here.
Except he’s referring to me who said it first and you didn’t bat an eye
I was hoping someone would notice this first. Ircher has been ignoring most people who try to case him, only ever replying to people he thinks are easy to out-argue.
In post 2821, Roden wrote:Anyway the real reason Ircher is scum here is because there is a 100% chance we have a Voyeur and/or a Watcher and there's no way they don't sit on Ircher N1 to catch a Roleblocker. But no one's stepping forward to vouch for Ircher besides I guess Andante, who just claimed VT.
Hot take:
let's actually kill scum today. The CORRECT play today is to KILL roden.
Here's why:
Here's roden's first "scum" ircher when there was multiple people already looking that way, but no case, no reasons why.
Then there's the naked vote. That naked vote is placed in spot 6/11. There's no "real" reason, just a naked vote.
Now Roden switches to Val.
1560 again naked jumps onto the wagon for no real reason for E-3
No where around for the last minute switcharoooo.
Now open up to D2:
All of a sudden is convinced that Ircher is lying. Full on bussing. knowing the partner is going down. The other part of the line "someone mentioned that the posts looked fabricated".
The last two posts are distancing between ircer & roden.
Up until the naked vote there was BARELY any mention re:ircher until the naked 6/11 vote & the E-3 vote then the start of D2.
So please for the sake of catching an actual scum. please vote roden
thank you kindly
for my sanity
You need to send me some of whatever it is you're smoking.
Roden isn't scum.
And you just kinda proved it.
That still doesn’t clear you or Mastina from being scum.
Idk why you’re so hellbent on thinking it makes it Mastina town.
Hint: it doesn’t.
No matter how high the stakes, sooner or later you're just gonna have to go with your gut.
And maybe, just maybe, that'll take you right where you were supposed to be.
No roden and Irchers interactions felt like scum distancing to me.
Please note he started to soft the RB after D2 conveniently after Ircher claims he was rb’d.
I’m sorry I don’t see it as town. I feel like it’s scum roden crumbing in case he’s run up for this exact thing
Also if you think flavor is irreveantl then Polaris could be a safe claim for all we know.
Idk what is making you BE SO SURE that roden and Mastina are town
No matter how high the stakes, sooner or later you're just gonna have to go with your gut.
And maybe, just maybe, that'll take you right where you were supposed to be.
In post 4066, catboi wrote:Yes, the game thread is shit and is in all likelihood already in a loss state for town and as such my desire to put anything forward is at a minimum
Alternatively you can actually come play the game and drop dragging down the rest of us here who are confident in a town win and trying to solve.
I'm letting you steer the game, have fun solving it, which I'm sure you're doing great at
I mean tbb is doing great. Totally on scum ircher elim
HINT THEY WERENT
OH YASSSS STEERING TO WIN
0:1 tbb
No matter how high the stakes, sooner or later you're just gonna have to go with your gut.
And maybe, just maybe, that'll take you right where you were supposed to be.
No matter how high the stakes, sooner or later you're just gonna have to go with your gut.
And maybe, just maybe, that'll take you right where you were supposed to be.
In post 4066, catboi wrote:Yes, the game thread is shit and is in all likelihood already in a loss state for town and as such my desire to put anything forward is at a minimum
Alternatively you can actually come play the game and drop dragging down the rest of us here who are confident in a town win and trying to solve.
I'm letting you steer the game, have fun solving it, which I'm sure you're doing great at
Ngl honestly we'd solve your slot better if you were absent.
Don't try me Catboi, cause I can play your game and better than you can. You may be able to create a toxic environment but I can thrive in it.
i love 2 know that i can go 2 bed n wake up early 2 take the dogs outside n therell b a new n improved trash fire 2 weigh in on
like im understandin why ppl say they hate mafia for real omg
flea fuckin like. tell me whats wrong w the roden case dont jus b like "OH ITS CRAP" like break it down cuz its fuckin good
neurological hydra -- shrike (sloppy typist)//CURSE (formal typist)
We won't sign our posts, just assume you're right when you guess
it/its pronouns only
n rodens like. scum by vibes 2. like thats a calculated ass iso. u need 2 sell me on roden town.
neurological hydra -- shrike (sloppy typist)//CURSE (formal typist)
We won't sign our posts, just assume you're right when you guess
it/its pronouns only
In post 4137, MUSHSHAGANA wrote:flea fuckin like. tell me whats wrong w the roden case dont jus b like "OH ITS CRAP" like break it down cuz its fuckin good
Is "fucking good" something that can be summed up entirely as "this could be bussing Ircher"?
not u 2 dam i fuckin hate it here i cant have shiiiiiiiiiittttttt in this town omg
its also fuckin like showin an awareness of what irchers abt 2 do u know. like its fuckin coordinated ass posting
neurological hydra -- shrike (sloppy typist)//CURSE (formal typist)
We won't sign our posts, just assume you're right when you guess
it/its pronouns only
In post 4137, MUSHSHAGANA wrote:i love 2 know that i can go 2 bed n wake up early 2 take the dogs outside n therell b a new n improved trash fire 2 weigh in on
like im understandin why ppl say they hate mafia for real omg
flea fuckin like. tell me whats wrong w the roden case dont jus b like "OH ITS CRAP" like break it down cuz its fuckin good
In post 4138, MUSHSHAGANA wrote:n rodens like. scum by vibes 2. like thats a calculated ass iso. u need 2 sell me on roden town.
I'll take that case on, however, it wont be today.
Health means you got nothing significant from me today. The nausea is real.
-Pinkie "Someone stop the world from spinning? Please? *urk*" bear
neurological hydra -- shrike (sloppy typist)//CURSE (formal typist)
We won't sign our posts, just assume you're right when you guess
it/its pronouns only
I'm not sure i trust the timing of Mala popping in with this "case" in the first place.
Like Dunn becomes a wagon and then suddenly they r like "Hey remember Roden? Yeah that guy. Couldn't he have been bussing everyone? All focus on him now"
listen like im willing 2 b swayed but like ur only defense is ?????? "timing weird" and uh "not a case" which. i think it shows a p solid case. if u dont like the case can u like fuckin engage w it so i can see if i agree w u???
fuck n ppl say im all vibes no meat omg.
neurological hydra -- shrike (sloppy typist)//CURSE (formal typist)
We won't sign our posts, just assume you're right when you guess
it/its pronouns only
In post 4136, The Three Bears wrote:
Don't try me Catboi, cause I can play your game and better than you can. You may be able to create a toxic environment but I can thrive in it.
