open 841: concgratulations to the winners and losers

[Kaiji]

i'd also like to add tho that andante is extremely anti bus and has expressed an unexplained townread on catboi and mare


which is why my solve is the way it is rn

she is absolutely not townreading mare and I had to talk her out of that read

second that's an absolutely nonsensically dumb draft for obvious reasons

further if you actually believe this, why are you pushing for no elimination here when it proves ~nothing

This is just you laying the groundwork for enchant being outed tomorrow

Bc I am of the school of thought that baiting smother investigative is good plus I don't kmow if I even have the momentum to get catboi here

[Kaiji]

VOTE: catboi
If we can get it done tho

[Kaiji]

Just remembered another point, last time I ranked neighbors with catboi it took a lot of prodding to get him to talk in there so it's bizzare he'd go for it

[Datisi]

Just remembered another point, last time I ranked neighbors with catboi it took a lot of prodding to get him to talk in there so it's bizzare he'd go for it

when did this happen?

[skitter30]

Honestly i dont think i want to get into the quagmire of one of andante/mare is dead ans we have another 1v1 tomorrow


And i donnt really think there's a scum vig in any case

I think i just want to flip enchant today

Why

well, tbh i don't see myself voting catboi before you
the options are flipping you today or no-limming and seeing what happens overnight and sorting that mess out tomorrow

[skitter30]

i'm gonna i guess finalize what i want to do in the next ~6 hours or so... i'm traveling this weekend so don't expect too much of me until like monday

[Kaiji]

Just remembered another point, last time I ranked neighbors with catboi it took a lot of prodding to get him to talk in there so it's bizzare he'd go for it

when did this happen?

Sometime last year, I linked the game even.

[Kaiji]

We were forcibly neighborized actually lol

[Kaiji]

Honestly i dont think i want to get into the quagmire of one of andante/mare is dead ans we have another 1v1 tomorrow


And i donnt really think there's a scum vig in any case

I think i just want to flip enchant today

Why

well, tbh i don't see myself voting catboi before you
the options are flipping you today or no-limming and seeing what happens overnight and sorting that mess out tomorrow

Guiilty>cop
You should know that

[Kaiji]

Do you just want to speed run dying ?

[Enchant]

Yeah, just kill cat and i will be most likely NK and stop annoying you with my presense.

If i doesn't, it will be easy.

[Something_Smart]

okay, can someone eli5 why no-yeet is superior here?

Basically, in a nutshell:
- if scum have the vig, we get to know that before we risk losing, and if they use it, then we basically know Enchant is scum (or if they want to protect Enchant, they have to give up on using it)
- if scum have the vengeful, we avoid secret elo
- if scum have neither, then we get a report on Enchant from at least one of Andante/Mare, and we also probably get a report from Enchant

Obviously the last case is still not preferable to executing today, but in the first two cases it's much better and we get a lot of info in the third case (including who scum choose to kill) so it is not the end of the world.

[Enchant]

Mafia doesn't have shit. Otherwise i would die already.

[Something_Smart]

Guiilty>cop
You should know that

You

should know that, however valid this may be, it is not at all valid if it could be elo.

[Alyssa The Lamb]

menalque didn't claim until this exact day phase

[Alyssa The Lamb]

and there was zero reason he would ever die n1 or n2

[Datisi]

Guiilty>cop
You should know that

aren't you the person that always says how scum should claim a guilty a day before yelo rather than in yelo

[Kaiji]

Guiilty>cop
You should know that

aren't you the person that always says how scum should claim a guilty a day before yelo rather than in yelo

yes but im trying to appeal to logic that others follow

[catboi]

i think i just talked myself into a catboi/andante/{s_s/alyssa} team

please explain in what universe I kill midwaybear n2 with that team

like it's really not actually that hard to think about

if mwb/kaiji is TvT then Iwant to keep that going. I'm not going to shoot myself in the foot with nightkills (unless I'm tilted because my teammates gamethrew but that's a different story entirely)

[Alyssa The Lamb]

I'm still kinda confused why any scum team with Andante in it kills mwb and has her not confirm his action

[Alyssa The Lamb]

That's still my primary issue with Andante being scum, and the way she acted for most of the game is not congruent with either of my previous games with her, both of which she was scum in

And I even caught her out in the game we were TvS in for a personality quirk she had that isn't present in this game

And she was caught in the other game for pretty similar reasons

[Kaiji]

Bc any other kill is too awkard prob

[Alyssa The Lamb]

And there are town reasons for her getting more fed up and just doing the minimum as the day went on

And the differences in seeing in how she's playing make more sense with her as town than scum

[Datisi]

i think i just talked myself into a catboi/andante/{s_s/alyssa} team

please explain in what universe I kill midwaybear n2 with that team

like it's really not actually that hard to think about

if mwb/kaiji is TvT then Iwant to keep that going. I'm not going to shoot myself in the foot with nightkills (unless I'm tilted because my teammates gamethrew but that's a different story entirely)

okay, good point, that doesn't make sense if andante is scum with you

q to everyone - how many claims did we have on d2? i'm working under the assumption that scum would always kill the cop if they think one exists. in the case of mena being town, would they had been able to narrow it down?

[schadd_]

.