Grandest Idea Mafia [Endgame]

[Korina]

So we had effectively 4 or 5 people this game with recruiting capabilities? and THIS is the good rand hahahahaha

Would you rather have:
A game where the most extreme role in the setup was like, a combined town cop-tracker-watcher or something like that, and the only factions present are town, mafia, werewolf, and a single sk rand
A game where like half the roles will end the game on n1 and nobody gets to play the game, and the other half require so much work from me that it’s not fun for me
This setup

[Morning Tweet]

so this is what happens when you crowdsource roles

[Morning Tweet]

haha but for what it was tho I thought it was pretty fun, thanks for taking the time to mod Korina!

[PookyTheMagicalBear]

i had fun :3

thx for modding ircher!!!

[PookyTheMagicalBear]

i meant thx for modding korina! :3

and thx to ircher/noraa for being awesome d1 elim ^__^

[Enchant]

I will be direct, but it was pretty straight.

No one likes playing town mostly. There's exceptions of course.
Therefore, with ability to choose your alignment from three rolls, everyone just go to scum. Game turns in "Who rolled stupid overpowered role, and didn't get elimmed wins" and simlle hunt for "You like playing scum, you die", and meta shit.

I failed with rolling stupid overpowered role, as well as other town and payed for it. Seems like sucking to rng is way of the game, which specific, but not bad. Either there need to be a little more town, or elims should be removed altogether (cuz they are jeopardized from start) and town must have "Faction Strongman Kill" which can be aimed by Village Idiot Vigilante, who doesn't know team and passes his NK to random town when dies. Oh nvm, how Jesters will win then...


Or i am whining. Happens actually.
GG everyone of course, thanks mdding and all.

[Toogeloo]

No one likes playing town mostly

Hi.

[TemporalLich]

I picked town because my cards were town/town/mafia and I had a mod discretion role

[Gypyx]

No one likes playing town mostly

Hi.

+1

but yeah, grandest idea doesn't work with it being so meta driven, unironically, secret alts would make this better

[TemporalLich]

would grander idea have the same problem?

[DkKoba]

I was forced to pick SK, i think just a 2 card pick would be ideal here and a reroll available with an unattainable wincon

[Morning Tweet]

if you included rerolls wouldn't everyone just get the alignment they want?

[Radical Rat]

No one likes playing town mostly

Hi.

+1

but yeah, grandest idea doesn't work with it being so meta driven, unironically, secret alts would make this better

Secret alts would theoretically make every Mafia game better, and yet for some reason both times I've attempted secret alt games, I've failed to properly get engaged. Though two is a rather small sample size, maybe it's just a coincidence.

There's also the matter of secret alts unfortunately not being able to truly conceal identities, unless the players make a conscious effort to play differently than normal

[DkKoba]

if you included rerolls wouldn't everyone just get the alignment they want?

Rerolls only for when you get a card like chaos elemental which cant win with its role

[Morning Tweet]

ahh got you. I agree, i think those would be better off rerolled

[Scorpio]

GG everyone!

That was...an interesting game.

Either way, was fun.

[Ircher]

Thanks for modding Korina.