KTaNE [game over!]

[Dwlee99]

I didn't ask until this day phase if mine was correct lol

[Bell]

I didn't ask until this day phase if mine was correct lol

Was it?

[Bell]

If you didn’t believe there was a difference and you didn’t ask datasi why did you make a second submission?

[Cephrir]

skimmed strange's iso and it's a big ole shrug

idk how to tell low charisma apart from scum but she kinda seems like scum

[Cephrir]

can i just VOTE: mistyx instead though

[VP Baltar]

I didn't ask until this day phase if mine was correct lol

Why not?

[Cat Scratch Fever]

Cephrir's misty vote is a real mood. If going by day play, I'd vote there or Titus.

Not sure if we should be voting outside the pool of 3 defusers though today

[VP Baltar]

Not sure if we should be voting outside the pool of 3 defusers though today

Only reason would be if we thought someone goofed in their response or if andres somehow messed up describing the bomb (which most likely isn't the case.) My module was pretty easy, but let me read andres' description and see if the other two looked more complicated.

My bombs each had two pretty simple modules and then one or two more complex ones to describe.

[Dwlee99]

I didn't ask until this day phase if mine was correct lol

Was it?

Yes

If you didn’t believe there was a difference and you didn’t ask datasi why did you make a second submission?

I did believe there would be a difference? Cause the descriptions Andres gave were of the pictures, I gave labels, and then I was like oh maybe I should say which buttons cause it's unclear based solely on label, and then said unambiguously which buttons to press

I didn't ask until this day phase if mine was correct lol

Why not?

I was pretty sure I did it right and Datisi's a busy man. When it blew up I had a slight worry it was my fault but then it wasn't so

[Dwlee99]

Not sure if we should be voting outside the pool of 3 defusers though today

Only reason would be if we thought someone goofed in their response or if andres somehow messed up describing the bomb (which most likely isn't the case.) My module was pretty easy, but let me read andres' description and see if the other two looked more complicated.

My bombs each had two pretty simple modules and then one or two more complex ones to describe.

Mine was the most complicated cause I had to describe 3 buttons to press but no one could have goofed in their response if Datisi has told all of us we did it correctly

[Dwlee99]

VP you were a defuser, is the description of the bomb just something you get in that big paragraph or do you get a picture you need to manually sit down and write a description of?

[Cat Scratch Fever]

Not sure if we should be voting outside the pool of 3 defusers though today

Only reason would be if we thought someone goofed in their response or

if andres somehow messed up describing the bomb (which most likely isn't the case.)

yeah I don't know if this is even possible, since defusers have to accept the recommendations they were given

Spoiler:

@Datisi, does the defuser have to accept the recommendations of the experts?

yes. the defuser

must

accept the recommendations, and

cannot

submit solutions on their own.

[Dwlee99]

I think VP is saying Andres could have written down something about the bomb incorrectly. ex, the color of a component, or the serial code, etc.

[Dwlee99]

Can VP or Strange cross-reference my lists to confirm that the labels I assigned to the buttons are not me swapping out which buttons get pressed

[VP Baltar]

VP you were a defuser, is the description of the bomb just something you get in that big paragraph or do you get a picture you need to manually sit down and write a description of?

You just get pictures and have to write it out. On my first bomb, I messed up describing one of the pictures, but someone (I think CSF) corrected me.

The only text on my bombs were the serial number and it told me if it had batteries or not.

[Cat Scratch Fever]

I think VP is saying Andres could have written down something about the bomb incorrectly. ex, the color of a component, or the serial code, etc.

oh right, that is a possibility, but agreed that it's unlikely

[VP Baltar]

Can VP or Strange cross-reference my lists to confirm that the labels I assigned to the buttons are not me swapping out which buttons get pressed

I can do this. I did look initially at a glance when you posted the update and it seemed the same to me, so I didn't go back and double check you with what andres posted.

[Dwlee99]

VP you were a defuser, is the description of the bomb just something you get in that big paragraph or do you get a picture you need to manually sit down and write a description of?

You just get pictures and have to write it out. On my first bomb, I messed up describing one of the pictures, but someone (I think CSF) corrected me.

The only text on my bombs were the serial number and it told me if it had batteries or not.

How did CSF know that your description was wrong?

[Dwlee99]

This actually adds a whole new layer to this bomb thing wow. This is cool

[Cat Scratch Fever]

VP you were a defuser, is the description of the bomb just something you get in that big paragraph or do you get a picture you need to manually sit down and write a description of?

You just get pictures and have to write it out. On my first bomb, I messed up describing one of the pictures, but someone (I think CSF) corrected me.

The only text on my bombs were the serial number and it told me if it had batteries or not.

How did CSF know that your description was wrong?

VP had to describe some pictures

The first half of his description could only have matched one picture

but the second half of his description switched up the words horizontal and vertical

So even though he messed up the description, I was still like 98% sure I knew which one he was referring to

[VP Baltar]

Yeah, it was a minor thing that was luckily pretty easy to tell, but I didn't even notice that one detail in the pretty long post I had to write.

[Dwlee99]

Gotcha okay. Only thing I could really see Andres messing up (for mine at least) was the thing had rows and columns. And maybe if he thought columns go horizontal that would be a problem but I do not think this is the case.

[Andante]

There is no way Andres described his bomb wrong, with the defusing stuff he double checked about his solution being right, no way he messed up saying what the bomb was, this is a terrible conversation

[Cat Scratch Fever]

It doesn't hurt to cover our bases

[Dwlee99]

I mean it did take him 30 minutes to describe it but yea I agree I don't think he messed up describing it

Who do you think is scum, Andante?