KTaNE [game over!]

[PookyTheMagicalBear]

youve now written 5 posts stating that i should be able to read your case and know what your main point is

instead of just writing what your main point is

[Menalque]

what is your case?

i am addressing the first two things i read

which were

pooky is scum for not blowing up vpb in n1 pt

and

pooky is scum for not pushing vpb on d2

write your one sentence point and ill address it

like why would you even write 4 paragraphs about how im misrepping your case

just write your most compelling point and i will read it and address it

im not refuting a 5000 word laundry list

Because I have already said multiple times what my argument is

It is, as far as I’m aware, clear to absolutely everybody who is not you

Whats more likely: you happen by sheer chance to be reading the same posts as everyone else yet the only one who doesn’t understand the argument actually being made? That you do understand but are pretending not to so as to engage with a much easier argument to defend yourself from? Or you’re not actually bothering to read my posts which would be a pretty weird thing to do from someone who actually needs to sort people?

Did you read this post? If so, do you understand it?

[PookyTheMagicalBear]

i skimmed ur case and its basically a giant laundry list of quotes with bad faith interpretations on each one

i am not going to refute each point separately because nobody is going to read a long back and forth and it is a waste of time

if you actually have a real cogent main point i will address it.

[Menalque]

I think it’s pretty clear and written in a simple vernacular for anybody to grasp, but you seem to be having trouble

[PookyTheMagicalBear]

what is your case?

i am addressing the first two things i read

which were

pooky is scum for not blowing up vpb in n1 pt

and

pooky is scum for not pushing vpb on d2

write your one sentence point and ill address it

like why would you even write 4 paragraphs about how im misrepping your case

just write your most compelling point and i will read it and address it

im not refuting a 5000 word laundry list

Because I have already said multiple times what my argument is

It is, as far as I’m aware, clear to absolutely everybody who is not you

Whats more likely: you happen by sheer chance to be reading the same posts as everyone else yet the only one who doesn’t understand the argument actually being made? That you do understand but are pretending not to so as to engage with a much easier argument to defend yourself from? Or you’re not actually bothering to read my posts which would be a pretty weird thing to do from someone who actually needs to sort people?

Did you read this post? If so, do you understand it?

why do you continue to be a pompous ass instead of just writing out what your main point is

[PookyTheMagicalBear]

I think it’s pretty clear and written in a simple vernacular for anybody to grasp, but you seem to be having trouble

then it shouldnt be hard for you to write it out one time instead of whining in 10 posts about me not getting it.

[Menalque]

what is your case?

i am addressing the first two things i read

which were

pooky is scum for not blowing up vpb in n1 pt

and

pooky is scum for not pushing vpb on d2

write your one sentence point and ill address it

like why would you even write 4 paragraphs about how im misrepping your case

just write your most compelling point and i will read it and address it

im not refuting a 5000 word laundry list

Because I have already said multiple times what my argument is

It is, as far as I’m aware, clear to absolutely everybody who is not you

Whats more likely: you happen by sheer chance to be reading the same posts as everyone else yet the only one who doesn’t understand the argument actually being made? That you do understand but are pretending not to so as to engage with a much easier argument to defend yourself from? Or you’re not actually bothering to read my posts which would be a pretty weird thing to do from someone who actually needs to sort people?

Did you read this post? If so, do you understand it?

why do you continue to be a pompous ass instead of just writing out what your main point is

what is your case?

i am addressing the first two things i read

which were

pooky is scum for not blowing up vpb in n1 pt

and

pooky is scum for not pushing vpb on d2

write your one sentence point and ill address it

like why would you even write 4 paragraphs about how im misrepping your case

just write your most compelling point and i will read it and address it

im not refuting a 5000 word laundry list

Because I have already said multiple times what my argument is

It is, as far as I’m aware, clear to absolutely everybody who is not you

Whats more likely: you happen by sheer chance to be reading the same posts as everyone else yet the only one who doesn’t understand the argument actually being made? That you do understand but are pretending not to so as to engage with a much easier argument to defend yourself from? Or you’re not actually bothering to read my posts which would be a pretty weird thing to do from someone who actually needs to sort people?

Did you read this post? If so, do you understand it?

[Menalque]

I assume that we can all see how pooky is playing dumb when I’ve explained very clearly why I’m not engaging with him on something I’ve already explained (3 times, after glancing at my iso!) and is instead continuing to badger on this point

[Menalque]

Oh, I almost wrote an actually mean post because I’m getting frustrated enough by the way pooky is trying to play today, so I’m gonna take a timeout

I’ll be around later

Question for those who are not called pooky: I feel like me pointing out how he’s being ridiculous is spamming up the thread, but I also feel uncomfortable letting him try to assert a narrative unchallenged. Is me engaging him and calling him out helpful, or is it making the thread less readable for you/a place you don’t want to be? Pls let me know in following posts so I know whether I should continue or just let him talk into the air

[PookyTheMagicalBear]

why dont u just write out your main point instead of spamming

[PookyTheMagicalBear]

are you actually that dense

[PookyTheMagicalBear]

yes im the one being dumb because you wont write out what your main point is but youd rather write 20 posts about how im playing dumb

very helpful

[Datisi]

general reminder to be respectful of your fellow players and not do personal attacks.

[Cat Scratch Fever]

I only got to page 60 yesterday because i fell asleep, so I'm going to be here for a while after getting food

I looked at your quote wall Mena, and I'm not that convinced by it, since I feel like it's missing some context -- like people healing VPB was because lmao did you look at the other heal options we had on D3? And I haven't gotten there in my reread obviously, but I remember dwlee didn't start towning it up until D3 at the earliest or D4 so some of pooky's read changes can possibly be ascribed to that.

Also pooky's interactions with VPB and MT on D1 don't look aligned. pooky kept trying to engage MT and getting stonewalled by her. I guess if they were SvS, the explanation for this would be MT was just not confident in her scum abilities to keep an SvS conversation going, but it seemed more like MT was afraid to interact with pooky to me? I'd appreciate a second opinion on this.

[Bell]

Okay. As long as we eventually kill pooky this game I don’t cares
I’m ready to go but I wanna make this very clear. Unless the game ends early. It’s pooky.

[Bell]

Lead the way CSF.

[Bell]

Sorry, need to reword. I want a guarantee. That pooky eventually gets eliminated this game. It can be now or end game. But at some point people need to vote him until he is eliminated. Got it?

[PookyTheMagicalBear]

i think u might have a grudge dude

[PookyTheMagicalBear]

if i was like scum

i wouldve shot you like days ago

[Cat Scratch Fever]

I feel like it shouldn't be that hard to convince myself that one of Enchant/Menalque/GuiltyLion are town

But it is

So I'm not sure I can honor your request Bell. Can you summarize why pooky is scum again? Is it the AtE today or the stuff from Mena's case?

[Cat Scratch Fever]

my take on our hood is that CSF and ceph were towny, pooky was scummy, and VP was neutral

also we need to track NKs

no kill last night means scum should have 1 kill.

if they have 2, it means that VPB is confscum, or if there's an extra nk after tomo then it means that (VPB, n2 defuser) contains at least 1 scum etc

[Bell]

It's the AtE. He only goes low like this when he's scum. He's fun otherwise. The sudden severe and unwarranted negativity and criticism is uniquely pooky scum.

[Cat Scratch Fever]

He kind of lost his shit in GnG's Upick Mafia too: https://forum.mafiascum.net/viewtopic.p ... er_sort=Go

First 100 or so posts

[Bell]

I mean, the request wasn’t to you anyway csf. You’ll be dead.

[Cat Scratch Fever]

If pooky is scum, then I may not be