In post 222, skitter30 wrote:@gl i guess when i read 157 and 158 the emphasis seems to be more on defending isis than questioning the votes on her, if that makes sense
Also did you have a problem with my vote on her?
In post 207, GuiltyLion wrote:Isis, meh 144 felt like it was just giving a random read rather than meant to push the game any sort of which way from it so I care less about it.
I mean i had voted her prior to this and she didnt react to that at all and instead just threw a vague townread on me which is ? to me
I didn't have an issue with your vote because "trying to find a reason to vote Beat" makes sense as scum-indicative behavior, even if I disagree with the observation the reasoning feels valid. It's not the same as "trying to replicate town meta" because that argument could be applied to virtually anything does, and Cakez claimed her posts were over the top when I didn't think that was true either.
tbh I didn't connect that Isis' townread on you was potentially in response to you voting her, imo it doesn't make a big difference but in the interest of no longer defending Isis too much I'll let her speak to that
"I think I no longer believe in monsters as faces in the floor or feral infants or vampires or whatever. I think at seventeen now I believe the only real monsters might be the type of liar where there's simply no way to tell. The ones who give nothing away"
In post 155, SirCakez wrote:These posts are so over the top that it just reads to me like Isis is trying to replicate her town meta
similar vein as what I just posted - why do you think scum!Isis would be so over the top you could catch her off of it just 4-5 pages into the game? doesn't that seem unlikely?
Maybe she thought she would get town reads for it? It seems pretty straightforward why do scum do anything? Usually to get town reads
In post 207, GuiltyLion wrote:meh I think some of that "too much defending" feeling is cause Meuh was saying my post sucked and challenging me on why I was asking Cakez about it, but fair enough
I do think Cakez townreading you is also bad yah, I would think after years of playing this game he would not be so trusting
Isis, meh 144 felt like it was just giving a random read rather than meant to push the game any sort of which way from it so I care less about it.
the main reason I focused on Meuh though was what I tried to show in my quoted posts, she disagrees and pushes back on your Beat read but then just goes "skitter town " immediately afterwards despite you doubling down on it
I'm pretty good at reading skitter so I feel okay dropping a read earlier
In post 179, GuiltyLion wrote:Meuh is my only real scumread and I don't like Cake's vote. waffley on Beat I could see her either way but I didn't like that one post I called out. There's also a few slots who haven't done anything at all that I need to get a read on
also, you can have a vote for lawyering on behalf of Cakez before he even answered my question
combined with your skitter and beat townreads, feels like you're trying to make buddies more than hunt scum
these reasons are the trashy, i feel like you as town would remember the time we both miselimated meuh and be more cautious about how you read her. i feel like ur the type of person to always try to see the two diff sides to things before committing to something, but wheres the weighing out both options here..?
now, im not sure if that exact game shes played "making buddies more than hunting" but i do remember i called her out for the "making friends more than hunting" reason in a different game without you and wound up being wrong so :shrug:
whats ur actual reason..? do u think she'll be an easy miselim..? is that why...?
In post 170, marcistar wrote:isis posts too much words but ends up saying nothing of value most of the time, but the rare post where theres value I like so isis town question mark?
meuh, i cant explain it.. like her posts dont really look bad at a glance... but something deep down is telling me we've got to be wary about her.
excuse me rude this was gonna be my secret twist read
I think GL's vote isn't one I will be following rn but it was a good vote
I FORGOT I SAID HER VIBES WERE BAD TBH EIUHFJDKC
i still stand by it, but i still stand by lions using shitty reasoning, he needs to get sumn better on her.
and wtf stop stealing my reads!@#@!@#! im the hard carry this game
In post 179, GuiltyLion wrote:Meuh is my only real scumread and I don't like Cake's vote. waffley on Beat I could see her either way but I didn't like that one post I called out. There's also a few slots who haven't done anything at all that I need to get a read on
also, you can have a vote for lawyering on behalf of Cakez before he even answered my question
combined with your skitter and beat townreads, feels like you're trying to make buddies more than hunt scum
these reasons are the trashy, i feel like you as town would remember the time we both miselimated meuh and be more cautious about how you read her. i feel like ur the type of person to always try to see the two diff sides to things before committing to something, but wheres the weighing out both options here..?
now, im not sure if that exact game shes played "making buddies more than hunting" but i do remember i called her out for the "making friends more than hunting" reason in a different game without you and wound up being wrong so :shrug:
whats ur actual reason..? do u think she'll be an easy miselim..? is that why...?
I wonder if GL has an aversion to the way I play, considering how much he talked about me in 2268... (https://forum.mafiascum.net/viewtopic.p ... er_sort=Go)
Like wow that scumread was intense and he mentioned me every other post, I feel bad for past me
But also that's an easy cop out for a faulty scumread with poor reasoning, so I probably shouldn't give it too much weight
In post 179, GuiltyLion wrote:Meuh is my only real scumread and I don't like Cake's vote. waffley on Beat I could see her either way but I didn't like that one post I called out. There's also a few slots who haven't done anything at all that I need to get a read on
also, you can have a vote for lawyering on behalf of Cakez before he even answered my question
combined with your skitter and beat townreads, feels like you're trying to make buddies more than hunt scum
these reasons are the trashy, i feel like you as town would remember the time we both miselimated meuh and be more cautious about how you read her. i feel like ur the type of person to always try to see the two diff sides to things before committing to something, but wheres the weighing out both options here..?
now, im not sure if that exact game shes played "making buddies more than hunting" but i do remember i called her out for the "making friends more than hunting" reason in a different game without you and wound up being wrong so :shrug:
whats ur actual reason..? do u think she'll be an easy miselim..? is that why...?
I wonder if GL has an aversion to the way I play, considering how much he talked about me in 2268... (https://forum.mafiascum.net/viewtopic.p ... er_sort=Go)
Like wow that scumread was intense and he mentioned me every other post, I feel bad for past me
But also that's an easy cop out for a faulty scumread with poor reasoning, so I probably shouldn't give it too much weight
...
did you forget about having this game before i pointed it out?
In post 179, GuiltyLion wrote:Meuh is my only real scumread and I don't like Cake's vote. waffley on Beat I could see her either way but I didn't like that one post I called out. There's also a few slots who haven't done anything at all that I need to get a read on
also, you can have a vote for lawyering on behalf of Cakez before he even answered my question
combined with your skitter and beat townreads, feels like you're trying to make buddies more than hunt scum
these reasons are the trashy, i feel like you as town would remember the time we both miselimated meuh and be more cautious about how you read her. i feel like ur the type of person to always try to see the two diff sides to things before committing to something, but wheres the weighing out both options here..?
now, im not sure if that exact game shes played "making buddies more than hunting" but i do remember i called her out for the "making friends more than hunting" reason in a different game without you and wound up being wrong so :shrug:
whats ur actual reason..? do u think she'll be an easy miselim..? is that why...?
I wonder if GL has an aversion to the way I play, considering how much he talked about me in 2268... (https://forum.mafiascum.net/viewtopic.p ... er_sort=Go)
Like wow that scumread was intense and he mentioned me every other post, I feel bad for past me
But also that's an easy cop out for a faulty scumread with poor reasoning, so I probably shouldn't give it too much weight
...
did you forget about having this game before i pointed it out?
Nah but I hadn't checked it, I remembered GL voting me but I forgot how adamant he was about it all
In post 179, GuiltyLion wrote:Meuh is my only real scumread and I don't like Cake's vote. waffley on Beat I could see her either way but I didn't like that one post I called out. There's also a few slots who haven't done anything at all that I need to get a read on
also, you can have a vote for lawyering on behalf of Cakez before he even answered my question
combined with your skitter and beat townreads, feels like you're trying to make buddies more than hunt scum
these reasons are the trashy, i feel like you as town would remember the time we both miselimated meuh and be more cautious about how you read her. i feel like ur the type of person to always try to see the two diff sides to things before committing to something, but wheres the weighing out both options here..?
now, im not sure if that exact game shes played "making buddies more than hunting" but i do remember i called her out for the "making friends more than hunting" reason in a different game without you and wound up being wrong so :shrug:
whats ur actual reason..? do u think she'll be an easy miselim..? is that why...?
I wonder if GL has an aversion to the way I play, considering how much he talked about me in 2268... (https://forum.mafiascum.net/viewtopic.p ... er_sort=Go)
Like wow that scumread was intense and he mentioned me every other post, I feel bad for past me
But also that's an easy cop out for a faulty scumread with poor reasoning, so I probably shouldn't give it too much weight
In post 179, GuiltyLion wrote:Meuh is my only real scumread and I don't like Cake's vote. waffley on Beat I could see her either way but I didn't like that one post I called out. There's also a few slots who haven't done anything at all that I need to get a read on
also, you can have a vote for lawyering on behalf of Cakez before he even answered my question
combined with your skitter and beat townreads, feels like you're trying to make buddies more than hunt scum
these reasons are the trashy, i feel like you as town would remember the time we both miselimated meuh and be more cautious about how you read her. i feel like ur the type of person to always try to see the two diff sides to things before committing to something, but wheres the weighing out both options here..?
now, im not sure if that exact game shes played "making buddies more than hunting" but i do remember i called her out for the "making friends more than hunting" reason in a different game without you and wound up being wrong so :shrug:
whats ur actual reason..? do u think she'll be an easy miselim..? is that why...?
I wonder if GL has an aversion to the way I play, considering how much he talked about me in 2268... (https://forum.mafiascum.net/viewtopic.p ... er_sort=Go)
Like wow that scumread was intense and he mentioned me every other post, I feel bad for past me
But also that's an easy cop out for a faulty scumread with poor reasoning, so I probably shouldn't give it too much weight
You don't think he's being genuine?
I think he's scum. He generally doesn't seem genuine or well-intentioned. Though your question seems like it's in response to my post but idk what specifically you're responding to
In post 179, GuiltyLion wrote:Meuh is my only real scumread and I don't like Cake's vote. waffley on Beat I could see her either way but I didn't like that one post I called out. There's also a few slots who haven't done anything at all that I need to get a read on
also, you can have a vote for lawyering on behalf of Cakez before he even answered my question
combined with your skitter and beat townreads, feels like you're trying to make buddies more than hunt scum
these reasons are the trashy, i feel like you as town would remember the time we both miselimated meuh and be more cautious about how you read her. i feel like ur the type of person to always try to see the two diff sides to things before committing to something, but wheres the weighing out both options here..?
now, im not sure if that exact game shes played "making buddies more than hunting" but i do remember i called her out for the "making friends more than hunting" reason in a different game without you and wound up being wrong so :shrug:
whats ur actual reason..? do u think she'll be an easy miselim..? is that why...?
I wonder if GL has an aversion to the way I play, considering how much he talked about me in 2268... (https://forum.mafiascum.net/viewtopic.p ... er_sort=Go)
Like wow that scumread was intense and he mentioned me every other post, I feel bad for past me
But also that's an easy cop out for a faulty scumread with poor reasoning, so I probably shouldn't give it too much weight
You don't think he's being genuine?
I think he's scum. He generally doesn't seem genuine or well-intentioned. Though your question seems like it's in response to my post but idk what specifically you're responding to
I think you answered what I asked even if I didn't communicate what I was asking very well
In post 170, marcistar wrote:isis posts too much words but ends up saying nothing of value most of the time, but the rare post where theres value I like so isis town question mark?
meuh, i cant explain it.. like her posts dont really look bad at a glance... but something deep down is telling me we've got to be wary about her.
have we played before or no, you changed your avatar so i can't store and retrieve that information well
only curiuos i dont think it affects the game
"Let us say that you are right and there are two worlds. How much, then, is this 'other world' worth to you? What do you have there that you do not have here? Money? Power? Something worth causing the prince so much pain for?'"
"Well, I..."
"What? Nothing? You would make the prince suffer over... nothing?"
" immediately afterwards despite you doubling down on it
