Open 854 | Eurybia's Curse | Game Over!

[Aristeia]

perhaps jokey is a bad word choice

I mean "casual"

[Isis]

mk

[Gamma Emerald]

it's happening again and I'm really sad

what is

[Meuh]

perhaps jokey is a bad word choice

I mean "casual"

Smart casual or business casual?

[Gamma Emerald]

Beat is probably the closest thing i have to a real scumread tbh

how so

Skitter has some good vibes so far, townread there!

think I agree

[Beat]

The Setup is designed around a Mafia lim always being more powerful than a town lim. Shooting for mafia every day is for the best

Ahh yes in Mafia we try to eliminate scum. Beat with the strats.

Dont like this taking the quote out of the relevant context.

[Beat]

I think we just win the game if we eliminate Pavo + GL

Feels.... overly confident and potentially malicious.

[Beat]

like, Meuh says she thinks Beat is town, thinks you're town and has no issue with your push on Beat

says she thinks Isis is town, has no issue with Cakez vote on Isis and actually grills me for calling it out

this is the behavior I'm pointing to when I say Meuh is looking more to make buddies than find scum, usually townies are at least somewhat suspicious of people voting and casing their townreads

I posted 79 because to me Skitter was pretty clearly wrong about the intent behind Beat's vote.

I guess maybe the thing I really want to ask here is - do you think Skitter being wrong about the intent of Beat's vote is town-indicative, or just completely NAI? What felt off to me the way you posted 79 and Skitter disagreed with you and reaffirmed she scumread Beat yet you then landed on a townread, I didn't understand the thought process of how that question and her answer lead to your read. But if 79 for you was nothing beyond clarifying a misconception then I might have less of an issue with it

I kind of doubt someone would purposely misinterpret a pretty clear memey vote to drive an agenda, tbh. I don't think it was purposeful so I just think it's NAI.
So yeah my intent with the post was just to clear that up, not defend Beat. I only really got the town-lean on Beat after looking into them from being prompted by Skitter. None of Beat's posts really stuck to me beforehand. Whether Skitter townreads Beat or not doesn't really matter to me when reading Skitter.

From the interactions here I don't think GL and Meuh are S/S. GLs push on Meuh feels. . undermining. It wouldnt be an effective bus and would only serve to weaken scum's hold on the gamestate. I could see it as either genuine scumread or scum shading so i think its nai individually, although Meuh's defense by reframing the question feels slightly scum indicitave

[Beat]

Note: Quoted are the bookends of stated interaction not the entire interaction

[Beat]

Don't Elim List: Beat, Marcistar, SirCakez, GuiltyLion, Isis

[Beat]

Looking over the messages and so far i'm getting townie vibes from both the Tiger PFPs

Why

[Aristeia]

I think we just win the game if we eliminate Pavo + GL

Feels.... overly confident and potentially malicious.

I am often overconfident but never malicious

[Titus]

I might spend this weekend being that girl and looking to provoke people.

[Beat]

We shall see

[Ydrasse]

VOTE COUNT 1.2

[3]

GuiltyLion

: Pavowski, Meuh, skitter30

[2]

Gamma Emerald

: Beat, Aristeia

[1]

skitter30

: Isis

[1]

Isis

: SirCakez

[1]

SirCakez

: GuiltyLion

[1]

Beat

: the worst

[1]

marcistar

: marcistar

[1]

the worst

: Titus

[2]

Not voting

: The Ugly Fruit, Gamma Emerald

With 13 alive, it takes 7 to eliminate.

Day one ends in (expired on 2022-06-12 18:48:05)

MOD NOTES

• please let me know if there are any errors, i do this by hand.

• skitter30 and the worst are currently v/la.

• have fun!

[GuiltyLion]

hey y'all just taking a quick skim not gonna be around playing much tonight but I wanna say I do TR Meuh's response to me in the tail end of that back and forth, I thought her approach tonally didn't feel too defensive and if I accept 79 being a clarification instead of a question with intent to sort it does resolve some of my gut dislike of it

[Titus]

hey y'all just taking a quick skim not gonna be around playing much tonight but I wanna say I do TR Meuh's response to me in the tail end of that back and forth, I thought her approach tonally didn't feel too defensive and if I accept 79 being a clarification instead of a question with intent to sort it does resolve some of my gut dislike of it

Why do you talk in word salad?

[Isis]

salad is yummy

[Gamma Emerald]

My magic 8 ball says Marci is town thus I must move my vote
VOTE: beat
Not a great entrance

i read this post and thought
"i think this is scummy? I'm not sure. I didn't really know how to read Cakez's twigtossy posting last time I played him. Oh I was scum that game. I formed too many in-character memories.

wait how do i read cakez now tho"

i'm gonna

read cakez midgame or something

I haven’t played with Cakez in a bit but I have had a good readrate on him the last few times I’ve done so

[Gamma Emerald]

VOTE: Gamma Emerald

y did u vote me here?

[Aristeia]

I didn't like that you dipped out of thread after Beat voted you

I just wanna say this plist makes me happy

VOTE: Guiltylion

Same

[Gamma Emerald]

VOTE: Meuh

also, you can have a vote for lawyering on behalf of Cakez before he even answered my question

combined with your skitter and beat townreads, feels like you're trying to make buddies more than hunt scum

Kinda feel GL is town for this

[Gamma Emerald]

I didn't like that you dipped out of thread after Beat voted you

I just wanna say this plist makes me happy

VOTE: Guiltylion

Same

I was busy
I’ve been rather slammed with schoolwork this past week

[Gamma Emerald]

like, Meuh says she thinks Beat is town, thinks you're town and has no issue with your push on Beat

says she thinks Isis is town, has no issue with Cakez vote on Isis and actually grills me for calling it out

this is the behavior I'm pointing to when I say Meuh is looking more to make buddies than find scum, usually townies are at least somewhat suspicious of people voting and casing their townreads

This sounds reasonable

[Gamma Emerald]

whats ur thoughts on the worst

no thoughts head empty
He’s like a late-game sort for me most times