Open 853 - PYP X/Y S_S [game over!]

[Aristeia]

Not really? Read the scum PT I linked, they were explicitly trying to be the highest numbers and succeeded.

ok and did they then knowing that they were the three biggest numbers decide to jump into the thread and say "hey we should be townread because we are the three biggest numbers?"

[Aristeia]

picking 18-20-42

is very different from picking

512 - 80085 - 9999999999999999999999

I'll let you figure out why.

[Ausuka]

Again, they were trying to pick large numbers, and they were the three highest numbers in practice. The mindset in the scum PT is far more important than the specific numbers they chose. Obviously I'm not saying this game is an exact replica of that game - I'm saying that the argument 'this would stand out and be suboptimal, therefore scum didn't do it' is wrong

[humaneatingmonkey]

im excited to move on from this numbers discussion. i can't get a decent reads out of it

[Ausuka]

feel free to propose an alternative

[Bellaphant]

im excited to move on from this numbers discussion. i can't get a decent reads out of it

This is why I called it busy work. Honestly I'm townread ing delete, I mean dweelee, just for replying with repeated numbers

[humaneatingmonkey]

okay

we have an ari wagon. does everybody feel the same way that she was creating a false setup spec narrative that high numbers are town wherein she also chose a high number? especially sus since i dont think it's even good town strategy to choose high numbers.

[humaneatingmonkey]

personally, i chose 80085 because i have personal sentimental memories associated with it. not because it would be good strategy.

[Aristeia]

so you're voting me for picking a high number even though you picked a higher number?

[Aristeia]

that's an interesting thought process

[humaneatingmonkey]

i voted you because it felt off that you are declaring that high numbers are town based on setup spec, and in an extension you, without regard for how accurate that statement would be.

[humaneatingmonkey]

so you're voting me for picking a high number even though you picked a higher number?

was i unclear or did you just try to misrep me right in front of my face? i hope it's not the latter. the disrespect.

[Harley Quinn]

okay

we have an ari wagon. does everybody feel the same way that she was creating a false setup spec narrative that high numbers are town wherein she also chose a high number? especially sus since i dont think it's even good town strategy to choose high numbers.

If she did that as more of a joke, it probably wouldn’t be too concerning.

[humaneatingmonkey]

i agree. don't know if it's a joke or not. i voted the moment i had the feeling. but now we have a wagon. not sure where others are.

[Harley Quinn]

aight ari, time's up. tell us what cool shit you're gonna do with the information we gave you.

not everyone has even responded or even put down 3 numbers

i see no point in explaining my thought process if people are unwilling to do a fairly simple task

What was your reasoning behind this exercise?

[Aristeia]

so you're voting me for picking a high number even though you picked a higher number?

was i unclear or did you just try to misrep me right in front of my face? i hope it's not the latter. the disrespect.

your post speaks for itself sir.

[Harley Quinn]

the draft phase is over.

the order of the draft is as follows:

Enchant	1
Ausuka	2
Harley Quinn	7
Bellaphant	9
Gamma Emerald	14
implosion	16
Malakittens	216
Aristeia	512
humaneatingmonkey	80085
Titus	999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999
Dwlee99	4
Roden	4
Save The Dragons	8
Klick	8

the mafia have selected the

informed

modifier - at the end of the second draft phase, the scumteam will receive a piece of information about the draft. if there are any role pairings which were not taken during the draft, the scumteam will be informed of one of these pairings. if there are multiple, they will be informed of one at random. if all role pairings were taken during the draft, the scumteam will be informed of this.

the role bidding phase begins now. for your convenience, i have also included the possible role choices below:

Spoiler:

night 3 vigilante	or	vengeful
1-shot vigilante	or	2-shot PGO (active)
ascetic cop	or	bulletproof
draft cop	or	1-shot watcher
doctor	or	roleblocker
universal backup	or	rolecop
neighborizer	or	voyeur
jailkeeper	or	tracker

please pm me

the specific role

you wish to be. you have about 48 hours to do so.

Another main problem with her theory is that only 4 people even chose high numbers, so what was even the point?

[Harley Quinn]

so you're voting me for picking a high number even though you picked a higher number?

was i unclear or did you just try to misrep me right in front of my face? i hope it's not the latter. the disrespect.

your post speaks for itself sir.

???

No one but you is making this an issue.

[Aristeia]

what do you mean?

[Aristeia]

I don't understand what you mean by "only four people"

would a different number of people make my theory more or less valid?

[Harley Quinn]

what do you mean?

The whole picking higher numbers is somehow town indicative and it’s a good idea to auto PoE in the lower numbers. That is what you’ve been saying, correct?

[Harley Quinn]

I don't understand what you mean by "only four people"

would a different number of people make my theory more or less valid?

Sure, because 7/11 picked lower numbers, so I don’t see your theory as helpful or why you’re defending it so strongly?

[Aristeia]

what do you mean?

The whole picking higher numbers is somehow town indicative and it’s a good idea to auto PoE in the lower numbers. That is what you’ve been saying, correct?

yes

[Aristeia]

I don't understand what you mean by "only four people"

would a different number of people make my theory more or less valid?

Sure, because 7/11 picked lower numbers, so I don’t see your theory as helpful or why you’re defending it so strongly?

9/13

why is it not helpful to rule out 4 players if they are all actually town?

[Harley Quinn]

I don't understand what you mean by "only four people"

would a different number of people make my theory more or less valid?

Sure, because 7/11 picked lower numbers, so I don’t see your theory as helpful or why you’re defending it so strongly?

9/13

why is it not helpful to rule out 4 players if they are all actually town?

Because it’s a bad metric as Ausuka has already pointed out.

Make reads based off of posting not numbers.