open 852: store bought potions (sold!)

[humaneatingmonkey]

well.. not everyone needs to agree. i need at least 4 i think.

[Venus and Mars]

Thats kind of my point, it doesn't make a lot of sense for scum!HEM to just throw suspicion on random slots that aren't getting limmed a day before deadline

As town HEM could be hunting legitimately this way

I still think Kitty is lhf but it does concern me that he isn’t trying to re-evaluate you.

@Roden, why does Shiro posting or not posting make such a difference to you? I mean there’s a lot to get caught up on, so not really sure why you’re waiting on that.

[humaneatingmonkey]

i'll get on roden shortly after we have decided what to do with kitty. im on the move right now and could only do this in about 8 hours. i dont expect to convert people, i just want to say my piece in case i die or something.

[Venus and Mars]

i'll vote kitty just for 1261. this isn't town kitty. kitty is mostly self-aware, iirc.

Anyone else think it's sus as hell that the STD wagon dissolved and his most prolific pusher is being wagoned now? STD is scum, and scum is sterring people away from him.

Do you have any meta that I can look at?

[Venus and Mars]

@Flea, I’m tending to agree with STD on HEM. I don’t understand you’re read?

[Venus and Mars]

his most prolific pusher

that's the boldest claim since the manifest destiny

i'll vote kitty just for 1261. this isn't town kitty. kitty is mostly self-aware, iirc.

does everyone else agree with me in my assessment on kitty? kitty seems self-aware in that game and not making absurd claims like being the most prolific pusher of std...

this is the asterisk on kitty. if not everyone agrees that kitty's pov is off and he's acting out of character like a parody of something, i'm dropping this.

well.. not everyone needs to agree. i need at least 4 i think.

I need to see an example of Kitty meta for me to have an opinion on this but this doesn’t sound like a post likely for scum to make.

[humaneatingmonkey]

https://forum.mafiascum.net/viewtopic.php?f=2&t=89313 this is the game i had with kitty. thank you in advance

[Venus and Mars]

ill submit a narrative report later.

i misunderstood flea, i think. but i still want to wait on what fae's gonna do later. that's why it's an asterisk.

Both Italiano and Flea strongly sr you but these most recent posts of yours, I don’t recall ever seeing posts like that coming from scum. Asking for consensus like that is usually town indicative.

I look for mindsets, that’s a big part of why I tr fire and sr furtive in Merlin and why I tr Gamma in both. In my experience, even the most experienced scum has trouble faking that.

[Roden]

Thats kind of my point, it doesn't make a lot of sense for scum!HEM to just throw suspicion on random slots that aren't getting limmed a day before deadline

As town HEM could be hunting legitimately this way

I still think Kitty is lhf but it does concern me that he isn’t trying to re-evaluate you.

@Roden, why does Shiro posting or not posting make such a difference to you? I mean there’s a lot to get caught up on, so not really sure why you’re waiting on that.

Because I town read you, and I think it would be helpful to get some fresh takes from someone who shares a slot with you.

[Roden]

HEM, why exactly do you scum read me? And what did I say that made me jump up your scum list past Flea?

[Roden]

Also what happened to your STD read

[humaneatingmonkey]

if kitty flips scum, N_M and STD are locktowns for me.

[Venus and Mars]

asterisks are certain conditions

my townreads are gamma, facebones, nancy, n_m*, std*

{enchant, dwlee} undefined number of scum here

I think Dwlee has pretty high scum equity. He hasn’t even attempted to re-evaluate me. I have no clue wrt Enchant.

The one read of yours I feel very confident you’re wrong on is Flea. Fae’s decent at scum but faer meta would have had to have significantly changed from Merlin game to this one if scum here and it was pretty recent.

[Venus and Mars]

asterisks are certain conditions

my townreads are gamma, facebones, nancy, n_m*, std*

{enchant, dwlee} undefined number of scum here

I think Dwlee has pretty high scum equity. He hasn’t even attempted to re-evaluate me. I have no clue wrt Enchant.

The one read of yours I feel very confident you’re wrong on is Flea. Fae’s decent at scum but faer meta would have had to have significantly changed from Merlin game to this one if scum here and it was pretty recent.

FUCK

THEY

. fuck me.

[Roden]

if kitty flips scum, N_M and STD are locktowns for me.

Why?

okay you can continue to not like them because i dont really have much to say. each passing moment, our intuition is betrayed by our second-guessing and i want to hold on to the really strong stuff that i felt watching std waffle and be scummy.

std's flip will inform the std vs nancy situation and give us a better perspective on how everyone was positioned there. i mentioned that earlier i think. n_m is opaque and has targetted kitty after giving nancy shit the whole game.

What happened to this?

[Venus and Mars]

Sorry again Dwlee.

[Venus and Mars]

does everyone else agree with me in my assessment on kitty? kitty seems self-aware in that game and not making absurd claims like being the most prolific pusher of std...

It’s more of an issue not re-evaluating for me. Idk, well he really is the main one pushing him rn, so idk if “prolific” necessarily means anything?

but he was bleeding obvtown in that other game, so I could be wrong.

I think my good cop/bad cop analogy is probably right. I think one scum is pushing me and one could possibly be pocketing me. The 3rd could be either or not doing either.

[humaneatingmonkey]

okay. that's a one. i need three more contrast and comparisons. who wants to volunteer?

[humaneatingmonkey]

@Gamma
@Roden
@Facebones
Since you all were in that game, I could use your notes. Roden, you can pitch in too because that's still great content.

[Venus and Mars]

Thats kind of my point, it doesn't make a lot of sense for scum!HEM to just throw suspicion on random slots that aren't getting limmed a day before deadline

As town HEM could be hunting legitimately this way

I still think Kitty is lhf but it does concern me that he isn’t trying to re-evaluate you.

@Roden, why does Shiro posting or not posting make such a difference to you? I mean there’s a lot to get caught up on, so not really sure why you’re waiting on that.

Because I town read you, and I think it would be helpful to get some fresh takes from someone who shares a slot with you.

Shiro had an extremely busy day and hasn’t read anything yet.

[humaneatingmonkey]

im writing now

[Venus and Mars]

if kitty flips scum, N_M and STD are locktowns for me.

Do you think bussing could be 100% out of the question? I admit, it does seem unlikely though. But I was in a game once where the entire scumteam hardbussed it’s most powerful pr and they wound up winning. So I wouldn’t locktown anyone for that.

[humaneatingmonkey]

could be, that may have been the reason why it was so comical that he called himself "the most prolific critic" of std or something.

[humaneatingmonkey]

like it was an over-the-top attempt to make it seem like they're really unaligned.

i dig you. i dig you.

[Venus and Mars]

could be, that may have been the reason why it was so comical that he called himself "the most prolific critic" of std or something.

Also, I have seen scum!NM hardbus and early, so I’d actually be more suspicious of him if Kitty’s scum because he never called him “caught scum” like he has me.

Since STD has never taken such a fixed stance on me, a Kitty scum flip would look somewhat better for him. In Anything uPick scum!Sakura bussed her entire team and was so brilliant, even the dead thread was shocked she was scum.