open 852: store bought potions (sold!)

[humaneatingmonkey]

EVEN I PUSHED HARDER THAN YOU HAHAHA

[KittyTacky]

KittyTacky (2): Not_Mafia, Save The Dragons

what a wagon

your theory is two scum buddies are voting you to silence you about one/both of them being scum and just hoping town falls on it

It wouldn't be very sus by itself but the wagon on you dissolved at the same time.

NANCY

I thought I was pushing harder than her. Or as hard. Also I'm easier to push than Nancy because I am LHF.

EVEN I PUSHED HARDER THAN YOU HAHAHA

Half my posts are about STD, what are you talking about mate?

[Venus and Mars]

his most prolific pusher

that's the boldest claim since the manifest destiny

i'll vote kitty just for 1261. this isn't town kitty. kitty is mostly self-aware, iirc.

Legit curious who you think is pushing STD harder.

Can you give us some reads?

Other than STD and me. I assume you’re still sr NM? What do you think of Roden’s read on you?

[Roden]

Where was my momentum if you think I lost it?

Std and nancy stopped being viable wagons and they're what you cited

Why do I only want you to look bad if Kitty flips town and not STD? If Kitty is my partner then why do I only shut you down and leave STD alone?

These aren't in my mind, tbt. But would it only be me who would look bad?

How do you read STD, anyway?

I never pushed Nancy and actively tried to stop her wagon. I slowed the momentum on STD myself. So I guess the accusation is that I purposely killed my own momentum...? Response to that is no I'm not game-throwing scum that's killing my own momentum in the game.

Who else looks bad if I'm discrediting you?

I've settled on town for STD because I don't think he's bold enough to fake feeling bad about making me feel bad. There are other reasons as well but that's the one that made me settle when assessing him.

[KittyTacky]

his most prolific pusher

that's the boldest claim since the manifest destiny

i'll vote kitty just for 1261. this isn't town kitty. kitty is mostly self-aware, iirc.

Legit curious who you think is pushing STD harder.

Can you give us some reads?

Other than STD and me. I assume you’re still sr NM? What do you think of Roden’s read on you?

Yeah, NM is still a scumlean. I actually think Roden is town, I understand 100% why he scumreads me and I have been liking his play so far. He's just wrong about me and STD.

[Venus and Mars]

NANCY

FLEA

Flea’s pushing you harder and no one is currently pushing NM harder than me.

[humaneatingmonkey]

I'm not game-throwing scum that's killing my own momentum in the game.

i kill my own momentum every time. that's how you get pocketz

[KittyTacky]

As for reads, I haven't made a reads list yet. But Venus is my biggest TR, followed by Flea. Mostly on gut.

[KittyTacky]

HEM is hard to sort for me.

[humaneatingmonkey]

kitty is making the case that he's the most prolific. as in, voluminous and constant. he was barely a force in shaping public opinion of std, is what im saying. nancy, flea, and maybe i contributed a lot more to it.

kitty, do you think you were the most pressing threat to std the moment you made the post?

[humaneatingmonkey]

i think i'm laying out the obvtown right now with no regard for how i can replicate it in any scum game.

[Roden]

I'm not game-throwing scum that's killing my own momentum in the game.

i kill my own momentum every time. that's how you get pocketz

Do you? You won the last two scum games I played with you by hard pushing mis-elims and tunneling Mala + Leaf/Gamma.

[Venus and Mars]

VOTE: Kittytacky back to this i think? i just disagree with nancy's tr of kitty

what scares me is what i said earlier about nancy possibly town reading someone she knows is a townie (as scum) or defending her partner (as scum). so my biggest concern with a kitty elim is that it's not going to help me solve nancy at all

@Kitty, besides the vote on you, what do you think of the rest of STD’s post?

[humaneatingmonkey]

none of those pushes went through.

[humaneatingmonkey]

Leaf townread me. Mala left me alone.

[humaneatingmonkey]

dont copy that

[KittyTacky]

i'll vote kitty just for 1261. this isn't town kitty. kitty is mostly self-aware, iirc.

Anyone else think it's sus as hell that the STD wagon dissolved and his most prolific pusher is being wagoned now? STD is scum, and scum is sterring people away from him.

Do you have any meta that I can look at?

Town game 1: https://forum.mafiascum.net/viewtopic.php?f=2&t=89071
Town game 2: https://forum.mafiascum.net/viewtopic.php?f=2&t=89313

Scum game 1: https://forum.mafiascum.net/viewtopic.php?f=54&t=86947
Scum game 2: https://forum.mafiascum.net/viewtopic.php?f=2&t=86404

I can be a village idiot sometimes, I am prone to saying dumb shit as either alignment, just my playstyle.

VOTE: Kittytacky back to this i think? i just disagree with nancy's tr of kitty

what scares me is what i said earlier about nancy possibly town reading someone she knows is a townie (as scum) or defending her partner (as scum). so my biggest concern with a kitty elim is that it's not going to help me solve nancy at all

@Kitty, besides the vote on you, what do you think of the rest of STD’s post?

If he's scum, he's pushing me because I am a threat

and

it won't give town info. If he's town, he just thinks I'm scum. But I think he's more likely scum.

[Not_Mafia]

I’m pushing Kitty because

A) I don’t believe the Nancy Elim will go through, not today at least
B) Nancy asked me to back off and I’m okay with putting it on the back burner for now

[Venus and Mars]

@Kitty, what do you think of my NM case?

[KittyTacky]

does everyone else agree with me in my assessment on kitty? kitty seems self-aware in that game and not making absurd claims like being the most prolific pusher of std...

It’s more of an issue not re-evaluating for me. Idk, well he really is the main one pushing him rn, so idk if “prolific” necessarily means anything?

but he was bleeding obvtown in that other game, so I could be wrong.

I think my good cop/bad cop analogy is probably right. I think one scum is pushing me and one could possibly be pocketing me. The 3rd could be either or not doing either.

kitty is making the case that he's the most prolific. as in, voluminous and constant. he was barely a force in shaping public opinion of std, is what im saying. nancy, flea, and maybe i contributed a lot more to it.

kitty, do you think you were the most pressing threat to std the moment you made the post?

Is "most prolific" not a synonym for "main"? That was what I meant. And yes. I think I am his main pusher at this point, at least.

[Venus and Mars]

I’m pushing Kitty because

A) I don’t believe the Nancy Elim will go through, not today at least
B) Nancy asked me to back off and I’m okay with putting it on the back burner for now

Why aren’t you listening to anyone else’s reads on me?

[KittyTacky]

@Kitty, what do you think of my NM case?

I do think that the inconsistency he showed with his pushes is weird. One of my reasons for SRing NM. This also doesn't "feel" like town NM.

[KittyTacky]

Getting sussed for idiotic posting as town is nothing new for me.

[humaneatingmonkey]

mm yeah i think im willing to be wrong about kitty. roden too.

[Venus and Mars]

@Kitty, what do you think of my NM case?

I do think that the inconsistency he showed with his pushes is weird. One of my reasons for SRing NM. This also doesn't "feel" like town NM.

So why not vote him then? I think STD is more likely to be town here than NM. It’s not townie to ignore other players’ reads and not reacess. NM isn’t even considering the possibility he could be wrong.