open 852: store bought potions (sold!)

[humaneatingmonkey]

im busy today. i want to vote n_m, enchant, facebones.

[Venus and Mars]

Im on rodens side in this debate

Oh really? He sounds more like overwhelmed town to me than anything but I suppose I could be swayed by his mindmelding with me on Flea/Gamma but still don’t see why it’s necessarily “off”?

[humaneatingmonkey]

no maybe not facebones

maybe actually roden, n_m, enchant

[Venus and Mars]

im busy today. i want to vote n_m, enchant, facebones.

Why FB? You townbinned him previously.

[humaneatingmonkey]

i got convinced of facebones being bewildered constantly as a scumtell. then i realized it doesn't make sense, and saw that it was roden who floated that idea.

[Roden]

Face you kinda need to do something besides acting bewildered and befuddled

I have no idea where to place you in this game, and hedging on where to vote isn't helping

It isn't like you didn't have an entire day phase to poke around and question people. Getting mad and overwhelmed about not knowing where to vote now just looks off.

Why?

I dont know, okay?
I DON'T KNOW

Stop yelling at me, Roden

@Roden, I don’t understand how you get “off” from this?

I don't think it's fair to come in at EoD and complain you don't know what to do if you didn't really do anything all Day in the first place

Everyone else actually has takes on the game

It's annoying if he's town and just an excuse if he's scum

[humaneatingmonkey]

It's annoying if he's town and just an excuse if he's scum

this is not actual scumhunting guys

[humaneatingmonkey]

VOTE: Roden

[Roden]

i got convinced of facebones being bewildered constantly as a scumtell. then i realized it doesn't make sense, and saw that it was roden who floated that idea.

Are you referring to this?

I only played with Face once, it was in a Newbie and he was town. General lack of activity and presence matches up with what I remember of him. I don't have much of an opinion on him besides that.

[humaneatingmonkey]

Final answer.

monkey ouuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuut

[humaneatingmonkey]

Face you kinda need to do something besides acting bewildered and befuddled

I have no idea where to place you in this game, and hedging on where to vote isn't helping

It isn't like you didn't have an entire day phase to poke around and question people. Getting mad and overwhelmed about not knowing where to vote now just looks off.

[Roden]

It's annoying if he's town and just an excuse if he's scum

this is not actual scumhunting guys

Cool, I wasn't hunting. I told him to vote and stop hedging.

VOTE: Roden

Is Kitty town now?

[humaneatingmonkey]

Roden has not been actually scumhunting. Just poking at annoying things that might annoy town and then using that to paint a scummy picture.

[humaneatingmonkey]

Yes I think Kitty could be town and sincere and just silly

[Roden]

Face you kinda need to do something besides acting bewildered and befuddled

I have no idea where to place you in this game, and hedging on where to vote isn't helping

It isn't like you didn't have an entire day phase to poke around and question people. Getting mad and overwhelmed about not knowing where to vote now just looks off.

Where does this say Face constantly being bewildered is a scum tell?

[Venus and Mars]

i got convinced of facebones being bewildered constantly as a scumtell. then i realized it doesn't make sense, and saw that it was roden who floated that idea.

I have no meta on FB but I read his “I don’t know” as sounding like confused and overwhelmed town. I also think that since Flea and Gamma are such obvious townies here, I don’t see the scum motivation for making that comment.

Wrt Roden, his frustration in his back and forth with you sounded kind of genuine to me but I like FB not immediately jumping on Kitty whatever he is, especially because I’m not convinced Kitty’s scum here and not lhf.

Usually when there’s a pile up on a player who isn’t flaming obvscum, they tend to be a mislim, unless it’s a bus. I currently lean the former.

[Roden]

Roden has not been actually scumhunting. Just poking at annoying things that might annoy town and then using that to paint a scummy picture.

K

Yes I think Kitty could be town and sincere and just silly

So you once again wanted us to follow you on a wagon and just trust you on it before again changing your mind

Got it

[Roden]

HEM has scum read and backed off of scum reading four different slots now, with literally zero provocation from the slot he was scum reading

[Roden]

VOTE: HEM

[humaneatingmonkey]

So you once again wanted us to follow you on a wagon and just trust you on it before again changing your mind

Got it

this is a discredit. roden would actually try and understand if this is my town gameplay. he's using it so i'm treated as silly dumb dumb in this game.

[Venus and Mars]

Face you kinda need to do something besides acting bewildered and befuddled

I have no idea where to place you in this game, and hedging on where to vote isn't helping

It isn't like you didn't have an entire day phase to poke around and question people. Getting mad and overwhelmed about not knowing where to vote now just looks off.

Why?

I dont know, okay?
I DON'T KNOW

Stop yelling at me, Roden

@Roden, I don’t understand how you get “off” from this?

I don't think it's fair to come in at EoD and complain you don't know what to do if you didn't really do anything all Day in the first place

Everyone else actually has takes on the game

It's annoying if he's town and just an excuse if he's scum

None of that makes him scum. Where is he “complaining”? All he said was for you not to “yell” at him? Not saying I agree with that but I don’t understand your harshness on his slot.

[humaneatingmonkey]

roden is so strained trying to mount a scum case on people and relying on mistakes to paint a narrative.

[Roden]

So you once again wanted us to follow you on a wagon and just trust you on it before again changing your mind

Got it

this is a discredit. roden would actually try and understand if this is my town gameplay. he's using it so i'm treated as silly dumb dumb in this game.

Did you or did you not ask us to trust you on two different scum cases before backing off without them actually saying anything first

[humaneatingmonkey]

he did this with me, facebones, and now as i see clearly, kitty.

[humaneatingmonkey]

Roden is obvscum here guys see for yourself