Mini 2273: Science Diagrams That Look Like Shitposts 2 [END]

[Corwinoid]

I am genuinely curious how the people who've played with him before really feel about him.

[Umlaut]

Vote Count 1.3

Not_Mafia (4):

Not_Mafia, GoldfishFromTheMoon, Alexcellent, Corwinoid

Corwinoid (2):

UNOwen, Vivax

geraintm (1):

clidd

Elsa Jay (1):

gibus

Alexcellent (1):

GeorgeBailey

clidd (1):

geraintm

gibus (1):

Elsa Jay

Crescent (1):

Eiralox

Not voting (1):

Crescent

With 13 alive, it takes 7 to launch.

Deadline:

(expired on 2022-06-12 13:13:00)

[Crescent]

Votes have come out faster this game than they did in the last one, despite half the player base having a vote down last game in less than a day. Interesting.

[Crescent]

Though what's not interesting? 8 different players having votes in a game of 13 is absolutely ridiculous. If there's anything scum always wants, it's that kinda total cluster****. Before those votes on NM, not sure anyone on that list was even above 2.

And the person I'd vote first right now to pressure isn't even on the list!

[GoldfishFromTheMoon]

And the person I'd vote first right now to pressure isn't even on the list!

Who is it?

[Crescent]

Look up 219 and 221 and the answer is right there.

[GoldfishFromTheMoon]

Look up 219 and 221 and the answer is right there.

Georgebailey?

[Crescent]

Oh wow looking at his ISO again I completely missed the part where he said he was Vanya last game. Interesting. Very interesting.

He was so inactive he eventually got replaced, but he doesn't feel like remotely the same player. He constantly came off as abrasively pointed and I gut townread him for it. He voted aggressively and often, and as far as I can tell did not do so without an obvious reason (the vote on you) He practically seems... Aloof in comparison this game. Like, he was barely active last game, but he was way more of a factor when he was actually around to post than this.

[Crescent]

Anyways it just makes me want to pressure that slot even more now.

It doesn't take long at all to compare the two ISOs, either. The only thing that vibes similar is the specific way he questioned Alex when voting. I definitely want to see more out of him.

[Alexcellent]

He seriously just put names in random order on a rainbow font while of course putting himself at the bottom.

Why do you people even let this guy sign up for games? How do you read such nonsense

I mean, these could actually be his reads and he's just thrown his own name in for the lols

But also, could just be trolling.

[Crescent]

There is no way that list is an accurate reflection of anyone's reads.

[GoldfishFromTheMoon]

There is no way that list is an accurate reflection of anyone's reads.

I don't think they are

completely

ridiculous, I've seen people draw pretty strange conclusions in mafia before, and it's always possible his role is informed or something. But I doubt these are actually his reads, I think it's just trolling and until not mafia posts some reasoning behind the reads I will treat them as such.

[Eiralox]

Crescent and Gibus are scum together, got it

Alexcellent,

considering the thread as it is now, is this pairing more or less probable since start of day one?

Oh I get the thirty-second post? What an honor... What to do with it do? Give a speech? Randomly vote? Claim to be a town leader and get shot night one? So many choices.

I'll stick with the basics though.

VOTE: Crescent

... I'll make a better vote later.

P.S.

I think the difference is some town get bad-vibes from it and decide to pressure me to get a better read, but it doesn't really ping anything from scum as something worth pursuing, which is why that vote usually comes from town.

What makes you think that gibus wasn't just random voting?

'Cause an entire day had passed and his "sticking with the basics" line suggests having an actual reason to vote that wasn't strong enough to actually go into detail on.

Crescent

, idk if u missed gibus's jokey nature(i'm making assumptions) but well.. any vote at the very start of day one will be a random vote, unless it's made by scum. My analysis of Gibus here is that 'sticking to the basics' means voting for cat lovers, which they might have assumed due to your meow in #16. (This theory of canine fascism is further supported by Gibus' vote on Elsa)(So hard reason? No. Soft cat reason? probable, therefore i consider it random unless it is a scum-clearing vote, ie. vote for buddy early to set the record.

I note that before gibus vote you have posted nothing which can read one way or another, so clearing Gib as town and stating that their vote was not random is well.... not logical. If you didn't do this early read and instead had your first 'they voted for me so prob/pos town' moment with me, as I've sorta been reading u to have, i'd not be suspicious, not at all... but come one, page 2, how can that not be a random vote if Gibus is town?

[Eiralox]

I consider it a really bad sign that a 2 day old game is already talking about inactive hunting. This doesn't feel like a discussion that has a place this early in a day.

I agree, the game has barely started we can't identify lurkers.

For reference:

Crescent 16
Elsa 12
clidd 7
Vivax 5
Alexcellent 5
Not_Mafia 4
GeorgeBailey 4
Umlaut 4
GoldfishFromTheMoon 4
geraintm 3
Corwinoid 2
UNOwen 2
gibus 1
Eiralox 1

I actually thought we had 0 posters, but apparently we don't.

Bailey, Cori, NM, and Eiralox have no game advancing content. Eiralox was basically "checking in" and never posted again.

once again, 100% fluff, more so than my post. you calling me on it suggests you were on the hunt, whether as town or scum... time will tell.

[Eiralox]

you can argue that your summation made it easier for town, as i argue of mine... so your meta regarding that interaction still reads scummy to me.

[Eiralox]

Gibus I also think is town

Why?

GoldFishFromTheMoon,

you did not answer this question.

UNOwen,

you did not press for an answer.

[Corwinoid]

you can argue that your summation made it easier for town, as i argue of mine... so your meta regarding that interaction still reads scummy to me.

I'm not sure where you're going with this. I haven't read Crescent either way, do you want to push something or bicker about fluff until something breaks?

[Eiralox]

And Eiralox just strikes me as waiting for something to actually happen before doing something instead of trying to force it to happen.

The wall post.. Honestly doesn't really say anything though. It rehashes the game, but it doesn't actually provide any content that advances the game, as it includes little to no reads or reactions to what they're rehashing. It's just a long post that exists for the sake of existing.

wording in the first sentence.... something about that... hm.

Anyway, here we go: ISO Eira: Before #148 i have asked several direct questions, some of them read-requests, the first of which was my 5th post in total, 4th if we discount dud vote. directly interacted with Elsa and geraintm at this point.

so again i fail to see your logic, explain how i waited before doing something, explain how I didn't try to force anything?

ISO Crescent: before #148, these are the only two direct questions you have asked:

Interactions would be fun to read. The Queen demands entertainment.

The Emperor Demands It.

We can always do the age old "vote out whoever posts last" thing. That's worked out before.

Are you saying this to try to get people to post, or is this actually a serious suggestion?

Was there supposed to be a vote count with that?

I only see non-retro read-related analysis in #43, #49, #72, #146, #147 (the latter two being the most detailed by far coming after my much-decried post where I state "so much of it is what they did previous games, another third a meta-analysis of what they're likely to do, and the rest very soft reads with little confrontational evidence-seeking, the only asked questions are a bit watery and don't seem in the inquisitive spirit."


soooo.... some flimsy shade being thrown here imo, once more i get the feel ur on the hunt.

[Eiralox]

you can argue that your summation made it easier for town, as i argue of mine... so your meta regarding that interaction still reads scummy to me.

I'm not sure where you're going with this. I haven't read Crescent either way, do you want to push something or bicker about fluff until something breaks?

how about giving me reads on Gibus, Crescent and UNOwen instead of admiring my fluff?
And if not on Not_Mafia, where would your vote be now?

[Eiralox]

ok lol u stated read bout crescent, the other then : l

[Vivax]

Good morning.

UNVOTE: Corwinoid
VOTE: GeorgeBailey

Almost voted not_mafia, but it'd be more useful to keep him around as pet troll for now.
If he really triggers that many people to the point it's all I can read about, I'll reconsider.

Corwin/George looks like a good combo still.

[Eiralox]

Gibus I also think is town

Why?

GoldFishFromTheMoon,

you did not answer this question.

UNOwen,

you did not press for an answer.

@Goldfish - you may have missed my question 126

Who was copying what now?

gibus first post copies Elsa first post, "stick to the basics" looks more suggestive without this context.

Apologies UNOwen u did press for an answer

[Eiralox]

@Goldfish - you may have missed my question 126

Who was copying what now?

gibus first post copies Elsa first post, "stick to the basics" looks more suggestive without this context.

Yeah I did miss it sorry,
So my logic at the time was that we were a few real time days into the game and gibus basically hadn't produced any content except for some joking around and a vote that didn't look serious, I didn't think scum would risk that because in my experience scum tend to have a high post count early on day one to try and seem present and helpful, steer the game, and avoid being scumread for lurking, if they are going to drop off it usually happens much later.

The read is tentative and is subject to change though and now that some proper content is happening I'll need to look through again.

and apologies Goldfish u did answer XD ugh i'm segmenting this too much

[Eiralox]

U

N

O

w

e

n

E

l

s

a

J

a

y

c

l

i

d

d

G

e

o

r

g

e

B

a

i

l

e

y

g

e

r

a

i

n

t

m

C

o

r

w

i

n

o

i

d

C

r

e

s

c

e

n

t

g

i

b

u

s

G

o

l

d

f

i

s

h

F

r

o

m

T

h

e

M

o

o

n

V

i

v

a

x

A

l

e

x

c

e

l

l

e

n

t

E

i

r

a

l

o

x

N

o

t

_

M

a

f

i

a

Yo @Not_Mafia, can u expand on ur Elsa Jay, Clidd, Alexcellent and Vivax placements? Any method behind the rainbow or will you continue to be mute?

[Vivax]

Is there really a chance he's jester?

Eiralox I think you took his bait hook line and sinker. I wouldn't assume there's any meaning behind that list.