open 852: store bought potions (sold!)

[Save The Dragons]

VOTE: gamma

[Save The Dragons]

VOTE: hem

[Venus and Mars]

so done with people not engaging me on good faith

How am I engaging you in bad faith? I’m pointing out your argument is bad.

I’m not saying that scum couldn’t pretend to be mech uninformed. I’m saying that a team that had an io of sense would extemely likely to be discussing it.

I haven’t voted you and rn, I’m leaning B).

i think you really haven’t thought this through and I think scum!you would probably not be making this type of easily debunked argument.

~M

[Save The Dragons]

i'm not wrong though

[Save The Dragons]

you're not paying attention to what i'm saying

[Save The Dragons]

and i could say it 100 different ways and we are just not connecting and you could say your thing 100 different ways and we are just not connecting

[Save The Dragons]

like it's probable that scumgamma is faking being informed

or that he hasn't done the due diligence with EVERY possible thing and decided to ask in the thread

both are possible and debunk your point

and yet i'm just wrong to you

[Save The Dragons]

because you wanna strawman me for saying scum don't talk mech

[Save The Dragons]

VOTE: hem

sheeping roden because why not

[Venus and Mars]

VOTE: hem

Interesting, so you’ve obviously changed your mind about the TvT.

So who do you think are HEM’s buddies then?

What I’m struggling with is that he claimed to have used harmography on me and he wouldn’t have had any way of knowing I had a jk right?

Now of course that is nai. It’s also possible that he used harmography on me to see if anyone used a pain potion on me, so if scum, he could then finish the job.

However, it’s pretty clear that the only player who would be likely to use a pain potion on me was NM but if HEM!scum and NM!town then he wouldn’t know that I’d be targeted. Or if scum, he’s buddies with NM and knows? or he knows I was targeted and hoping to frame NM for my death?

Like I think it’s extremely likely that NM used his pain potion on me, so either if HEM!scum, NM either a buddy and HEM knew it or he was possibly setting him up but yeah, why did he use harmography on me?

I would think if someone were to use a harmography potion it would have been on Flea.

@HEM why did you use harmography on me?

Also Flea is super obvtown here, so that take concerns me.

[Save The Dragons]

Interesting, so you’ve obviously changed your mind about the TvT.

not really i'm just kind of giving up right now

maybe i'll feel it later

[Venus and Mars]

because you wanna strawman me for saying scum don't talk mech

???

I said I think it’s B. I think your argument that scum wouldn’t have discussed mech makes little sense. Read my posts. I don’t think you’re scum.

You’re thought process sounds genuine. There’s a difference between an logically flawed thought process and a scum one. It’s hard to explain but I don’t know if you understand my point but believe you think this.

You’re still not great a reading me but I don’t believe this is ever a scum take.

Scum generally isn’t good at faking something like that.

~M

[Save The Dragons]

my argument

is

not

that

scum

would

have

not

dis
c

cus

sed

mech

[Venus and Mars]

Interesting, so you’ve obviously changed your mind about the TvT.

not really i'm just kind of giving up right now

maybe i'll feel it later

Okay, why do you think HEM used harmography on me?

He knows that NM irrespective of alignment would very likely have used a pp on me if he had one. So yeah, I’m a bit suspicious of that but if he and NM are aligned that he would of course have to have known that.

So it doesn’t really make logical sense for them to be aligned.

~M

[Save The Dragons]

that's a good point

[Venus and Mars]

I’m saying that HEM and NM are not aligned.

[Save The Dragons]

yes that's fine

NM is town
HEM could be town/scum

[Venus and Mars]

I’m saying that HEM and NM are not aligned.

Sorry I posted that before I read your last post.

[Venus and Mars]

yes that's fine

NM is town
HEM could be town/scum

He has Roden and Flea in his PoE, both who hard tr me. First off, Flea is never scum here but why would either Roden and Flea want to kill me?

So that really doesn’t make much sense.

[Venus and Mars]

My theory is that if scum, HEM wanted to find out if NM had a pain potion or not because he absolutely knew that if he had one, he’d probably use it on me.

This wouldn’t really be suspicious at all to me if his PoE didn’t have 2 players in it who have no reason to kill me.

And I think you’re town, so I see a disconnect between using harmography on me and his PoE.

[Save The Dragons]

im distracted at the moment i will think about it when i have free braincells

[Save The Dragons]

UNVOTE:

[Venus and Mars]

*kicks self for not waiting to claim jk later because that might have possibly influenced other claims*

[Venus and Mars]

Fuck forgot it was weekend and I was larping.
also larping tomorrow.

SO, I was convinced on FB. I'm still set on V&M town, honestly. HEM still stinks and ngl I've not reread but my gut and its hard to ignore my gut honestly.

I took no action last night.

HEM, why is Flea scum here?

Like that is hands down the worst take of this entire game.

~M

[Venus and Mars]

My theory is that if scum, HEM wanted to find out if NM had a pain potion or not because he absolutely knew that if he had one, he’d probably use it on me.

This wouldn’t really be suspicious at all to me if his PoE didn’t have 2 players in it who have no reason to kill me.

And I think you’re town, so I see a disconnect between using harmography on me and his PoE.

That said, I 100% believe he did use harmography on me and his results are accurate, which is why his PoE doesn’t make much sense.