Open 853 - PYP X/Y S_S [game over!]

[Titus]

titus just thinks she was shot because she thinks she's right

but i know she's wrong so she probly wasn't shot

Gee my third suspect knows I am wrong. What a shock

[Aristeia]

well i know my own alignment

so i obviously know you're wrong

[Titus]

I did leave open that possibility but your stauch defense of obvscum comes from nowhere and I can't see what it's based on.

[Save The Dragons]

i think that's a little uncharitable i can at least see where ari is coming from

[Titus]

Clue a sister in?

[Save The Dragons]

i mean i believe she believes mathblade wouldn't act like this as scum i think that's a reasonable opinion to have i just disagree with it

[Titus]

i mean i believe she believes mathblade wouldn't act like this as scum i think that's a reasonable opinion to have i just disagree with it

What is that based on? It's one thing to disagree but it needs a basis to do so.

[Save The Dragons]

from today:

I just can't see scum!mathblade walking into this game and deciding to defend scum!hem because he knows I almost never listen to him on anything esp when his logic is total nonsense.

mathblade couldn't win thread control against me as a conftown I don't think he thinks he would be able to win thread control against me as mafia

and the way HEM turned towards voting mathblade was super unaligned imo

from earlier:

harley

mathblade not making sense

is not scum indicative for him

i have argued for so literally days with town!mathblade.

i mean it's not like she's going "here's X game where mathblade did Y" but that wouldn't convince me personally anyway

[MathBlade]

i mean i believe she believes mathblade wouldn't act like this as scum i think that's a reasonable opinion to have i just disagree with it

Why do you disagree with it?

You asked for an example of why I don’t play like this.
I gave it to you and you haven’t responded to that.

[MathBlade]

from today:

I just can't see scum!mathblade walking into this game and deciding to defend scum!hem because he knows I almost never listen to him on anything esp when his logic is total nonsense.

mathblade couldn't win thread control against me as a conftown I don't think he thinks he would be able to win thread control against me as mafia

and the way HEM turned towards voting mathblade was super unaligned imo

from earlier:

harley

mathblade not making sense

is not scum indicative for him

i have argued for so literally days with town!mathblade.

i mean it's not like she's going "here's X game where mathblade did Y" but that wouldn't convince me personally anyway

?? Why are you asking for things that won’t change your mind?

[Save The Dragons]

it's hard for me to really assess what's going on

i believe that maybe you did the thing in the past

it doesn't mean you'd act like that all the time

[Save The Dragons]

i'm not asking ari for mathblade meta

i'm telling titus that it's not out of question that ari is defending you

[Titus]

After 1575, I gave Ari concrete data showing the data matched and Ari didn't address it at all. Instead she pushed Implosion. Ari is literally trying to excuse the absence of aggressive Mathblade behavior by saying it fails solely because she's in the game. She's the only one who can persuade Math to abandon a tunnel. She's the only one who can scare town!Math that he doesn't play to his meta. I can't see town!Ari having that level of hubris.

[Save The Dragons]

my hypo cop check is Bellaphant

[MathBlade]

it's hard for me to really assess what's going on

i believe that maybe you did the thing in the past

it doesn't mean you'd act like that all the time

It’s more what are you going off of to scumread me.

You’re arguing I am scum because of my play. Generic and reasonless

You asked about specific play with the exact scum in question I don’t do the same things I have done here

So by evidence of play I am town

So I don’t follow why you scumread me

[MathBlade]

After 1575, I gave Ari concrete data showing the data matched and Ari didn't address it at all. Instead she pushed Implosion. Ari is literally trying to excuse the absence of aggressive Mathblade behavior by saying it fails solely because she's in the game. She's the only one who can persuade Math to abandon a tunnel. She's the only one who can scare town!Math that he doesn't play to his meta. I can't see town!Ari having that level of hubris.

Yes she has that hubris and earned it on another game

[Save The Dragons]

didn't i literally ask you about this an hour ago

i feel like i've barely expressed why i'm voting you, why do you feel like i'm not scum piling on you

[MathBlade]

didn't i literally ask you about this an hour ago

i feel like i've barely expressed why i'm voting you, why do you feel like i'm not scum piling on you

Yes
And I explained why I don’t scumread you for it
Or why I don’t

It doesn’t mean I don’t try to get you to fix your mistakes

[MathBlade]

Don’t want to explain*

[Save The Dragons]

i don't care about meta and didn't really care, i just wanted to see that you actually had an example

[MathBlade]

i don't care about meta and didn't really care, i just wanted to see that you actually had an example

Okay then what did you learn from me having an example?

[Save The Dragons]

i'm not so sure you're scum i just think that my gut is telling me you are.

i don't think you enter the thread the way you did as town. maybe i'm wrong.

for example you said i would auto be hesitant of you because you smoked me so many times and proceeded to provide 1.5 games where you beat me as scum that took place a while ago

[Save The Dragons]

i don't care about meta and didn't really care, i just wanted to see that you actually had an example

Okay then what did you learn from me having an example?

that you didn't just lie

[Titus]

Yes she has that hubris and earned it on another game

Then why isn't she displaying it?

Why isn't her hubris leading her towards the very meta she cited?

[Aristeia]

After 1575, I gave Ari concrete data showing the data matched and Ari didn't address it at all. Instead she pushed Implosion. Ari is literally trying to excuse the absence of aggressive Mathblade behavior by saying it fails solely because she's in the game. She's the only one who can persuade Math to abandon a tunnel. She's the only one who can scare town!Math that he doesn't play to his meta. I can't see town!Ari having that level of hubris.

like you're telling me

that town!mathblade won't change his mind on a townread ever

therefore he's scum

and I'm telling you, I've literally made town!mathblade change his mind on a townread.