Open 853 - PYP X/Y S_S [game over!]

[Aristeia]

not true there is probably a doctor

unless you're doctor you have no way of knowing this as town, and if you are doctor what the fuck are lecturing me for softing not-doc/rb when you're basically doing the same?

oh you mean i can't have picked doctor/roleblocker and not gotten it?

[MathBlade]

I tolerated your defense of HEM but this defense of Enchant too is just more scum siding lol

Then vote me.

Confirm Enchant as BP town

Lock town unelimmable I am fine with that

you being vanilla town doesn't mean Enchant is BP town

It does because of the missing kill

not true there is probably a doctor

Then said doc would be on Roden if it exists. If doc goes rogue then another no kill happens possibly

But if Roden dies I am going to think doc doesn’t exist

so we lim you - you flip vanilla town

so doc protects roden

roden checks enchant finds he is not ascetic so possibly scum bulletproof

ausuka dies at night

ok what now

Town BP.

Not scum BP.

There was no kill.

So ergo Enchant is conf town and can be reevaluated at elo but not before

[implosion]

MathBlade you both have a plan that depends on the existence of a doctor to save Roden to confirm Enchant as town, and then don't go the extra step and see that the existence of that doctor for that plan means Enchant is not confirmably town....

[Gamma Emerald]

not true there is probably a doctor

unless you're doctor you have no way of knowing this as town, and if you are doctor what the fuck are lecturing me for softing not-doc/rb when you're basically doing the same?

oh you mean i can't have picked doctor/roleblocker and not gotten it?

eh
still think your argument here stinks

[Aristeia]

how about this

i'm doctor

i protected HQ

so now instead of being able to hide and keep ausuka alive indefinitely i have to get shot at night

[MathBlade]

not true there is probably a doctor

unless you're doctor you have no way of knowing this as town, and if you are doctor what the fuck are lecturing me for softing not-doc/rb when you're basically doing the same?

oh you mean i can't have picked doctor/roleblocker and not gotten it?

Then you’d have outed as VT immediately and Enchant = scum and taken him out.

But you’re instead arguing he’s scum BP versus town.

[Gamma Emerald]

then why the fuck are you arguing so hard for math!town?

[implosion]

Oh actually eh i guess it kinida makes sense with 3096. still don't like it as a plan much but

[Aristeia]

then why the fuck are you arguing so hard for math!town?

wtf does me being a doctor have to do with math being town

[Gamma Emerald]

you could have stopped a kill on him
which would be improbable imo but at least there would be an easy litmus test for if that universe makes sense (voting out Titus)

[Aristeia]

i probly stopped a kill on HQ because she's obv town and pick #3

[implosion]

I think scum shooting HQ is a lot more plausible than scum shooting Enchant. But Math being blocked is also still a possibility.

[Aristeia]

yea im sure math who's fucking trying to kill himself to

prove

Enchant is conftown bulletproof is scum

[Dwlee99]

No I'm doctor
VOTE: Enchant

[implosion]

I kind of think in retrospect that playing today in such a way, with like, Ausuka claiming, was a mistake. There's so many roles in this setup that can interfere with kills in principle, trying to get unambiguous info feels like a nightmare.

[MathBlade]

No I'm doctor
VOTE: Enchant

If you’re a doc you’d be voting Ari who hard claimed doc

[Aristeia]

they are joking

[Gamma Emerald]

if dwlee is serious we eject Ari post-haste, then Math next because this whole thing has clearly been a cover to protect her scum partner.

[MathBlade]

I kind of think in retrospect that playing today in such a way, with like, Ausuka claiming, was a mistake. There's so many roles in this setup that can interfere with kills in principle, trying to get unambiguous info feels like a nightmare.

Nope it’s a great play.

We end up with a conf town and know scum shot in Enchant or HQ

If Ari is town doctor who dies then Enchant can be pushed not before.

[MathBlade]

if dwlee is serious we eject Ari post-haste, then Math next because this whole thing has clearly been a cover to protect her scum partner.

Lol I have been begging to be elimmed for like ever

If Ari flips scum I am like conf town and scum shot enchant but yeah we will have elims for days at that point

[implosion]

i wonder if scum-enchant might actually take bp over ascetic cop because of fear of getting vigged lol

[implosion]

I kind of think in retrospect that playing today in such a way, with like, Ausuka claiming, was a mistake. There's so many roles in this setup that can interfere with kills in principle, trying to get unambiguous info feels like a nightmare.

Nope it’s a great play.

We end up with a conf town and know scum shot in Enchant or HQ

If Ari is town doctor who dies then Enchant can be pushed not before.

do you know what conf means

[MathBlade]

if dwlee is serious we eject Ari post-haste, then Math next because this whole thing has clearly been a cover to protect her scum partner.

Yeah it’s a matter of if they are serious

It’s going to be hilarious if Dwlee is one scum and Ari was the other and Titus and I were both bickering because we couldn’t get our way

[implosion]

"one of these two people is 100% cleared town" is a logically near-worthless statement

[implosion]

It’s going to be hilarious if Dwlee is one scum and Ari was the other and Titus and I were both bickering because we couldn’t get our way

i cannot easily express how silly of a scumteam this idea is