LOST (Game Over)

[PookyTheMagicalBear]

actually i guess luke could just be clueless

Tbone mathblade frogster should all die tho

[Dancing Puppets]

luke
DP=taly, johnny=math

Bone
taly dp johnny math

csf
johnny taly math dp

pd
math johnny puppets taly

pooky
math johnny taly dp


TALY 2.5+3+2+0+1 = 8.5
JOHNNY .5+1+3+2+2 = 8.5

i hate u all

since T-Bone is the person polled who had Taly at #1 on his kill wishlist.

I think it's only fair he make the case for why Taly should die.

I am also willing to conditionally vote for Taly on the condition that we eliminate T-Bone immediately tommorrow if Taly flips town.

lololololol

I <3 you so much Pooky.

[Lukewarm]

I made my case on why I thought that Math was town, and I don't think that a single player engaged with it.

I applaud you having the self confidence to suggest a luke+frog scum team though.

[ProfessorDrapion]

oh I just noticed Luke and Tbone both protecting math

Luke Tbone Mathblade Frogster scum team kill them all

No Frog and Math prob TvM from both treatment.

Math or Frog being wolf still makes CSF look bad IMO.

[PookyTheMagicalBear]

r u going to make a case for Taly being scum Luke

[Lukewarm]

Professor Drap, can you please look through your games, and find the one that you lost to scum!CSF.

I know you don't think that it is relevant, but it feel very relevant to me. Multiple people have said that this game is outside of CSF's scum range, but you apparently have an example of a game to prove that that is not the case.

I would like to look at your counter example.

[ProfessorDrapion]

Professor Drap, can you please look through your games, and find the one that you lost to scum!CSF.

I know you don't think that it is relevant, but it feel very relevant to me. Multiple people have said that this game is outside of CSF's scum range, but you apparently have an example of a game to prove that that is not the case.

I would like to look at your counter example.

I don’t wanna out my main.


I also want to point out that in a game I’ve played on another site people kept trying to base things on meta which isn’t accurate.

[Lukewarm]

r u going to make a case for Taly being scum Luke

Probably not.

[T-Bone]

Wow can't believe I got Luke mixed up with Bell what a scumclaim.

Why are you being so defensive? This is like the second post now and no one is even accusing you of anything?

That was a joke and I was self deprecating myself there.

[PookyTheMagicalBear]

T bone are you going to make a case for Taly being scum?

[Dancing Puppets]

actually i guess luke could just be clueless

Tbone mathblade frogster should all die tho

Yeah I really don’t think Luke is scum. But I had a dayvig now, I’d probably use it on T-Bone.

You aren’t going to have the entire scumteam pushing Taly, probably other two scum are laying low.

Oh and T-Bone is probably pocketing RAD here.

[T-Bone]

luke
DP=taly, johnny=math

Bone
taly dp johnny math

csf
johnny taly math dp

pd
math johnny puppets taly

pooky
math johnny taly dp


TALY 2.5+3+2+0+1 = 8.5
JOHNNY .5+1+3+2+2 = 8.5

i hate u all

since T-Bone is the person polled who had Taly at #1 on his kill wishlist.

I think it's only fair he make the case for why Taly should die.

Nah, if you think I'm scum then just let me post whatever. I'm not dancing for you.

[PookyTheMagicalBear]

I think if you are town and you are going to use your voice to advocate for someone to die

it is your basic responsibility to case them and explain why we should kill them and why they are guilty.

that is the bare minimum as a responsible member of the town.

[Lukewarm]

V/LA for 4 days

(Yes, this is me just not wanting to keep existing in Day 1. Hope someone dies, see you guys tomorrow)

[PookyTheMagicalBear]

like it's really amazing to me that Luke/T-Bone decided to get Cephrir to Gladiate Taly but when asked to

case taly as scum

and

advocate for why taly is going to flip scum

they both refuse.

Absolutely astonishing play if you are both town here.

[PookyTheMagicalBear]

I'm curious why you think it's ok to gladiate someone that you can't even produce reasons for wanting to flip.

[Dancing Puppets]

I think if you are town and you are going to use your voice to advocate for someone to die

it is your basic responsibility to case them and explain why we should kill them and why they are guilty.

that is the bare minimum as a responsible member of the town.

+1

You too Luke. Tell us why Taly is scum here.

Both of you keep saying you want this day to end, so help us out here please.

[T-Bone]

I'm really over the both of you trying to tell me what to do tbh.

That I read Ceph as likely town and that I don't Taly is good enough for me. I'm not informed I don't know either of their alignments. I will vote Ceph also just to end the day because I think a flip at a chance for scum is more important than not taking that chance.

You both have said over and over that you don't agree. Your preferences have been noted. You're pretending that Ceph didn't say "choose between four players" as if Taly was my top scum read or something. Taly wasn't, Taly existed in the middle for me. Now my choice is between Taly and Ceph or doing nothing, and I think nothing is the proscum move. You don't so AGAIN your preferences are noted.

If you think I'm scum let me be scum in peace.

[Lukewarm]

like it's really amazing to me that Luke/T-Bone decided to get Cephrir to Gladiate Taly but when asked to

case taly as scum

and

advocate for why taly is going to flip scum

they both refuse.

Absolutely astonishing play if you are both town here.

My exact answer to Ceph was that I town read johnny and math.

So given the choices he presented, it would have to be between Taly and DP.

I then also told him that I would prefer he target frog over all of them.

[Dancing Puppets]

like it's really amazing to me that Luke/T-Bone decided to get Cephrir to Gladiate Taly but when asked to

case taly as scum

and

advocate for why taly is going to flip scum

they both refuse.

Absolutely astonishing play if you are both town here.

I guess it’s possible Luke could be scum but I’m more getting deeply tunnelled town vibes, could obviously be wrong though. \_0_/

[T-Bone]

Obviously Luke when presented those choices we should have refused to participate. That's ultimately what the argument is. Demanding we go back in time and tell Ceph to choose no one.

[Lukewarm]

That might not be clear

I town read Johnny and Math, so not those two

My main thought on Taly since we started wagoning her, was that she claimed that she was solely a neighbor and that she thought it was a good role.

I got those "would scum really lock into such a weak claim" vibes.

I asked Bell if her or toog had alraedy claimed in their hood (thereby stoping her from being able to fake claim) but I don't think I got an answer

Ceph, if you are leaning taly, can we wait to hear this answer from Bell?

My main thought on Taly since we started wagoning her, was that she claimed that she was solely a neighbor and that she thought it was a good role.

I got those "would scum really lock into such a weak claim" vibes.

I asked Bell if her or toog had alraedy claimed in their hood (thereby stoping her from being able to fake claim) but I don't think I got an answer

Ceph, if you are leaning taly, can we wait to hear this answer from Bell?

If not, then carry on.

ughhh but luuuuke i wanna blow shit up and end this cancerous day

Then I vote Puppets

Change my rank to

Puppets>Taly>Johnny=Math

But also Frog over all of them

lol

[Bell]

1. Taly said they see two narratives for Pooky. They can’t read enchant.
Asked if I could understand or empathize with Tbone’s positions.
Stated wanting to get my reads with less noise and how it was a waste not to use the PT.
2. Thought I was posturing when I told them there was a subset of players that would probably hard town read me.
3. Didn’t like that there were two wagons and they were both slow to topple. Took the pace of the game into account.
Didn’t like BBT’s posting but left a bookmark there.
4. They asked me why I wasn’t actively trying to kill them if i couldn’t read them/why I wasn’t pressuring them.
5. They asked if they wanted a dead neighborhood.
6. Wrote a post about how they wanted to approach me and that they felt I was rejecting them. They weren’t wrong.
7. Game2fast cmlt. Dunn dropped for Mason push. Thought Luke’s positioning felt opportunistic but hedged.

That’s it pretty much.

[Taly]

I feel like a bargaining chip wtf

[T-Bone]

Ceph from 12 hours ago. Do not gladiate anyone.