LOST (Game Over)

[BlueBloodedToffee]

Like, if OTH really wants to explain it then I can't really stop them can I?

[Dancing Puppets]

I honestly don’t know what to make of you, other than our reads are so diametrically different.

We agree on Enchant if you really want to start there.

But yeah we see the game in completely different ways, I think that much is obvious. Whether you are also town or not and vise versa we won't know until the game is over, so like, idk what you want to do about it in the meantime? I feel like I've had good reads so far and so until I start having incorrect reads I'm gonna keep them where they are sans new information.

For what it's worth I know you've said something to the effect of "I could be in someone's pocket" a few times, and I think if that's true it's either OTH or CSF that has pocketed you. I don't know if that helps, I know you have your reasons for why you said you have your reads.

I think I thought that about Frog but was obviously very wrong on that. Sure someone could possibly be pocketing me but I have no clue whom.

If anyone is it’s for certain not OtH and seriously doubt CSF is either.

[Cat Scratch Fever]

Barely present = scummy?

They were all barely present + there were other reasons to scumread math/roden. If you're curious about why, you can go back to read as i'm not going to go into depth on why each were scumread.

Mala i think her contributions tend to be better as town, that roguelikes mini normal being a notable exception. Though she was also scumread for tone i believe

I'm just saying as someone who was active in the thread, i didn't think those klick votes were weird.

[BlueBloodedToffee]

Of course not, you're on just as many wagons as Klick (except for Ceph I believe). It's not just the votes either, there is literally no build up or explanation for any of them.

[Dancing Puppets]

So?

It’s hard not to think you’re intentionally being obtuse.

[Bellaphant]

Just gone back to check the Roden thing - we needed wagons Ans I think the game state was there were a few people who were 'shrug!scum' and Roden was one of them. Think Johnny and enchant were also in that pool.

[Cat Scratch Fever]

@bbt, all right agree to disagree. I still don't think you're particularly interested in getting the right answer if you're not interested in hearing why you're scumreads (dancing puppets) may be town

[T-Bone]

I honestly don’t know what to make of you, other than our reads are so diametrically different.

We agree on Enchant if you really want to start there.

But yeah we see the game in completely different ways, I think that much is obvious. Whether you are also town or not and vise versa we won't know until the game is over, so like, idk what you want to do about it in the meantime? I feel like I've had good reads so far and so until I start having incorrect reads I'm gonna keep them where they are sans new information.

For what it's worth I know you've said something to the effect of "I could be in someone's pocket" a few times, and I think if that's true it's either OTH or CSF that has pocketed you. I don't know if that helps, I know you have your reasons for why you said you have your reads.

I think I thought that about Frog but was obviously very wrong on that. Sure someone could possibly be pocketing me but I have no clue whom.

If anyone is it’s for certain not OtH and seriously doubt CSF is either.

Okay then disregard that. Do you want to do anything about Enchant? Mutual read.

[Lukewarm]

@oth, tell me why. Also, I misread the bit in Luke's case about puppets, that wasn't in the conclusion I drew.

..........

[Dancing Puppets]

I honestly don’t know what to make of you, other than our reads are so diametrically different.

We agree on Enchant if you really want to start there.

But yeah we see the game in completely different ways, I think that much is obvious. Whether you are also town or not and vise versa we won't know until the game is over, so like, idk what you want to do about it in the meantime? I feel like I've had good reads so far and so until I start having incorrect reads I'm gonna keep them where they are sans new information.

For what it's worth I know you've said something to the effect of "I could be in someone's pocket" a few times, and I think if that's true it's either OTH or CSF that has pocketed you. I don't know if that helps, I know you have your reasons for why you said you have your reads.

I think I thought that about Frog but was obviously very wrong on that. Sure someone could possibly be pocketing me but I have no clue whom.

If anyone is it’s for certain not OtH and seriously doubt CSF is either.

Okay then disregard that. Do you want to do anything about Enchant? Mutual read.

I’m already voting them.

[Off The Hook]

@RCE

what were your reasons for saying no yeet was bad yesterday?

~GE

I’ll wait for gamma to pick it up then. Just for posterity I’m treating you both as one poster. I don’t do the differing hydra reads thing.

gamma wants to know bcuz apparently u used similar wording to luke
gamma also says shes not gonna come running everytime u call

Tell Gamma this is why we can’t be best friends.

okay and? I do socialize here but I don’t try to be familiar with everyone, certain events have made it impossible for me to consider everyone on MS a friend.

~GE

[T-Bone]

VOTE: Enchant

[Off The Hook]

C&G's post restriction sounds fake as fuck at this point

I just don't get why they'd make it up in the first place, and that's the only reason I don't want to hard push them atm

I mean if they could self destruct then we just have to give them a d5 deadline to get themselves modkilled because their role is horrible for late game

They claimed that their posting restriction was only for Day 1, and that they have no restriction any longer.

So why do they still feel like a wet towel?

~GE

[Off The Hook]

so if im reading this right
based on this numbers my slot Klick and bell had been going back and forth between scum null and town
what happened with this reads my slot haven't even posted much

the first one is like klick and bell red
2nd one is both null
3rd one is klick red and bell green
then you move klick 1 up after

I wanna TR this but I have a gut feeling it’s a bad idea

~GE

[Off The Hook]

I’m back after breaking some stuff down for marci. So let me break this down for everyone:

DP is doing other sorting. BBT is not. That’s why him pushing this line of logic is bad. He is absolutely MADDENED by the scumreads being based on such a point and is tunnel-visioned on smearing as many others as possible.

~GE

That just isn't true, but sure. I can only respond to things as I am here, there will be a ton of things I have missed this game and I just have to accept that.

Right now, I see people pushing me based on very poor reasons and I have every right to call it out. At the very best it's a push from lazy town and at the worst it's an easy push for scum.

Do you have thoughts on other slots?

~GE

[Off The Hook]

i haven't seen a modkill for being unable to find someone to replace the slot since like 2010 lol

I’ve only seen it happen on my homesite

~GE

[Cytosine and Guanine]

We're kind of behind.
Can any of you help catch us up?
-Guanine

[Off The Hook]

VOTE: Mislim Bait

Hmm, Klick was good at explaining town reads but not so much his scum reads.

I'm happy with my vote.

This engagement looks solid
I’ll wait to be caught up before moving our vote but I actually feel like giving BBT a chance here

~GE

[MalcolmTucker]

Massively behind and another busy day tomorrow, will be more active Friday, anything I should catch up on?

[Off The Hook]

Wanted to see who will be pissed off and start white knighing hard.

I think regardless of Taly alignment, mafia white knighting her. It's like 99%.
Will soon vote one of these, need to think which one though.

Does anyone think this could seriously be a town thought?

I have my reservations about it, but Enchant needs to actually do something with it first

~GE

[Off The Hook]

Yeah, your bad post made me ISO your predecessor and then I'll look into what you have done so far as well.

You worried?

You're obviously nitpicking with a red lens because you voted me first before isoing klick

I understand MLB’s feelings here a bit but BBT’s progression also feels logical.

~GE

[Off The Hook]

I still hate how I'm suddenly Muslim Bait after being away for a while gdi

There was a pseudo-purge of problematic usernames a few months ago I believe, it probably got hit with that

~GE

[Off The Hook]

You did go overboard because you literally said 'Is there any reason we shouldn't use this VCA to speed elim Taly?'

If a speed elim is not going overboard, what is?

thats a question to get more context

Could have phrased it better then

~GE

[Off The Hook]

enchant gets a word count buff everytime he talks about something nai or mechanic.
mala had this idgaf energy but suddenly went full caps screaming bloody hell after getting wagoned which sounds fake

Do you remember why Mala was screaming caps?

~GE

[Off The Hook]

Naked vote again.

Klick was pretty bad at explaining any of his scum reads or his votes but was more than happy to elaborate on town reads. Again, easy option for scum.

The ceph 180 is probably the most interesting but idk if it's worth a vote by itself

The other votes were on scummy people imo. Corwin (math slot), Roden, and mala were barely present in the game.

Why does barely present = scummy? That’s how this post reads.
~GE