LOST (Game Over)

[Taly]

sure I love hugs

[butterflies]

It's possible but

they did throw in a null-read there at one point.

I don't think it's beyond Bella to have townread a potential teammate.

Why does that rule out that she was buddying me?

This post? I do agree it doesn’t really make logical sense. If Bella was tr scum!CSF than it clearly would rule out a pocket obviously.

[butterflies]

nancy

if i became your +1 vote this dayphase, where would we vote?

I’m still going back and forth on that. Rn, I’m just trying to get to the bottom of this Johnny/CSF thing. I’m trusting Pooky’s reads and want to check some stuff out.

[JohnnyFarrar]

I still think Johnny is scum >_<

I concede BBT is probably town, i forgot BBT and Bella had a that weird conversation about game pace

Starting at this post and for basically that whole page. I don't know your definition of "wooden" but this ish is 100% tone deaf with a side of eneffectual pushing

[JohnnyFarrar]

Yes but there’s no reason for you not to ask Pooky that question since he had the same read. Why don’t you want to know his opinion?

Because I'm trying to sort YOU ya dink, pooky is outta the poe for today

[JohnnyFarrar]

I still think Johnny is scum >_<

I concede BBT is probably town, i forgot BBT and Bella had a that weird conversation about game pace

Starting at this post and for basically that whole page. I don't know your definition of "wooden" but this ish is 100% tone deaf with a side of eneffectual pushing

Ebwop I guess that whole page and onto the next one is more accurate

[butterflies]

Did anything happen in the PT to reaffirm the read?

It was better, but no. They just picked up a bit in posting.
If you believe in town slips (I don't), they forgot Roden claimed mason.
It'd be funny if Bella and Taly are both town that forgot or didn't see Roden claim.

I think Bella is wolf that didn't see it thus I was hoping no one would mention about her posts so she could respond to the one I gave to them so I can get a better read on them.
Taly is def town, either forgot about them being the mason or forgot about masons entirely.

This is stupid

There’s 5 scum
Surely scum would keep a log of who claims what

Math spewed Bella wolf and Taly town. How did I miss this?

[Cat Scratch Fever]

It's possible but

they did throw in a null-read there at one point.

I don't think it's beyond Bella to have townread a potential teammate.

Why does that rule out that she was buddying me?

This post? I do agree it doesn’t really make logical sense. If Bella was tr scum!CSF than it clearly would rule out a pocket obviously.

What doesn't make sense?

[Cat Scratch Fever]

I still think Johnny is scum >_<

I concede BBT is probably town, i forgot BBT and Bella had a that weird conversation about game pace

Starting at this post and for basically that whole page. I don't know your definition of "wooden" but this ish is 100% tone deaf with a side of eneffectual pushing

What is tone deaf? What do you think I'm missing?

[butterflies]

I still think Johnny is scum >_<

I concede BBT is probably town, i forgot BBT and Bella had a that weird conversation about game pace

Starting at this post and for basically that whole page. I don't know your definition of "wooden" but this ish is 100% tone deaf with a side of eneffectual pushing

Ebwop I guess that whole page and onto the next one is more accurate

CSF isn’t a player I have extremely confident meta reads on, like I do with OtH, Taly, Dwlee, Pooky and even RCE. I’m trying to re-ISO both Math and Bella.

[butterflies]

It's possible but

they did throw in a null-read there at one point.

I don't think it's beyond Bella to have townread a potential teammate.

Why does that rule out that she was buddying me?

This post? I do agree it doesn’t really make logical sense. If Bella was tr scum!CSF than it clearly would rule out a pocket obviously.

What doesn't make sense?

Bella can’t pocket you if you’re her buddy.

[Taly]

i have experience with

gamma

and

marci

and im weary of that slot

so how are you meta-reading

OTH

as town,

nancy

?

[Cat Scratch Fever]

Bella can’t pocket you if you’re her buddy.

Malcolm was saying that Bella was not pocketing me because she wasn't townreading me early Day 1.

My point was simply that because Bella did not townread me in the beginning of Day 1 does not mean she was not pocketing me for the rest of the game.

[butterflies]

i have experience with

gamma

and

marci

and im weary of that slot

so how are you meta-reading

OTH

as town,

nancy

?

Flea really hasn’t read anything but both me and Titus were hard tr that slot from the getgo.


I’ve given a lot of reasons but the most confident one is that Marci has an extremely distinctive alignment-based playstyle. Inviticus closely resembles HDP (scum) , where as her posting here closely resembles OMB (town).

[Taly]

It'd be funny if Bella and Taly are both town that forgot or didn't see Roden claim.

also this is completely irrelevant but i wasnt... thinking clearly, when i forgot

roden's

alignment in

bell's

PT.

there were reasons i went VLA.

pedit

could you link

nancy

?

[JohnnyFarrar]

What is tone deaf? What do you think I'm missing?

Like I don't think I've been very interesting for the last week or so in this game, so jumping in to shade me and not saying *anything* about Mal, Mislim, or Rad hits me as tone deaf if I'm being optimistic. If I weren't also worried about my own tendency to omgus I might call it scum motivated

[butterflies]

Bella can’t pocket you if you’re her buddy.

Malcolm was saying that Bella was not pocketing me because she wasn't townreading me early Day 1.

My point was simply that because Bella did not townread me in the beginning of Day 1 does not mean she was not pocketing me for the rest of the game.

That’s fair. I actually find most pockets tend to come from scum who initially pushes you than reverses it, as opposed to players tr you right out of the gate. That’s definitely been my experience anyway and it works really well too because it looks very similar to town re-evaluating their read on you.

[butterflies]

It'd be funny if Bella and Taly are both town that forgot or didn't see Roden claim.

also this is completely irrelevant but i wasnt... thinking clearly, when i forgot

roden's

alignment in

bell's

PT.

there were reasons i went VLA.

pedit

could you link

nancy

?

I already did that Taly. It’s probably in an early DP post.

[Cat Scratch Fever]

What is tone deaf? What do you think I'm missing?

Like I don't think I've been very interesting for the last week or so in this game, so jumping in to shade me and

not saying *anything* about Mal, Mislim, or Rad hits me as tone deaf if I'm being optimistic.

If I weren't also worried about my own tendency to omgus I might call it scum motivated

That's fair

I think Mislim Bait is town. Haven't had time to reread Malcolm or Rad.

[Cat Scratch Fever]

But I've also been lowkey pushing you since day 1 >_> it's not like this push is completely out of left field or something

[JohnnyFarrar]

Well right, but there was a whole discussion between the three of them like 8 posts prior

[Taly]

noted

*flops onto nancy*

[butterflies]

https://forum.mafiascum.net/viewtopic.p ... B%5D=35197

I dare anyone to tell me this isn’t town!Marci.

I will check if I linked anything else.

@Taly

[JohnnyFarrar]

But I've also been lowkey pushing you since day 1 >_> it's not like this push is completely out of left field or something

So I literally did this exact thing as scum in the game I just won. Picked someone and pushed them for 3 full days without really trying to gain momentum. That's the *ineffectual pushing* I was referencing earlier

[Cat Scratch Fever]

Well right, but there was a whole discussion between the three of them like 8 posts prior

I did pick Malcolm over BBT to talk to for a reason. Without having reread anything, I think Rad is probably town though their readslist with the Roden null read and butterchurn townlean gives me pause (like if one of those is town, the other should be town too?)

Otherwise I've been kind of skimming since like yesterDay