yeah I mean, how would it help us to claim? cause if people say the night they're good on... scum can plan their kills around that... and claiming cop or doc.. scum knowing the numbers could just balance it out so it's more even.. I see no benefit in claiming
now the "cop" we do have... I don't don't trust it at all, like, until goldfish does something towny, they're chilling in the pool of people i sr
I think we shouldn’t riush the day again so we get maximum info.
Spoiler:
Andante was extremely upset about the whole interaction with Frog and thinks also that Frog might have not realized the unsigned posts were mine. So unless he decies to continue to escalate the situation with continued usage of incendiary words, she would much prefer that the whole entire thing be dropped because she really doesn’t want to continue to play if she has to continue to deal with it.
Imo, in previous game where i replaced, mafia indeed claimed "Town" check on teammate. It got crushed later on, because there was strong poe of 3 people remaining.
So i think, liming other cop claim is not in our benefit, even if possibility him being maf exist.
In post 788, Bellaphant wrote:@fun times, you forgot 'i copped one of the few obv!town'.
Like....I can understand copping a person you were unsure on/wouldn't be able to read but that would be enchant/not mad/even penguin power for me, just because of playstyle.
Oh? Link/quote? I don’t recall?
~Nancy btw
Sorry, this was sarcasm - I just really don't like the choice.
In post 780, Bellaphant wrote:@frog, finding the use of language a little bit emotional: there must be better words than abusive And gaslit. Can we tone it down a little? Like, I'm not even parsing the conversation and these touch paper words aren't helpful
“Touch paper”?
I probably understand the meaning of this less due to the existence of the phrase “touch grass”
Emotive I guess. The content doesn't seem like frog actually wants to upset the hydra, but the words are going to do that. Frogs response to everything seems really overblown but I'm not sure if scum would make this much noise?
In post 806, PenguinPower wrote:Also we have two cops so do you trust one and not the other?
I mean, both are alive..
how bad of an idea is it to yeet goldfish, then if goldfish is town, we have an IC, and if scum, well, yeah scum down
Only one was claimed D1.
I’m no Jinglebingle so I can’t be certain as to the mechanics, but that doesn’t feel like a good trade rn.
I'm not massively opposed to this? If goldfish is scum, which isn't out of possibility, then somnus is either town, or also scum. If goldfish is town, then as fun times says, we still have an ic. It feels harsh to say what have we lost.
In post 788, Bellaphant wrote:@fun times, you forgot 'i copped one of the few obv!town'.
Like....I can understand copping a person you were unsure on/wouldn't be able to read but that would be enchant/not mad/even penguin power for me, just because of playstyle.
Oh? Link/quote? I don’t recall?
~Nancy btw
Sorry, this was sarcasm - I just really don't like the choice.
Yeah, Idk why goldfish would pick him specifically but if she is a cop, having Somnus as an IC this early would just put a target on him. I think he’s very likely town anyway regardless of what goldfish is.
In post 806, PenguinPower wrote:Also we have two cops so do you trust one and not the other?
I mean, both are alive..
how bad of an idea is it to yeet goldfish, then if goldfish is town, we have an IC, and if scum, well, yeah scum down
Only one was claimed D1.
I’m no Jinglebingle so I can’t be certain as to the mechanics, but that doesn’t feel like a good trade rn.
I'm not massively opposed to this? If goldfish is scum, which isn't out of possibility, then somnus is either town, or also scum. If goldfish is town, then as fun times says, we still have an ic. It feels harsh to say what have we lost.
Oh really? You really think it’s likely that hypothetical scum!goldfish fakes inno on her buddy here? Their interactions didn’t really look aligned to me.
In post 780, Bellaphant wrote:@frog, finding the use of language a little bit emotional: there must be better words than abusive And gaslit. Can we tone it down a little? Like, I'm not even parsing the conversation and these touch paper words aren't helpful
“Touch paper”?
I probably understand the meaning of this less due to the existence of the phrase “touch grass”
Emotive I guess. The content doesn't seem like frog actually wants to upset the hydra, but the words are going to do that. Frogs response to everything seems really overblown but I'm not sure if scum would make this much noise?
I hesitate to respond to this at all because Andante is so extremely upset and it’s also emotionally affecting me as well but they’re are a couple of things that really aren’t making a whole lot of sense to me.
How is Frog sr us and townlocking Gamma for townclearing us? Also why is he voting Enchant for voting us if he still thinks we’re scum here? Is any of that making sense to anyone?
Do you mean the "you read me correctly previously games" thing? Ok so let me explain this and also why meta is bad at the same time.
A: I don't know your alignment so why would this be a good point for anyone except yourself if you are actually town here? For all we know you could be scum and i actually read you correctly. And even if i did read you wrongly, so what? Why couldn't i also be town that read you wrongly for once?
B: Sometimes people just play differently. There is a reason why i played a game once and people called me "scum for meta" and i was literally just town but had changed my playstyle drastically for that one game. Meta is garbage and you use that as the main point for your arguments i'm not going to bother. If you want an recent example, even Alianna was called "scum for meta" yesterday and they were town.
I think mechanically, the argument to lim Goldfish is sound.
If they are mafia then that's a win.
If they are town that's unfortunate because we didn't hit scum, but they are town that already had an check. Meaning we won't lose any more town power. And if we have N2 doctor they can protect an confirmed town!Somnus that night. And even if we don't have an doctor for that night, mafia doesn't know that. So Somnus would likely not die anyway since any doctor worth their salt should be protecting our only conf!town in that instance.
Of course it would be better if Goldfish was actually an townread, then i could trust their results. But i don't really see them as a very believable townie with the low content they have currently.
